Google Pay Penalty Competition Commission of India Android Case
1 year, 8 months ago

Google Pay Penalty Competition Commission of India Android Case

ABP News  

In probably the first case of a Big Tech giant paying a penalty to the Indian regulators as the government aims to bring a new Digital India Act, Google has paid the entire penalty amount of Rs 1,337.76 crore imposed by the Competition Commission of India for anti-competitive practice in the Android ecosystem, the media has reported. To recall, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal in March upheld the orders of the fair trade regulator, CCI, imposing a penalty of Rs 1,337.76 crore on US-based tech giant Google in the Android mobile devices case, with some modifications. The bench directed the NCLAT to dispose of Google's appeal by March 31, and granted Google seven days to deposit 10 per cent of the Rs 1,337.76 crore penalty imposed by the CCI. In response to Google's announcement of implementing its new Google Play payments policy, the Alliance of Digital India Foundation had expressed deep concern over the policy change and has demanded that the new policies must be put on hold, since Google charging a nearly 30 per cent service fee on app developers will prove to be a significant blow to the Indian startup ecosystem.

India Penalty Google Android Nclat Cci  android  india  commission  133776  cci  case  google  crore  rs  nclat  penalty  pay  tribunal  competition

History of this topic

India's Competition Commission starts new probe into Google's app store policies following Winzo’s complaint
1 month, 1 week ago

India's Competition Commission starts new probe into Google's app store policies following Winzo’s complaint

Firstpost  

Winzo’s claims that Google, through its Play Store, imposes unreasonable terms on app developers via its Developer Distribution Agreement and Developer Program Policies. These policies create a one-sided relationship that limit developers’ ability to operate fairly in the market This investigation is not Google’s first brush with India’s competition watchdog. The probe centres around allegations that Google’s app store policies …

Google Faces Fresh CCI Probe Following Complaint From Real-Money Gaming Firm WinZO: Here's What Went Down
1 month, 1 week ago

Google Faces Fresh CCI Probe Following Complaint From Real-Money Gaming Firm WinZO: Here's What Went Down

ABP News  

Google's regulatory troubles in India continue to grow, with the Competition Commission of India initiating a fresh investigation into the tech giant. The move comes in response to a complaint filed by WinZO, an online gaming platform, alleging anti-competitive practices related to Google's Play Store policies. Accordingly, the commission directs the director general to cause an investigation.” WinZO's Allegations WinZO …

CCI orders probe into Google’s game download policy for alleged dominance abuse
1 month, 1 week ago

CCI orders probe into Google’s game download policy for alleged dominance abuse

Live Mint  

New Delhi: Competition Commission of India on Thursday ordered an investigation into Google's policies on download of apps from Google Play, its app store, and on Google denied the allegations in its response to CCI’s queries, the order issued by the competition watchdog showed. The mobile gaming platform alleged that Google Play, which hosts third-party app developers, restricts download of …

Google wins challenge against 1.49 billion euro EU antitrust fine
3 months, 3 weeks ago

Google wins challenge against 1.49 billion euro EU antitrust fine

Live Mint  

Alphabet unit Google won its challenge on Wednesday against a 1.49 billion euro antitrust fine imposed five years ago for hindering rivals in online search advertising, a week after it lost a much bigger case. The European Commission in its 2019 decision said Google had abused its dominance to prevent websites from using brokers other than its AdSense platform that …

Google loses fight against $2.7 billion EU antitrust fine
3 months, 4 weeks ago

Google loses fight against $2.7 billion EU antitrust fine

The Hindu  

Alphabet's Google on Tuesday lost its fight against a 2.42 billion euro fine levied by EU antitrust regulators seven years ago, one of a trio of hefty fines meted out to the company for various anti-competitive practices. The European Commission fined the world's most popular internet search engine in 2017 for using its own price comparison shopping service to gain …

Google loses final EU court appeal against 2.4 billion euro fine in antitrust shopping case
3 months, 4 weeks ago

Google loses final EU court appeal against 2.4 billion euro fine in antitrust shopping case

Associated Press  

LONDON — Google lost its final legal challenge on Tuesday against a European Union penalty for giving its own shopping recommendations an illegal advantage over rivals in search results, ending a long-running antitrust case that came with a whopping fine. The European Union’s Court of Justice upheld a lower court’s decision, rejecting the company’s appeal against the 2.4 billion euro …

