Thackeray-Shinde row: Supreme Court to decide later on referring pleas to 7-judge Bench
The HinduThe Supreme Court on Friday, February 17, 2023, decided to hear the merits of a bitter political battle between rivals, Maharashtra Chief Minister Eknath Shinde and his predecessor Uddhav Thackeray, for control over Shiv Sena and not digress from the factual aspects of the dispute for now by referring to a seven-judge Bench a legal question based on a 2016 judgment. During the hearing of the case, Mr. Thackeray’s camp had questioned the correctness of a legal principle laid down by a Constitution Bench in Nabam Rebia case in 2016 that a Speaker facing a notice of resolution for his removal cannot decide disqualification proceedings against legislators under the anti-defection law without first clearing his name. Reading out the short order, Chief Justice Chandrachud said the question of reference to a larger Bench cannot be “isolated or divorced” from the facts of Shinde-Thackeray quarrel. In the above backdrop, the issue whether the reference of the decision in the Nabam Rebia judgment to a larger Bench is warranted would be determined together with the merits of the case,” Chief Justice Chandrachud pronounced the order for the Bench.