
Yakub’s petition should have been heard by Constitution Bench: Prof. Upendra Baxi
Live LawA lot has been spoken about the execution of Yakub Abdul Razzak Memon, in the morning of July 30, 2015. The most recent to join the debate is Prof. Upendra Baxi.Hailing the fact that the Court sat in the early hours to hear the petition, Prof. Upendra Baxi wrote in an Article published by India Today, “The pre-dawn hearing was heroic and demosprudential ; it amplified the message that the doors of the court are never closed to a death sentence convict, even in terror cases, and that it is prepared to assemble even past midnight to do justice. It also coveys there are lawyers who will continue to combat the law in order to attain justice.” While observing that justice according to law may not meet the criteria of justice in courts of public opinion, he opined that"In my opinion this matter should have at least been decided by a five-judge Constitution Bench since nothing less than a discipline on the discretion of the CJI to constitute review and curative petitions was at stake. He observed that even when considered as “mighty contributions to justice according to law”, the Memon decisions are still open to questioning. At around 5 am on July 30, the Apex Court rejected Memon’s mercy plea, observing that a stay on the death warrant could be a travesty of justice since ample opportunity was provided to Memon, after the rejection of the first mercy petition.
History of this topic

Fake List of Politicians and Actors Linked to Yakub Memon's Mercy Petition
The Quint
July 30: When 15,000 Indian 'liberals' paid tribute to terrorist Yakub Memon
Op India
Trials of a death-row convict
The Hindu
NSA Doval defends Yakub Memon's execution, says 'weakness of nation includes unjustified tolerance'
Firstpost
Yakub’s petition should have been heard by Constitution Bench: Prof. Upendra Baxi
Live Law
Yakub Memon’s Execution: When Reason Gave Way to Mediocrity
The Quint
The justice deficit
Deccan Chronicle
The accused was a victim too
Deccan Chronicle
Dear media, don’t misreport, misrepresent and communalize Yakub Memon
Op India
Yakub Memon hanging aftermath: The irrationality of arguments against death sentence
Firstpost
Yakub Memon's funeral: Did the serial blasts convict deserve a hero's farewell?
Firstpost
Should Judicial Processes be Seen Through a Religious Prism?
The Quint
The Hindi Press Mostly Supported the Yakub Memon Hanging
The Quint
Yakub Memon Was Judicially Garroted, So Grave Doubts Remain
The Quint
Yakub Memon hanged, Nation bids adieu to Dr. Kalam: Top 5 News Headlines | IndiaTV News
India TV News
Yakub Memon hanging stokes political debate
The Hindu
Yakub Memon's final moments: Hallucinations, a birthday cake and then anger
Firstpost
An open letter by a cop to those opposing death penalty to Yakub
Op India![After night long judicial action, Yakub Memon executed on his 53rd birthday [Read the Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
After night long judicial action, Yakub Memon executed on his 53rd birthday [Read the Judgment]
Live Law![After night long judicial action, Yakub Memon executed on his 53rd birthday [Read the Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
After night long judicial action, Yakub Memon executed on his 53rd birthday [Read the Judgment]
Live Law
Questions raised over Yakub Memon’s hanging
Live Mint
Who is Yakub Memon: Here's all you need to know about the 1993 Mumbai blasts convict
Firstpost
Yakub Memon hanged 22 years after Mumbai blasts
Live Mint
Yakub Memon hanged on birthday
The Hindu
SC rejects Memon’s plea to stall execution
The Hindu
Yakub Memon hanged: Timeline of the dramatic last 24 hours
India Today
India executes plotter of deadly 1993 Mumbai bombings
Al Jazeera
Yakub Memon Hanged: Late Night Drama Fails To Save Him
The Quint
Yakub Memon buried in Mumbai
The Hindu
Yakub Memon case: Tense atmosphere outside jail
The Hindu
President rejects mercy plea; Memon lawyers appeal again
The Hindu
President rejects mercy petition of Yakub Memon
India TV News
End of the road for Yakub Memon: President rejects 1993 blasts convict's mercy plea
Firstpost
SC upholds Yakub's death sentence, Govt clears FDI proposals worth Rs 981 crore: Top 5 News Headlines
India TV News
BJP welcomes SC verdict on Yakub Memon, calls those opposed to sentence as 'mentally challenged'
Firstpost![SC 3-Judge bench dismisses Yakub Memon’s petition; Maharashtra Governor rejects mercy plea [Read the Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
SC 3-Judge bench dismisses Yakub Memon’s petition; Maharashtra Governor rejects mercy plea [Read the Judgment]
Live Law![SC 3-Judge bench dismisses Yakub Memon’s petition; Maharashtra Governor rejects mercy plea [Read the Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
SC 3-Judge bench dismisses Yakub Memon’s petition; Maharashtra Governor rejects mercy plea [Read the Judgment]
Live Law
Justice hasn't been done: Experts question Yakub Memon SC verdict procedure, victims happy
Firstpost
What is at Stake is Our Commitment to National Self-Improvement
The Quint
Did Yakub Memon Have to Hang in Ram Rajya?
The Quint
Yakub Memon may be hanged at 7 am on Thursday as SC refuses to stay execution
Firstpost
Why Yakub Memon still has hope as SC decides fate on his execution today
Firstpost
Pardoning Yakub Memon will be a tribute to Dr. Kalam: Gopalkrishna Gandhi
The Hindu![SC delivers split decision on Yakub Memon’s plea:Three Judge Bench headed by Dipak Mistra will hear Tomorrow [Read the Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
SC delivers split decision on Yakub Memon’s plea:Three Judge Bench headed by Dipak Mistra will hear Tomorrow [Read the Judgment]
Live Law![SC delivers split decision on Yakub Memon’s plea:Three Judge Bench headed by Dipak Mistra will hear Tomorrow [Read the Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
SC delivers split decision on Yakub Memon’s plea:Three Judge Bench headed by Dipak Mistra will hear Tomorrow [Read the Judgment]
Live Law
A Judge as Delusional Dictator Clinging on to Death By Hanging
The Quint
Yakub Memon's death sentence: SC asks Attorney General to clarify rules of curative petitions
Firstpost
No proof that Yakub Memon surrendered
India TV News![Executing Memon; Gross Travesty of justice; Former Judges and Jurists [Read the Petition]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Executing Memon; Gross Travesty of justice; Former Judges and Jurists [Read the Petition]
Live LawDiscover Related









