Judge gives US regulators until December to propose penalties for Google's illegal search monopoly
4 months ago

Judge gives US regulators until December to propose penalties for Google's illegal search monopoly

The Independent  

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Attorneys for the Justice Department and Google were unable …

Android mobile ecosystem case: Supreme Court to hear pleas of Google, CCI in September
5 months, 3 weeks ago

Android mobile ecosystem case: Supreme Court to hear pleas of Google, CCI in September

The Hindu  

The Supreme Court Thursday said it will hear in the second week of September the cross-pleas of Google and the Competition Commission of India challenging a verdict of an appellate tribunal in a case related to the tech giant's alleged anti-competitive practices in the Android mobile device matter. On March 29 last year, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal had …

Google fights $17 billion UK lawsuit over adtech practices
8 months ago

Google fights $17 billion UK lawsuit over adtech practices

The Hindu  

Google parent Alphabet has urged a London tribunal to block a mass lawsuit which accuses it of abusing its dominance in the online advertising market, in the latest case to focus on the search giant's business practices. The lawsuit seeks damages of up to 13.6 billion pounds on behalf of publishers of websites and apps based in the United Kingdom, …

Delhi High Court Dismisses Google's Appeal Against Rejection Of Patent, Imposes ₹1 Lakh Costs
9 months, 1 week ago

Delhi High Court Dismisses Google's Appeal Against Rejection Of Patent, Imposes ₹1 Lakh Costs

Live Law  

The Delhi High Court has imposed Rs. 1 lakh costs on Google LLC while dismissing its appeal against the refusal of the grant of a patent by the Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs in 2019. Google had filed the appeal against the rejection of its application for a grant of a patent titled “Managing Instant Messaging Sessions on Multiple …

CCI Orders Probe Into Google's Play Store Policies: Here's What The Company Said
9 months, 3 weeks ago

CCI Orders Probe Into Google's Play Store Policies: Here's What The Company Said

News 18  

The Competition Commission of India on Friday ordered a probe into the Google Play Store, accusing the tech giant of exploiting its dominant position in the country’s online market. The CCI said that Google allegedly imposed unfair terms and discriminatory practices in its Play Store, violating several provisions of the country’s anti-trust law. The CCI decision came after multiple Indian …

Probe into Google's Alleged Anti-Competitive Practices Regarding Play Store Pricing
9 months, 3 weeks ago

Probe into Google's Alleged Anti-Competitive Practices Regarding Play Store Pricing

Deccan Chronicle  

NEW DELHI: The competition watchdog on Friday ordered a probe against Google for alleged anti-competitive practices with respect to its Play Store pricing policy. “The informants are primarily aggrieved with Google's updated payment policies in relation to its proprietary app store -- Google Play Store -- which is alleged to be in violation of the competition law,” said the Competition …

Competition watchdog orders probe against Google for Playstore pricing policy. What's the issue?
9 months, 3 weeks ago

Competition watchdog orders probe against Google for Playstore pricing policy. What's the issue?

Hindustan Times  

The competition regulator ordered an investigation against Google on Friday for suspected anti-competitive practices regarding its pricing policy on the Play Store. Google under scrutiny for alleged discriminatory payment policies on Play Store The Competition Commission of India said that the informants were primarily concerned about Google's revised payment policies related to its proprietary app store, Google Play Store, which …

Google reinstates Indian apps, will require payment of dues
10 months ago

Google reinstates Indian apps, will require payment of dues

The Hindu  

Google is reinstating dozens of apps that were delisted by the company on March 1 for resisting the firm’s platform fees on in-app payments, the tech company said in a statement on March 5. “In the spirit of cooperation, we are temporarily reinstating the apps of the developers with appeals pending in the Supreme Court,” a Google spokesperson said, referring …

Google mulls removing apps by 10 companies in India for not paying service fee
10 months, 1 week ago

Google mulls removing apps by 10 companies in India for not paying service fee

Hindustan Times  

Alphabet Inc's Google will enforce action against the apps of 10 companies for not paying a service fee for the usage of its app store platform in India, including potentially de-listing their apps, the tech giant said on Friday. Companies including Walt Disney and Tinder-owner Match have previously sued Google over its policy of imposing a "service fee" of 11%-26% …

