Harris and Trump have made their closing arguments. Here's how they wound down their campaigns
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Harris and Trump have made their closing arguments. Here's how they wound down their campaigns

NPR  

Harris and Trump have made their closing arguments. Here's how they wound down their campaigns toggle caption Evan Vucci/AP; Susan Walsh/AP Vice President Harris ended her campaign focused on persuasion, committing in ads and rally speeches to be a president for all Americans — even those who disagree with her. His rally speeches combined "low IQ" smears of his opponent with dire warnings about immigration and crime, as well as a celebration of economic tariffs. A regular part of Harris' rally speeches was a line noting that while Trump has an "enemies" list, she has a "to-do list" of policies to improve the lives of the American people, from expanding home-care options for seniors to measures aimed at increasing the stock of available housing. During a Halloween campaign event in Arizona, Trump called former Republican Rep. Liz Cheney a "radical war hawk" and said "let's put her with a rifle standing there with nine barrels shooting at her, OK?

Campaign Trump Harris  harris  arguments  campaign  supporters  speeches  wound  spent  trump  closing  heres  voters  state  rally  focused  campaigns

History of this topic

Harris’ campaign leaders say there was a ‘price to be paid’ for shortened campaign against Trump
3 weeks, 6 days ago

Harris’ campaign leaders say there was a ‘price to be paid’ for shortened campaign against Trump

Associated Press  

NEW YORK — The leaders of Kamala Harris’ presidential campaign insist they simply didn’t have enough time to execute a winning strategy against Donald Trump, pointing to “ferocious” political headwinds that were ultimately too much to overcome in the 107-day period after President Joe Biden stepped aside. Harris’ leadership team, speaking on the “Pod Save America” podcast that aired on …

Trump election win: The Harris campaign’s most absurd response to complete failure.
1 month, 1 week ago

Trump election win: The Harris campaign’s most absurd response to complete failure.

Slate  

It is a confusing time to be a Democrat. Trump has wasted no time outfitting his Cabinet with both familiar neocon reactionaries and darker, weirder menaces licking their chops at the damage they’ll soon be able to inflict. But I think I speak for everyone when I say the one entity I don’t need to hear anything from is the …

Many Reasons Why Kamala Harris Lost US Presidential Race To Donald Trump, But 3 Factors Stand Out Loud And Clear
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Many Reasons Why Kamala Harris Lost US Presidential Race To Donald Trump, But 3 Factors Stand Out Loud And Clear

ABP News  

US Election Results 2024: Kamala Harris’s 2024 presidential campaign was historic, as she was the first female vice president to run for the highest office. While there will be post-mortems, and reams of text written about the first woman vice-president's loss in the unprecedented US elections, since there were numerous factors that played a role in it, three clear reasons …

Opinion | Why Harris lost US polls: First-hand account from 2024 campaign trail
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Opinion | Why Harris lost US polls: First-hand account from 2024 campaign trail

India Today  

Having travelled across the United States from the start of the primary season in the US presidential election, I’ve had a unique vantage point from which to witness both the campaign’s successes and struggles. Harris’s campaign aides admitted that this framing was a significant challenge; they acknowledged that their strategy of emphasising Biden’s achievements didn’t resonate well with voters who …

Trump’s victory: What worked for him, what failed for Harris
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Trump’s victory: What worked for him, what failed for Harris

Live Mint  

In a closely watched election, Donald Trump emerged victorious, capitalizing on strategic messaging, policy promises, and voter dissatisfaction with the current administration. Despite various legal challenges and divisive rhetoric, Trump’s message resonated with a significant portion of the electorate, while Kamala Harris, struggled to overcome her association with President Biden’s administration and a disillusioned electorate. What worked for Trump Economic …

How Trump turned a 'close race' US election into a historic win, and what next?
1 month, 2 weeks ago

How Trump turned a 'close race' US election into a historic win, and what next?

