
Ayodhya Verdict: Retiring Judge Can Be Retained: Experts
India TV NewsNew Delhi, Sep 23 : Legal experts on Thursday said there are options within the legal framework to retain one of the retiring judges in the three judge bench of the Allahabad High Court to deliver the verdict on the Ayodhya title suit. They said if the Supreme Court interim stay stands beyond September 28, there is a constitutional provision to retain the judge, D V Sharma who retires this month-end by appointing him as an adhoc judge till he signs the judgement.Former Law Minister Shanti Bhushan and noted constitutional expert P P Rao said such a ocassion will not arise as there are all likelihood that the Chief Justice of India will appoint a three-judge bench to hear the matter on Tuesday and two days will be there for the High Court to deliver its verdict before one of the judges retires. "The situation which has arisen today due to difference of opinion between the two judges will not arise when a larger bench will hear the issue," they said adding that if in any chance there is a delay, government can retain the retiring judge by appointing him adhoc judge.Rao said another option is that the judge, who is retiring during the pendency of the matter can sign the judgement and place before the Chief Justice of the High Court in a sealed envelope, which could be opened if the apex court gives a go ahead to the High Court to pronounce the verdict.However, senior advocate K K Venugopal, who had appeared in the apex court on the Ayodhya dispute in 1992 when Kalyan Singh was the Chief Minister, said such a situation would not arise.He said he was hopeful that the verdict will come before the retirement of the judge. The three judges will decide the issue on Tuesday giving sufficient time to the High Court to deliver the verdict before the retirement of one of its judges," Venugopal said.
History of this topic

Bombay High Court Weekly Round-Up: March 10 – March 16, 2025
Live Law
Madras HC upholds compulsory retirement of district judge
New Indian Express
Why has the Supreme Court cleared the decks for appointing retired High Court judges on an ad-hoc basis? | Explained
The Hindu
Supreme Court reserves order on plea against termination of 2 Madhya Pradesh judges
India Today
'Constitution Does Not Mention Cooling-Off Period For Judges Before Post-Retirement Appointments': Union Law And Justice Minister In Rajya Sabha
Live Law
Allahabad HC Directs Continuance Of Service By All Retiring Presidents, Members Of UP District Consumer Forum Till Supreme Court's Decision
Live Law
Supreme Court Criticises Gujarat HC Bench For Releasing Case Without Judgment 10 Months After Reserving Verdict
Live Law
Supreme Court Informed Of Madhya Pradesh High Court's Refusal To Reconsider Dismissal Of 6 Women Judges
Live Law
In 2024, Supreme Court will see exit of 3 judges & Chief Justice of India Chandrachud
India Today
Supreme Court(2:1 Majority) Suspends Conviction Of BSP MP Afsal Ansari; Dissenting Judge Says Impact On Electorate Can't Be Considered
Live Law
Supreme Court Vacates Stay In A 16 Year Old Criminal Appeal; Pulls Up Appellant-Lawyer Who Sought Repeated Adjournments
Live Law
Supreme Court Weekly Digest (15 May 2023- 21 May 2023)
Live Law
Abhijit Gangopadhyay: a judge who follows his own style in justice delivery
The Hindu
Post-retirement benefits for judges’ case: SC stays HC order to take U.P. govt secretaries into custody
Hindustan Times
Resolve the judges appointment logjam
Hindustan Times
Ayodhya five-judge bench of Supreme Court: Where are the judges now?
India Today
Supreme Court staring at vacancy crisis in 2023 as 9 judges set to retire
India Today
Tying hands of single judge: Calcutta HC's Justice Abhijit Gangopadhyay seeks CJI's intervention
India Today
Supreme Court Seeks UP Govt Response On Policy For Premature Release Of Prisoners Above 80 Years Old
Live Law
SC Collegium Proposal For Bombay HC- Appointment Of 3 Addl Judges As Permanent; Addl Judge Justice Abhay Ahuja Given Fresh Term
Live Law
A divine force made the Ayodhya case conclusion possible: Former CJI Ranjan Gogoi
India Today
Can Criminal Proceedings Continue After Exoneration In Departmental Enquiry On Same Allegations? Plea In Supreme Court
Live Law
"Nothing Can Happen Here Till There Is Stay": Delhi Court Adjourns Hearing In INX Media Case Till August 12
Live Law
Former Judge Of Allahabad High Court Who Delivered Ram Janmabhoomi Verdict, Justice Dharam Veer Sharma Passes Away
Live Law
SC Halts Permanent Appointment of Judge Who Passed POCSO Orders
The Quint
Andhra High Court Judge Critical of Jagan Reddy Govt Retires, Hundreds Gather to Bid Farwell
News 18![Every Endeavour Should Be Made By The District & Sessions Judge To Fill Up The Vacant Posts As Expeditiously As Possible: Delhi HC [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Every Endeavour Should Be Made By The District & Sessions Judge To Fill Up The Vacant Posts As Expeditiously As Possible: Delhi HC [Read Order]
Live Law![Bombay HC To Continue Hearing Extremely Urgent Matters With Limited Benches Till May 19 [Read Circular]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Bombay HC To Continue Hearing Extremely Urgent Matters With Limited Benches Till May 19 [Read Circular]
Live Law
Justice S C Dharmadhikari, Second Senior Bombay HC Judge, Resigns
Live Law
SC dismisses all 18 petitions seeking review of the historic Ayodhya verdict
Op India
Ayodhya judgment: Supreme Court to conduct in-chamber hearing of petitions seeking review of its 9 Nov ruling today
Firstpost![Premature Retirement Of Judges In Public Interest; Bombay HC Refuses Relief To Former District Judge [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Premature Retirement Of Judges In Public Interest; Bombay HC Refuses Relief To Former District Judge [Read Judgment]
Live Law
SC verdict in Ayodhya against Sharia: Sunni Waqf Board lawyer
Op India
CJI under RTI Act: Supreme Court to pronounce verdict tomorrow
India TV News
Ayodhya verdict reaffirms India's secular value: Naveen Patnaik
India TV News
Ayodhya verdict: Ram Lalla comes home, a new Masjid to rise
Deccan Chronicle
Ayodhya verdict is perhaps first judgement delivered on Saturday by Supreme Court, says senior official
Firstpost
Ayodhya verdict | Supreme Court observation akin to Liberhan Commission finding on ‘calculated’ demolition
The Hindu
Ayodhya verdict: 'Everyone is a winner,' says former ASG PS Narasimha; 'lot of contradictions,' claims lawyer Zafaryab Jilani
Firstpost
Ayodhya Verdict: Watch full coverage of Supreme Court judgement on India TV
India TV News
Ayodhya Verdict: Uneasy calm in Ayodhya
India TV News
Here's why Supreme Court chose Saturday to deliver Ayodhya verdict
India TV News
Ayodhya Verdict highlights
India TV News
Ayodhya verdict shows Indian democracy alive and strong, says PM Modi
India Today
Ayodhya on edge ahead of verdict, elaborate security arrangements in place
India TV News
India holds its breath with SC set to announce Ayodhya verdict today
Live Mint
Ayodhya on edge ahead of verdict, all educational institutions closed in UP till Monday
Live Mint
The 5-judge power bench that delivered Ayodhya verdict
India TV News
Ayodhya case: Supreme Court to pronounce verdict on November 9
The Hindu
Ayodhya case: CJI to meet senior UP officials Friday to review law and order
Live MintDiscover Related















