Why did Google take action against 10 Indian developers? Here's all you need to know
10 months, 1 week ago

Why did Google take action against 10 Indian developers? Here's all you need to know

India TV News  

Google has announced that it will remove some Indian apps from its Play Store. “After giving these developers more than three years to prepare, including three weeks after the Supreme Court’s order, we are taking necessary steps to ensure our policies are applied consistently across the ecosystem, as we do for any form of policy violation globally,” Google wrote in …

Supreme Court Issues Notice To Google India On Indian App Developers' Plea Against Play Store Billing Policy
10 months, 4 weeks ago

Supreme Court Issues Notice To Google India On Indian App Developers' Plea Against Play Store Billing Policy

Live Law  

The Supreme Court on February 2 issued notice on a petition to Google India on petitions filed by filed by tech start-ups challenging Google Play Store's billing policy as exploitative. However, a bench comprising Chief Justice DY Chandrachud, and Justices Manoj Misra and Satish Chandra Sharma refused to immediately stay Google's decision to remove apps from its Play Store over …

Google-CCI case: Supreme Court to begin hearing in the matter 30 April
11 months, 2 weeks ago

Google-CCI case: Supreme Court to begin hearing in the matter 30 April

Live Mint  

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Monday said it would commence hearing on 30 April in Google's challenge to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal's decision upholding the ₹1,338 crore fine levied by the Competition Commission of India against Google for antitrust breaches. Representing Google, senior lawyer Harish Salve noted that the case introduces new legal questions for the court's …

Google to assemble Pixel phones in India from 2024
1 year, 2 months ago

Google to assemble Pixel phones in India from 2024

The Hindu  

Google, Inc. set a 2024 target to assemble its Pixel line of smartphones in India, the firm announced at its annual Google for India event on Thursday. The company said that it was firming up protections against financial frauds, saying it was engaged with the Reserve Bank of India and the National Payments Corporation of India on the issue. Saikat …

Google enters retail loan business in India, Google Pay to launch sachet loans
1 year, 2 months ago

Google enters retail loan business in India, Google Pay to launch sachet loans

Live Mint  

Google India on Thursday announced sachet loans on the Google Pay application to help small businesses in the country. Google India said that merchants in India often need smaller loans, hence, the tech giant launched sachet loans on the Gpay application. The company will provide loans to small businesses at just ₹15,000 that can be repaid in simpler repayment amounts …

Google in last ditch effort to overturn $2.6 bln EU antitrust fine
1 year, 3 months ago

Google in last ditch effort to overturn $2.6 bln EU antitrust fine

The Hindu  

Alphabet's Google on Tuesday made a last-ditch effort at Europe's top court to overturn a 2.42 billion euro EU antitrust fine imposed for market abuse related to its shopping service, saying that regulators failed to show that its practices were anti-competitive. Google lawyer Thomas Graf said the European Commission had failed to show that the company's different treatment of rivals …

Panel urges govt to finalize digital competition bill
1 year, 5 months ago

Panel urges govt to finalize digital competition bill

Live Mint  

NEW DELHI : The parliamentary standing committee on finance, led by Jayant Sinha, on Thursday urged the Union government to finalise the digital competition bill at the earliest to check a slew of anti-competitive practices plaguing the digital markets. In December, Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance recommended formation of Digital Competition Law, and defining Big Tech companies as Systemically Important …

Google says court order on Disney app fee in India temporary
1 year, 5 months ago

Google says court order on Disney app fee in India temporary

The Hindu  

Google said on Wednesday an Indian court's directive ordering the company to charge a lower 4% in-app payment on Disney's streaming service in the country was a temporary measure until the court proceedings play out. Disney in India has gone to court in what is the latest and most high-profile challenge to Google's policy of imposing a "service fee" of …

Google-CCI Case: Cross-Pleas To Be Heard By SC In October In Android Mobile Device Case
1 year, 5 months ago

Google-CCI Case: Cross-Pleas To Be Heard By SC In October In Android Mobile Device Case

