
Supreme Court Allows All Disabled Candidates To Take Scribe In Exams Without Meeting Benchmark Disabilities
Live LawThe Supreme Court today allowed a writ petition filed by a candidate suffering from Focal Hand Dystonia, seeking to avail the benefit of the scribe by relying on landmark Vikas Kumar v. UPSC in which it held that benchmark disability is not the precondition to obtaining a scribe. A bench of Justices J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan passed the judgment by reiterating the Vikas Kumar judgment in which a UPSC candidate, who suffered from Writer's camp, was allowed to avail scribe as against the Civil Services Examination Rules, 2018, in which it was stated that a scribe could be provided only to blind candidates and candidates with locomotor disability or cerebral palsy with an impairment of at least 40%. Set up incentives programs for scribe to ensure their availability and provide necessary training; vii.provide some time prior to the examination to allow the candidates to familiarize themselves with the scribe to ensure that there is a sense of comfort while communicating with the scribe during the examination; viii.offer PwD candidates a choice of examination modes, such as scribe braille, large print, audio recording of answers, etc; ix.take penal action against authorities/officials in charge of decisionmaking process, who fail to follow the guidelines set out by the Respondent No.5 and formulate guidelines which exclude PwD; x. sensitise the persons working for the respondent authorities, and train them on a regular basis, to address the reasonable accommodation needs of PwDs; and xi. The petitioner candidate has filed a writ petition against various examination authorities such as the Institute of Banking Personnel Selection, State Bank of India, Staff Selection Commission, Bihar Staff Selection Commission and the Union of India via the Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities where he was denied the facility of scribe and compensatory time on grounds that these were only available for persons with benchmark disability.
History of this topic

Visually challenged persons suitable for judicial service: Supreme Court
The Hindu
'None Should Be Excluded From Judicial Service Only Because Of Disability' : Supreme Court Strikes Down MP Rule Barring Visually Impaired Candidates
Live Law
Visually impaired persons are eligible for appointment as judge in district judiciary: SC
New Indian Express
RPwD Act | Hyper Rigid Approach While Dealing With Disabled Candidates Dilutes Purpose Of 'Reasonable Accommodation': Delhi High Court
Live Law
SC allows all disabled candidates to have scribes for exams
The Hindu
Supreme Court's Key Decisions On Rights Of Persons With Disability In 2024
Live Law
'Casual Approach': Supreme Court Summons Director General Of Health Services In Plea Of Disabled Candidate For MBBS Admission
Live Law
Supreme Court Grants Relief To Disabled Candidates For AIBE; Express Surprise At NLU Consortium Having No Policy For CLAT
Live Law
Documents Filed In Court Must Be Accessible To Persons With Disabilities : Lawyer Flags Issue Before Supreme Court
Live Law
Citizens with disabilities, making their rights real
The Hindu
Percentage Of Disability Less Than The Benchmark Level Would Not Render Meritorious Disabled Candidate Unfit For Job: Rajasthan High Court
Live Law
'Supreme Court Opened Doors Of Accessibility For Persons With Disabilities' : Prof Amita Dhanda | Interview
Live Law
A formidable legacy in securing disability rights
Hindustan Times
Give priority to 'absolutely blind' candidates over 'low vision' ones in jobs: Karnataka HC
Hindustan Times
SC orders NMC to issue fresh norms to admit PwD students
Hindustan Times
Disability Assessment: A Path to Inclusion and Justice
Hindustan Times
Effect Of Rights Of Persons With Disability Act Can't Be Taken Away By Conditions In Prospectus Of Educational Institute: Kerala High Court
Live Law
Persons With Disabilities Should Not Be Deprived From Public Employment Despite Being Eligible & Meritorious On Hyper-Technical Grounds: Rajasthan HC
Live Law
Supreme Court pushes government for special daily news bulletin for hearing and speech impaired persons
The Hindu
SC releases guidelines to prevent stereotyping of differently abled
Hindustan Times
