"Be Sensitive": J&K High Court Urges Trial Courts To Avoid 'Copy-Paste' Practices In Bail Orders
Live LawThe High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has stressed the necessity for judicial sensitivity and diligence in dealing with bail applications. Justice Dhar made these observations in a plea involving petitioner Umar Bashir Khan, who sought bail in connection with FIR registered under Sections 451, 376/511, 354, and 506 of the Ranbir Penal Code. After examining the submissions and evidence, Justice Sanjay Dhar strongly criticized the trial court's handling of the bail application. Justice Dhar remarked, “From a perusal of the afore-quoted observations of the trial court and, in fact, from a perusal of the order passed by the trial court on 02.09.2024 as a whole, it appears that the said court has decided the bail application of the petitioner on the basis of facts of some other case” The court added, “This clearly reflects absolute non-application of mind and casual approach on the part of the trial court. Highlighting the importance of judicial diligence, the judgment stated, “Even a single day's delay in granting bail to a person who is otherwise entitled to it amounts to violation of his fundamental right to life and liberty.” Granting bail to the petitioner with a bond of ₹25,000 the High Court used the occasion to issue broader guidance to subordinate courts.