ABP News  

The Supreme Court on Friday said it will hear on October 10 the cross-pleas of Google and the Competition Commission of India challenging the verdict of an appellate tribunal in a case related to Google's alleged anti-competitive practices in the Android mobile device case. On March 29, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal had handed out a mixed verdict on …

Google asks India's top court to quash Android antitrust directives
1 year, 6 months ago

Google asks India's top court to quash Android antitrust directives

The Hindu  

Google has urged India's Supreme Court to quash antitrust directives against it for abuse of the Android market, two sources said, as its presses its legal battle against the competition watchdog in one of its most important markets. The Indian tribunal had ruled authorities must prove harm caused by anti-competitive behaviour "but did not apply this requirement" to several of …

Firms resist Google’s fees on in-app purchases, as non-compliance deadline looms
1 year, 6 months ago

Firms resist Google’s fees on in-app purchases, as non-compliance deadline looms

The Hindu  

Dating and matrimonial apps, OTT streaming apps and ed-tech platforms have come together to pressure Google into removing or vastly reducing commissions the search giant charges for in-app purchases on Android smartphones. Last October, the Competition Commission of India ordered Google, among other things, to “not restrict app developers from using any third-party billing/payment processing services, either for in-app purchases …

Indian Government plans action against Google after antitrust breaches
1 year, 7 months ago

Indian Government plans action against Google after antitrust breaches

The Hindu  

India's government plans to take action against Alphabet Inc.'s Google after an antitrust watchdog last year found the group to have abused its market position by indulging in anti-competitive practices, a top IT minister told Reuters. India's antitrust body in October fined Google $275 million in two cases, which involved abusing its dominant position in the Android operating system market, …

Google Faces CCI Inquiry Over Alleged Non-Compliance With Play Store Billing Order
1 year, 7 months ago

Google Faces CCI Inquiry Over Alleged Non-Compliance With Play Store Billing Order

News 18  

The Competition Commission of India on Friday ordered an inquiry into the alleged non-compliance by Google related to the CCI order regarding the Play Store user choice billing policy. The order was in response to the Alliance of Digital India Foundation submission with the Indian market regulator on Google not complying with the CCI directions and introducing user choice billing …

Google took action against over 3,500 loan apps in India for violating norms in 2022
1 year, 8 months ago

Google took action against over 3,500 loan apps in India for violating norms in 2022

India TV News  

New Delhi: Google took action against over 3,500 loan apps in India in 2022 for violating Play Store policy requirements, the company said on Thursday. Google said that overall it prevented 1.43 million policy-violating apps from being published on Google Play banning 173,000 bad accounts preventing over USD 2 billion in fraudulent and abusive transactions in 2022. "In India, in …

Google billing policy: Tech giant moves Delhi HC against single judge order
1 year, 8 months ago

Google billing policy: Tech giant moves Delhi HC against single judge order

Hindustan Times  

Google on Tuesday moved the Delhi high court challenging the single judge’s direction to the Competition Commission of India to decide the applications filed by the Alliance of Digital India Foundation against the tech giant’s new user-choice billing policy. A clutch of pleas by ADIF, an industry body of startups, had sought direction to Google to keep its proposed User …

Google Moves Delhi High Court Challenging Single Judge Order Directing CCI To Consider Applications Of Start-Ups Against New Payment Policy
1 year, 8 months ago

Google Moves Delhi High Court Challenging Single Judge Order Directing CCI To Consider Applications Of Start-Ups Against New Payment Policy

Live Law  

Google has moved the Delhi High Court challenging an order of the single judge directing the Competition Commission of India to take up the applications moved by an alliance of start-ups against tech giant’s new in-app user choice billing policy and consider the same on or before April 26. Senior Advocate Sandeep Sethi appearing for Google mentioned the appeal before …

Decide plea against Google’s new billing policy by April 26, Delhi HC orders CCI
1 year, 8 months ago

Decide plea against Google’s new billing policy by April 26, Delhi HC orders CCI

Hindustan Times  

NEW DELHI: The Delhi high court on Monday told the Competition Commission of India to decide a complaint filed by Alliance of Digital India Foundation, an industry body of Indian startups, against Google’s new user-choice billing policy and decide the same by April 26. ADIF contends that the UCB was a cloaked version of the GPBS, which projects the hoax …

