From Tipu to Savarkar to Nehru: our history is littered with stories of misinformation, and they gripped the nation in 2022 too
1 year, 11 months ago

From Tipu to Savarkar to Nehru: our history is littered with stories of misinformation, and they gripped the nation in 2022 too

The Hindu  

“The very ink with which all history is written is merely fluid prejudice,” wrote Mark Twain in Following the Equator. Much spotlight also shines on the petitions’ contentious sign-off: “I beg to remain your most obedient servant.” Savarkar’s mercy pleas The problem with such debates is, history gets reduced to an amenable ideological prop. But the ideologues on both sides continue to read pragmatism — one in Savarkar’s petitions, the other in Nehru’s proximity to Lord Mountbatten. Although the debate isn’t exactly new, Hindu nationalists fired a bombshell revelation of how Motilal Nehru pulled strings to get his son out of Nabha jail in 1923. Distorting history While we know Savarkar wrote four letters pledging his troth to India’s colonial overlords in exchange for clemency, do we also know that one of those was for all inmates and not just himself?

History India Hindu Nehru Nabha Tipu Jawaharlal Savarkar Wrote  indias  political  2022  history  gripped  nehru  politics  stay  nation  littered  misinformation  tipu  petitions  savarkar  wrote

History of this topic

Poll results a reality check for ‘overconfident’ BJP: RSS mouthpiece Organiser
6 months, 1 week ago

Poll results a reality check for ‘overconfident’ BJP: RSS mouthpiece Organiser

The Hindu  

The results of Lok Sabha poll-2024 have come as a reality check for “overconfident” BJP workers who failed to understand that Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s call of 400+ was a target for them and not for the Opposition, said a story published in Organiser, English mouthpiece of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. The article, titled as “Conversation for course correction”, adds …

Review of A New History of India — From its Origins to the 21st Century: Heroes and villains
1 year, 7 months ago

Review of A New History of India — From its Origins to the 21st Century: Heroes and villains

The Hindu  

For some time, professional historians have wondered whether a single, usable, Indian past can any longer be written. Professional historians have of late also been dealing with the political challenge to their practice, as a wide range of ‘custodians’ of the past have emerged, from amateurs, ‘scientists’ and community gatekeepers, to hyper-ethno-nationalists, who lay exclusive claim not only to historical …

Savarkar & His Critics: Why Both Ambedkar and the Upper Castes Opposed Him
2 years, 4 months ago

Savarkar & His Critics: Why Both Ambedkar and the Upper Castes Opposed Him

The Quint  

The book tells the story of the place of history in Vinayak Damodar Savarkar’s political thought. It examines Savarkar’s central claim that “Hindutva is not a word but a history”. ) Yet, Savarkar was not in fact consistent in this approach in Saha Soneri Pane: he violated the basic protocols of what he had identified as “today’s research”. Savarkar had …

Mohan Guruswamy | Rewriting history, with an open mind or empty mind?
2 years, 5 months ago

Mohan Guruswamy | Rewriting history, with an open mind or empty mind?

Deccan Chronicle  

Historical revisionism is the process of rewriting history to correct the misinterpretations of the past or for an ideological purpose. British scholars, who seemed genuinely interested in how this country evolved, wrote most of modern India’s history. As a young student in a Catholic school, in recently independent India, the first history lessons imparted to me told that story, particularly …

DC Edit | Why rewrite history?
2 years, 6 months ago

DC Edit | Why rewrite history?

Deccan Chronicle  

Bihar chief minister Nitish Kumar’s wonderment about how history can be revisited is as much pregnant with political meaning as the call of home minister Amit Shah on its need. History is history,” Mr Kumar said in reply to Mr Shah’s statement that “we can write our own history.” While the home minister who had his political baptism in the …

Mohan Guruswamy | Indian history: The tales of defeat in North India
3 years, 1 month ago

Mohan Guruswamy | Indian history: The tales of defeat in North India

Deccan Chronicle  

History invariably is written and rewritten to serve the political and ideological cause of the ruling elites. As a young student in a Catholic school, in recently Independent India, the first history lessons imparted to me told that story, particularly the period of the last occupation by the British, somewhat differently. South Indian history, which is fairly distinct and certainly …

Leftist History Negates India’s Civilisational Greatness, Underplays Bloody Islamic Conquests
3 years, 2 months ago

Leftist History Negates India’s Civilisational Greatness, Underplays Bloody Islamic Conquests

News 18  

English novelist George Orwell had mentioned in his book ‘Nineteen Eighty-Four’ that “who controls the past controls the future: who controls the present controls the past.” This could not have been more germane than in the legacy wars and live battlefield that Indian historiography routinely becomes. Sir John Strachey, a British administrator in-charge of training the Imperial Civil Service newbies …

How India’s historians have reflected on the country’s history, culture and heritage
4 years, 2 months ago

How India’s historians have reflected on the country’s history, culture and heritage

The Hindu  

THE term ‘Indian history’ is deceptively simple at first sight, so much so that we take it as a given rather than as a point of reflection: it assays a study of the past of the Indian subcontinent. As early as in 1935, Shafa’at Ahmad Khan, in his presidential address to the first All India Modern History Congress, warned of …

Discover Related