Centre's response sought on plea raising issue of assistance to persons with disabilities
The Hindu
For inclusive court proceedings, ensuring reasonable accommodation for lawyers with disabilities is vital
Hindustan Times
Supreme Court To Pass Guidelines To Ensure Access To CLAT For Candidates With Disabilities
Live Law
Ensure No Disabled Candidate Is Denied Access To CLAT: Supreme Court To NLU Consortium
Live Law
Panel to conduct accessibility audit in Supreme Court for disabled persons
The Hindu
Disability rights: A call to our CJI to champion this cause with all his might
Hindustan Times
Kerala Govt accused of sabotaging reservations for disabled
The Hindu
'Have An Element Of Sensitivity': Supreme Court To Centre On Plea By Disabled Persons Challenging Exclusion From IPS, IRPFS, DANIPS Services
Live Law
Mentally Disabled Persons Entitled To Have Assessment Done At Their Homes For Disability Certificate : Madras High Court
Live Law
How Supreme Court Protected Rights Of Disabled In 2021
Live Law
Supreme Court Directs Centre To Issue Instructions To Implement Reservation In Promotions For Persons With Disabilities Within 4 Months
Live Law
Reservation In Promotions For Persons With Disabilities : Centre Seeks Clarifications On Supreme Court Verdict
Live Law
Persons With Disabilities Have Right To Reservation In Promotions : Supreme Court
Live Law
SC directs Centre to frame 'proper guidelines' on granting writers to persons with disability during exams
Firstpost
SC Directs Centre to Frame 'Proper Guidelines' on Granting Scribe to Disabled Persons for Exams
News 18
Benchmark Disability Not A Precondition To Obtain A Scribe: Supreme Court Allows Scribe For UPSC Candidate With 'Writer's Cramp'
Live Law![Words Like "Disabled," "Physically Handicapped" & "Mentally Retarded" Offend Human Dignity Of Persons With Different Abilities: Pakistan SC [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Words Like "Disabled," "Physically Handicapped" & "Mentally Retarded" Offend Human Dignity Of Persons With Different Abilities: Pakistan SC [Read Judgment]
Live Law
For equal treatment: The Hindu Editorial on the Supreme Court extending benefits to the disabled
The Hindu
Disabled are entitled to same benefits of SC/ST quota: Supreme Court
The Hindu
SC affirms 3% quota for disabled in PSUs
The Hindu![Higher Educational Institutions Should Reserve 5% Seats For Persons With Benchmark Disabilities: Himachal Pradesh HC [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Higher Educational Institutions Should Reserve 5% Seats For Persons With Benchmark Disabilities: Himachal Pradesh HC [Read Judgment]
Live Law
Proper Implementation Of ‘Rights Of Persons with Disabilities Act 2016’: SC Grants Three Months’ Time For States And UTs
Live Law
SC Directs Counselling And Admission Of Candidate Suffering From Thalassaemia For Medical Seat Under Disability Quota
Live Law![Can State Specify Percentage Of Disability For Reservation In Recruitment? Madras HC Asks [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Can State Specify Percentage Of Disability For Reservation In Recruitment? Madras HC Asks [Read Order]
Live Law![Physically Handicapped OBC Candidates Can’t Claim 10 Attempts in Civil Service Examination: SC [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Physically Handicapped OBC Candidates Can’t Claim 10 Attempts in Civil Service Examination: SC [Read Judgment]
Live Law![Delhi HC Highlights Deficiencies In Persons With Disabilities (PWD) Act , Suggests Reforms [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Delhi HC Highlights Deficiencies In Persons With Disabilities (PWD) Act , Suggests Reforms [Read Judgment]
Live Law![No reservation for disabled in promotional posts: Himachal Pradesh HC [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
No reservation for disabled in promotional posts: Himachal Pradesh HC [Read Judgment]
Live Law![Reservation for differently abled persons will have to be computed on the basis of total vacancies of the cadre: SC [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Reservation for differently abled persons will have to be computed on the basis of total vacancies of the cadre: SC [Read Judgment]
Live Law
Supreme Court directs Central and State Governments to Monitor the Implementation of the Persons with Disabilities Act, 1995
Live LawDiscover Related









































