
WB Coal Scam Probe-'CBI Cannot March Army Into State To Investigate Offence In Supersession Of State Police': Mukul Rohatgi Tells SC
Live LawThe Supreme Court on Wednesday commenced the hearing on the challenge to the order of the Calcutta High Court whereby it allowed the CBI to investigate a case pertaining to illegal mining and transportation of coal through Railways in West Bengal, without the State's consent. In an appeal preferred by CBI, a Division Bench of the High Court stayed the Single Judge's order and allowed CBI to investigate the case without any hindrance. He indicated the relevant clause of the Letters Patent of the Chartered High Courts- ' No appeal from High Court exercising original jurisdiction' - which stipulates that there shall be no appeal to the High Courts at Madras, Bombay and Bengal from any sentence or order passed or made in any criminal trial before the Court of original criminal jurisdiction which may be constituted by one or more Judges of the said High Court. Perusing the decision in Fauji's case, Justice Chandrachud noted but whether the criminal jurisdiction relates to section 482 of the CrPC or Article 226, no LPA would lie – "They even gave the example that in the state of UP, if a plea for anticipatory bail under 226 is not entertained, there will be no LPA ".
History of this topic

Coal Scam: Delhi High Court Seeks CBI’s Response On Appeal By Former Coal Secretary HC Gupta, IAS KS Kropha Against 3-Yrs-Sentence
Live Law
Coal Block Case: Delhi High Court Quashes PMLA Case Against EMTA Coal After CBI Files Closure Report In 2015 FIR
Live Law
Coal scam case: CBI raids five locations in Kolkata, Bengal law minister's premises in Asansol
India TV News
Bengal coal scam case: ED summons eight IPS officers to Delhi next week
India TV News
West Bengal Coal Scam- Delhi High Court Seeks ED's Response On Inspector's Plea Challenging Trial Court Summons In Money Laundering Case
Live Law
Coal Scam- Enforcement Directorate Moves Delhi High Court Seeking Quashing Of Notices Issued To It's Officials By West Bengal Police
Live Law![Mukul Rohatgi Vs SG Tushar Mehta On CBI 's Jurisdiction In West Bengal [Courtroom Exchange In Coal scam Case Before SC]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Mukul Rohatgi Vs SG Tushar Mehta On CBI 's Jurisdiction In West Bengal [Courtroom Exchange In Coal scam Case Before SC]
Live Law
West Bengal Coal Mining Case: Supreme Court Grants Interim Protection to Anup Majee
Live Law
"We Are Not Concerned With Further Developments, We Will Consider Whether Appeal Will Lie To DB Against SB Order?" SC On WB Coal Scam Probe
Live Law
Coal Scam: SC Grants 4 Weeks' Time To CBI For Filing Fresh Status Report, RS Cheema To Continue As Spl.PP
Live Law
PNB scam: Accused Hemant Bhatt challenges PMLA court's jurisdiction, seeks transfer of case to CBI court
Firstpost
CBI informs Supreme Court that it has probed 33 coal scam cases during 2006-2009
Firstpost
Coal scam: SC forms SIT to probe ex-CBI chief Ranjit Sinha for abuse of authority
India TV News
Ranjit Sinha tried to influence coal scam probe : SC panel
Live Law
Coalscam: CBI chief Ranjit Sinha ordered closure of case, investigator tells court
Firstpost
Special CBI Court delivers first conviction in coal black allocation scam, convicts JIPL and Directors
Live Law
Special CBI Court delivers first conviction in coal black allocation scam, convicts JIPL and Directors
Live Law
Coal scam: SC-appointed team seeks visitors' record of Ranjit Sinha's official residence
India TV News
Coal scam: SC seeks CBI, ED response on probe Aditya Birla Group's for alleged hawala transactions
Firstpost
Coal scam: Court fixes 10 July for consideration of CBI's report
Firstpost
Coal scam: Court to consider CBI's supplementary report on 8 May
Firstpost
CBI registers a fresh case in coal scam
India TV News
Court asks CBI to further probe coal scam case
India TV News
Coal scam: CBI files revised closure report in KM Birla case
India TV News
Coal scam case: Court slams CBI director, says closure report approved by him lacks logic
India TV News
SC to pronounce verdict on Coal block allocation on Monday
India TV News
CBI case against Lalu confidante in coal block allocation
India TV News
CBI probing role of more firms in coal scam
The Hindu
Bhushan seeks CVC opinion on coal scam cases
The Hindu
CBI registers two fresh cases in coal scam
India TV News
Coalgate: CBI to file status report in SC tomorrow
India TV News
Coal scam: Centre's nod not needed in court-monitored probe, says SC
Firstpost
Coalgate: CBI to file status report in SC today with Birla probe details
Firstpost
CBI likely to file status report in coal scam on Oct. 22
The Hindu
CBI likely to file status report in coal scam on Oct 22
India TV News
CBI likely to start filing charge sheets in coal scam
India TV News
Coal block scam: SC allows CBI to share final probe report with lawyers
Firstpost
Coal Scam: SC criticises government for vetting CBI report – India TV
India TV News
Coal scam: CBI to file new case
India TV NewsDiscover Related








![[Prevention Of Corruption Act] CBI Can File Final Report Even If No Offence Is Revealed During Probe: Kerala High Court](/static/images/error.jpg)



