Shark Tank judge Anupam Mittal calls Google ‘Digital East India company’
1 year, 8 months ago

Shark Tank judge Anupam Mittal calls Google ‘Digital East India company’

Live Mint  

Shark Tank India judge and Shadi.com founder Anupam Mittal on Thursday hit out at Alphabet-owned Google for its ‘illegal’ choice billing system and even went to the extent of calling the company ‘Digital East India company.’ The billionaire investor said that Google is working in disregard to Indian laws and he hopes that the Prime Minister's Office official is taking …

Indian startups go to court to stop Google’s new in-app billing system
1 year, 8 months ago

Indian startups go to court to stop Google’s new in-app billing system

Live Mint  

A group of Indian startups has asked a court to suspend Alphabet Inc Google's new in-app billing fee system until the country's antitrust body investigates the U.S. firm for alleged non-compliance with its directives, a legal filing showed. The Alliance of Digital India Foundation last month asked India's antitrust regulator to investigate Google for devising a new system startups say …

Indian startups go to court to stop Google's new in-app billing system
1 year, 8 months ago

Indian startups go to court to stop Google's new in-app billing system

The Hindu  

A group of Indian startups has asked a court to suspend Alphabet Inc. Google's new in-app billing fee system until the country's antitrust body investigates the U.S. firm for alleged non-compliance with its directives, a legal filing showed. The Alliance of Digital India Foundation last month asked India's antitrust regulator to investigate Google for devising a new system startups say …

Startups go to court to stop Google’s new in-app billing system
1 year, 8 months ago

Startups go to court to stop Google’s new in-app billing system

Live Mint  

A group of Indian startups has asked a court to suspend Alphabet Inc Google's new in-app billing fee system until the country's antitrust body investigates the U.S. firm for alleged non-compliance with its directives, a legal filing showed. The Alliance of Digital India Foundation last month asked India's antitrust regulator to investigate Google for devising a new system startups say …

Google in trouble again! $32 million fine for unfair practices in the app market
1 year, 8 months ago

Google in trouble again! $32 million fine for unfair practices in the app market

India TV News  

South Korea's antitrust regulator has reportedly slapped a fine of 42.1 billion won on Google and its regional arms for unfair business practices, with the aim to solidify its dominance in the Korean smartphone gaming app market. One Store is a major homegrown app market launched in January 2016 by South Korea's three mobile carriers, along with Naver Corp, reports …

Match, Indian startups call for antitrust probe of Google in-app billing fee
1 year, 9 months ago

Match, Indian startups call for antitrust probe of Google in-app billing fee

The Hindu  

Tinder-owner Match Group and Indian startups have asked the country's competition body to investigate Alphabet's Google for alleged non-compliance with an antitrust directive by charging a high service fee for in-app payments, filings show. Google later decided to start offering User Choice Billing for allowing alternative payments alongside Google's when purchasing in-app digital content, but the ADIF said in its …

CCI to get more enforcement powers on Big Tech following amendment to Competition law
1 year, 9 months ago

CCI to get more enforcement powers on Big Tech following amendment to Competition law

The Hindu  

The proposed amendments, cleared by Parliament, to the Competition Act gives more powers to the Competition Commission of India in pursuing what it sees as anti-competitive behaviour. Recently, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal upheld a ₹1,337 crore fine imposed by the CCI on Google for the firm’s contracts with mobile manufacturers. The Bill, which amends the Competition Act, 2002 …

NCLAT upholds ₹1,338 cr fine on Google, grants partial relief on four grounds
1 year, 9 months ago

NCLAT upholds ₹1,338 cr fine on Google, grants partial relief on four grounds

Hindustan Times  

An appellate tribunal on Wednesday handed out a mixed verdict on Google's alleged anti-competitive practices in the android mobile devise case - upholding a fine of ₹1,338 crore but scrapping conditions like allowing hosting of third-party app stores on its Play Store. Notably, the NCLAT in its 189-page order, upheld CCI's six directions, including one in which Google was asked …

NCLAT upholds penalty on Google; sets aside certain directions issued by CCI
1 year, 9 months ago

