
Will | Person Directed To Make Payments From A Particular Fund But Not Out Of The Entire Estate Is Not Executor: Bombay High Court
Live LawThe Bombay High Court recently observed that when directed to make payments from a particular fund in a Will, a person cannot be deemed an executor of the Will by implication if they lack the general power to receive and pay from the entire estate of the deceased. Justice Manish Pitale stated – “even when a person is directed to make certain payments out of a particular fund but not out of the general estate, it cannot be said that such a person has been appointed as an executor by implication.” The court was dealing with a petition filed by one Dimple Rakesh Doshi seeking Letters of Administration with Will annexed concerning a Will dated May 29, 2022. The court relied on various precedents such as the Calcutta High Court judgment in Nimai Charan Chatterjee v. Lakshmi Narayan Chatterjee which gave the tests applied for ascertaining whether a person has been appointed as an executor. The court observed that even when directed to make payments from a specific fund, a person cannot be deemed an executor by implication if they lack the general power to receive and pay from the estate.
History of this topic

Probate Not Necessary For Wills Executed By Indian Christians And Muhammadans After State Amendment To Indian Succession Act: Kerala HC
Live Law
Probate Proceedings End With Death Of Will's Executor, Substitution Of Legal Heirs Not Permissible: Patna High Court
Live Law
Muslim Person's Power To Dispose Property By Will Limited For Benefit Of Heirs: Kerala High Court Explains Scope
Live Law
Acceptability Of A 'Will' In Financial Institutions: Problems And Possible Solutions
Live Law
No restriction on executor of Will also being a beneficiary under it
Live MintDiscover Related

















![[Muslim Law] Daughter As Legal Heir Cannot Be Excluded From Revenue Documents Without Recording Valid Reasons: J&K High Court](https://www.livelaw.in/h-upload/2023/10/29/500784-466227-justice-javed-iqbal-wani.jpg)

























![[MV Act] Family Pension Paid To Deceased's Family Can't Be Deducted While Calculating Compensation: Delhi High Court](https://www.livelaw.in/h-upload/2021/06/11/394837-motor-vehicle-accident-tribunal.jpg)

