If Minor and Accused are Married, Physical Relationship Between Them will be Presumed: HC
News 18The Allahabad High Court on Wednesday observed that “if there is a statement of a minor victim that either she and the accused have solemnised marriage or stayed as husband and wife, then there will be a presumption that during their stay together they had physical relationship except where the victim specifically denies so”. The court held that in cases where the minor victim, in her statements recorded under Sections 161 and 164 of CrPC, that the fact of her marriage with the accused or their living arrangements as husband and wife but conspicuously keeps silent on the issue of physical relationship, it would be presumed that she and the accused had a normal relationship as husband and wife which also includes a physical relationship. After hearing in detail the arguments put forth by the counsel for the rival parties as well as the Amicus Curiae, the high court answered the said question as follows: The court also said the IO is under obligation to conduct a fair investigation and for that he has to follow the procedure prescribed under the statutes, however, he has the liberty to record statements of witnesses more than one time to unearth the truth. Medical evidence may be a factor to take a contrary view to the statement of the victim recorded under Sections 161 and 164 of CrPC by the IO, however, the IO has to record specific reasons in the final report/ charge sheet for such opinion/ view, court stressed.