[Updated]: RTI Applicable To Office Of CJI; SC Upholds Delhi HC Judgment
In a historic judgment, the Supreme Court on Wednesday held that the office of Chief Justice of India is a public authority under the Right to Information Act. "Confidentiality may have some bearing and importance in ensuring honest and fair appraisals, though it could work the other way around also and, therefore, what should be disclosed would depend on authentic enquiry relating to the public interest, that is, whether the right to access and the right to know outweighs the possible public interest in protecting privacy or outweighs the harm and injury to third parties when the information relates to such third parties or the information is confidential in nature", stated the Court. In the words of Justice Khanna : "The public interest test in the context of the RTI Act would mean reflecting upon the object and purpose behind the right to information, the right to privacy and consequences of invasion, and breach of confidentiality and possible harm and injury that would be caused to the third party, with reference to a particular information and the person". Independence in a given case may well demand openness and transparency by furnishing the information" In the context of information relating to judicial appointments, Justice Khanna's judgment drew a distinction between "input" and "output".
Discover Related
Court pulls up CBI for ‘fabricating evidence’ in justice Yadav case
Chief Justice, Supreme Court judges to declare assets to public amid cash row
SC sets up fact-finding panel to probe Patiala MC poll ‘violations’
Plea for police probe into Delhi HC judge residence fire listed on March 28
In-house probe expedited, judge may depose today
CBI probe sought into death of retired Tirunelveli Sub-Inspector of Police
Delhi HC issues notice on plea challenging Atishi's election from Kalkaji
CJI’s probe panel visits high court judge Yashwant Varma’s house
CJI sets up 3-member panel to probe judge
ED conducts searches across four States in SDPI case
TASMAC issue: HC directs ED not to proceed further
Not a single special CBI court in Bengal: Shah
HC says it may explore possibility of entrusting probe into AEE selection to CBI
SC asks CBI stand on plea to probe 'fraud' by Kolkata's SREI group
Cash-for-job scam: SC stays Madras HC order for CBI probe against ex-AIADMK minister
Application U/S 34 Of Arbitration Act Not Maintainable If Not Filed With Copy Of Arbitral Award: Delhi High Court