
What defines a heartbeat? Judge hears arguments in South Carolina abortion case
Associated PressCOLUMBIA, S.C. — South Carolina’s ban on abortions after roughly six weeks, before many women know they are pregnant, returned to court Thursday with Planned Parenthood and the state arguing over what could be two different ways to define a heartbeat in the law. Even the state Supreme Court justices who upheld the new law in August noted there appeared to be two definitions of “fetal heartbeat” ending the window in which someone could seek an abortion. Lawyers for the state are turning Planned Parenthood’s argument on its head by arguing that the organization said over 300 times that the law bans abortions after six weeks, during a successful challenge that caused the General Assembly to alter the law and led to the second unsuccessful challenge. “They are just trying to understand it.” South Carolina’s law is written slightly differently from any other state’s with a similarly timed ban, and minor differences in punctuation are what means the ban doesn’t kick in until the chambers and valves of the heart come together, Eastling argued.
History of this topic

When does a heartbeat start? South Carolina Supreme Court again takes up abortion issue
Associated Press
Judge says South Carolina can enforce 6-week abortion ban amid dispute over when a heartbeat begins
Associated Press
'Something needs to change.' Woman denied abortion in South Carolina challenges ban
NPR
'Want us to tell doctors to stop fetal heart?' SC remark in abortion hearing
Hindustan Times
South Carolina abortion ban with unclear ‘fetal heartbeat’ definition creates confusion, doctors say
Associated Press
Newly all-male South Carolina Supreme Court scrutinizes abortion ban months after tossing one out
Associated Press
South Carolina Republicans advance new abortion restrictions
Associated Press
South Carolina Supreme Court strikes down state abortion ban
LA Times
The misleading echo of a heartbeat
Live Mint
Abortion floor debate splits South Carolina Republicans
Associated Press
EXPLAINER: Abortion landscape under state ‘heartbeat’ laws
Associated Press
Appeals court upholds ruling blocking SC abortion law
Associated Press
Wisconsin GOP looks to block abortions if heartbeat detected
Associated Press
US appeals court to rehear Tennessee abortion ban argument
Associated Press
The Texas abortion ban hinges on 'fetal heartbeat.' Doctors call that misleading
NPR
South Carolina gov: Abortion order ‘oversteps’ federal power
Associated Press
The Lawmakers Behind ‘Fetal Heartbeat’ Abortion Bans Are Lying To You
Huff Post
Texas governor signs ‘heartbeat’ abortion ban into law
CNN
‘Fetal heartbeat’ in abortion laws taps emotion, not science
Associated Press
Appeals judges skeptical about reinstating NC abortion ban
Associated Press
South Carolina Judge Says Abortions Can Continue During Lawsuit
Huff Post
South Carolina judge: Abortions to continue during lawsuit
Associated Press
New SC abortion law remains on hold under judge’s order
Associated Press
South Carolina abortion law suspended 1 day after passage
Associated Press
US judge suspends South Carolina’s new abortion law
Al Jazeera
Court Temporarily Blocks South Carolina Heartbeat Abortion Ban
NPR
South Carolina governor awaits bill banning most abortions
The Independent
South Carolina governor signs abortion ban; Planned Parenthood sues
LA Times
S. Carolina House committee approves ban on most abortions
Associated Press
‘Here we go again': Judge blocks Mississippi abortion ban
Associated Press
For Victims Of Reproductive Coercion Like Me, 'Heartbeat' Abortion Laws Could Be A Death Sentence
Huff Post
The Lawmakers Behind 'Fetal Heartbeat' Abortion Bans Are Lying To You
Huff Post
Abortion laws in the US: Here are all the states pushing to restrict access
CNN
Louisiana ‘heartbeat’ abortion ban nearing final passage
Associated Press
Louisiana ‘heartbeat’ abortion ban nearing final passage
Associated Press
'Heartbeat' Bills Get the Science of Fetal Heartbeats All Wrong
Wired
More ‘heartbeat’ abortion bans advancing in South, Midwest
Associated Press
Georgia's Governor Signs 'Fetal Heartbeat' Abortion Law
NPR
Lawyers: Mississippi making abortion ‘virtually unavailable’
Associated Press
Correction: Abortion-Ohio story
Associated Press
Abortion bills: ‘Heartbeat’ ban signed into law by Ohio governor
CNN
Abortion-rights group sues Mississippi over ‘heartbeat’ law
Associated Press
Mississippi governor signs ‘heartbeat’ abortion law
Associated Press
US group to sue over strict Mississippi ‘heartbeat’ abortion law
Al Jazeera
Mississippi governor signs law banning most abortions once a heartbeat can be detected
LA Times
Georgia 'heartbeat' law: State passes bill banning abortions before many women know they are pregnant
The Independent
Tennessee advances bill banning fetal heartbeat abortion
Associated Press
Kentucky attorney general warns abortion bill is unlawful
Associated Press
Judge declares Iowa fetal heartbeat law unconstitutional
Associated PressDiscover Related














