NCLAT upholds penalty on Google; sets aside certain directions issued by CCI

The Hindu  

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal on Wednesday upheld the ₹1,337 crore fine imposed on Google by the Competition Commission of India. While holding that the CCI investigation did not violate principles of natural justice, the tribunal set aside certain directions issued by the CCI. The court quashed the directions relating to the non-monetary directives that would have forced the …

NCLAT reserves verdict on Google's plea against CCI
1 year, 9 months ago

NCLAT reserves verdict on Google's plea against CCI

Hindustan Times  

The NCLAT on Monday concluded its hearing over the petition filed by Google, in which the tech giant challenged the Competition Commission's order imposing a ₹1,337.76 crore penalty for anti-competitive practices in relation to Android mobile devices. Challenging the CCI order, Google said the findings are "patently erroneous and ignore" the reality of competition in India, Google's pro-competitive business model, …

ADIF Accuses Google Of Disobeying CCI Orders And Charging App Developers Unfair Commissions
1 year, 10 months ago

ADIF Accuses Google Of Disobeying CCI Orders And Charging App Developers Unfair Commissions

News 18  

The Alliance of Digital India Foundation on Thursday said Google is blatantly disobeying CCI orders and charging app developers an exorbitant 11-26 per cent commission even if they opt for alternative billing system. “Google has recently changed its billing requirement for app developers wherein it has mentioned that if a user pays through an alternate billing system, the Google plays …

Reviewing SC Order, Will Cooperate With CCI On Way Forward, In Parallel With Our Appeal: Google
1 year, 11 months ago

Reviewing SC Order, Will Cooperate With CCI On Way Forward, In Parallel With Our Appeal: Google

ABP News  

With the Supreme Court turning down Google's plea for a stay on the CCI order, the tech giant on Friday said it is reviewing the details of the decision which is limited to interim relief and did not decide the merits of the appeal. The company said it remains committed to users and partners and "will cooperate with the CCI …

Google says will cooperate with CCI after Android decision
1 year, 11 months ago

Google says will cooperate with CCI after Android decision

The Hindu  

Google said on January 20 it will cooperate with India’s competition authority after the Supreme Court upheld an antitrust order forcing the U.S. firm to change how it markets its popular Android platform. The Supreme Court has said a lower tribunal—where Google first challenged the Android directives—can continue to hear the company’s appeal and must rule by March 31. Hoping …

‘Will cooperate…’: Google on Supreme Court's ruling over Android
1 year, 11 months ago

‘Will cooperate…’: Google on Supreme Court's ruling over Android

Hindustan Times  

Google said on Friday it will cooperate with India's competition authority after the country's top court upheld an antitrust order forcing the U.S. firm to change how it markets its popular Android platform. India's highest court has said a lower tribunal - where Google first challenged the Android directives - can continue to hear the company's appeal and must rule …

No relief for Google as SC declines stay on CCI penalty, gives extension to pay fine
1 year, 11 months ago

No relief for Google as SC declines stay on CCI penalty, gives extension to pay fine

India Today  

In a big setback for tech giant Google, the Supreme Court on Thursday declined to grant a stay on the penalty of Rs 1337.76 crore imposed by the Competition Commission of India. The court also asked the NCLAT to hear Google's plea challenging the order passed by the CCI before March 31. The CCI imposed a penalty of Rs 1337.76 …

Google's Actions Are Feudalistic, Following Different Standards For Europe & India: CCI Tells Supreme Court
1 year, 11 months ago

Google's Actions Are Feudalistic, Following Different Standards For Europe & India: CCI Tells Supreme Court

Live Law  

The Supreme Court on Thursday refused to interfere with the order of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal which refused to stay the order of the Competition Commission of India which imposed a penalty of Rs 1,338 crore on Google India for abuse of dominance in relation to Android eco-system. However, he submitted that Google was not extending the same …

Supreme Court rejects Google’s plea against NCLAT order in Android case
1 year, 11 months ago

Supreme Court rejects Google’s plea against NCLAT order in Android case

The Hindu  

The Supreme Court on Thursday affirmed a National Company Law Appellate Tribunal order refusing interim relief to Google against a Competition Commission of India directive to pay a penalty of ₹1,337.76 crore for "abuse of dominance" in the Android ecosystem. Google had moved the apex court after NCLAT, in early January, refused to grant any interim relief while listing its …

Discover Related