Firstpost  

Trump’s victory represents a monumental political comeback—and if he gets a Republican-controlled Congress, the stage is set for a new chapter in American governance In a stunning political twist, Donald Trump has claimed victory in the 2024 US Presidential Election, securing his return to the White House as the 47th President of the United States. A Comeback for the Ages …

Why did Kamala Harris fail to secure majority in US Presidential elections | ANALYSIS
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Why did Kamala Harris fail to secure majority in US Presidential elections | ANALYSIS

India TV News  

In a meeting with one of America's most powerful unions in September at its Washington headquarters, Vice President Kamala Harris said she'd protect union jobs and workers' livelihoods better than Donald Trump. Still, the Harris campaign believed her signature issues - reproductive rights and Trump's divisiveness - would energize a coalition of women, Black voters, young Americans, independents and "Never …

Historic Election in the United States: Democrats and Republicans Battle It Out in Key Races
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Historic Election in the United States: Democrats and Republicans Battle It Out in Key Races

The Hindu  

Millions of Americans voted in the close race for the White House between Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump. The race is crucial for control of the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives. Harris focused her efforts on crucial battleground States, while Trump closed out his campaign in Michigan, where he has been struggling to attract voters …

US Election: Trump vs. Harris, a Battleground Showdown
Trending News
1 month, 2 weeks ago

US Election: Trump vs. Harris, a Battleground Showdown

India Today  

Americans will vote for their next president in the upcoming election. The first ballots were cast in the minutes after midnight in a tiny New Hampshire township along the US-Canada border. Trump and Harris criss-crossed key battleground states and delivered closing remarks. More than 78 million Americans have already cast their votes.

Trump and Harris Lock in Final Showdown Before 2024 Polls
Trending News
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Trump and Harris Lock in Final Showdown Before 2024 Polls

Firstpost  

In their closing speeches, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris claimed edge over the other in an election that pollsters have termed too close to call. Trump promised to lead the United States to ‘new heights of glory’, while Harris said she was ‘ready to be the next president’. The final pitches of Harris and Trump reflected the critical importance that …

Harris’s people look confident. The Trump campaign appears panicky: ‘He’s realizing that he could lose’
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Harris’s people look confident. The Trump campaign appears panicky: ‘He’s realizing that he could lose’

The Independent  

Sign up for the daily Inside Washington email for exclusive US coverage and analysis sent to your inbox Get our free Inside Washington email Please enter a valid email address Please enter a valid email address SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Those missteps include the disastrous decision to include …

Historic Campaigns Collide as Harris and Trump Lock in Final Showdown
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Historic Campaigns Collide as Harris and Trump Lock in Final Showdown

Deccan Chronicle  

In the final hours before Election Day, Kamala Harris and Donald Trump deliver their final pitches in Philadelphia, highlighting the importance of voter turnout in the close race. Both candidates emphasize the need for mobilization on Election Day, with Harris urging everyone to vote in Pennsylvania and Trump urging his supporters to show up and win.

Harris and Trump Battle It Out in Final Pennsylvania Push
Trending News
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Harris and Trump Battle It Out in Final Pennsylvania Push

India Today  

In the final days of the US presidential election, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris converge on Pennsylvania to urge voters to show up on Election Day. Both candidates emphasize economic themes and their commitment to the state's economy. Despite polls showing a close race, both candidates remain optimistic about their chances of victory.

Voters express what issues mattered as they marked their ballots
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Voters express what issues mattered as they marked their ballots

NPR  

Voters express what issues mattered as they marked their ballots In the final hours before the 2024 election season closes, the presidential campaigns are reaching out to voters in key swing states including North Carolina, Michigan and Nevada. MICHEL MARTIN, HOST: Across the country, a lot of people have already cast their ballots, but a lot of people haven't, and …

Trump and Harris have wrapped up campaigning. It's now up to voters
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Trump and Harris have wrapped up campaigning. It's now up to voters

NPR  

Trump and Harris have wrapped up campaigning. It's now up to voters STEVE INSKEEP, HOST: Last month in Philadelphia, I went for a run, ended up going up the "Rocky" steps - the ones Sylvester Stallone's character runs up in triumph during the movie, "Rocky." So after a comedian at last weekend's Trump event called Puerto Rico a, quote, "floating …

Five Key Reasons Why the Harris vs Trump Contest is So Close to Call
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Five Key Reasons Why the Harris vs Trump Contest is So Close to Call

Firstpost  

The 2024 US presidential election remains too close for any candidate to have a definitive lead. While Harris has raised more money, Trump is riding on anti-incumbency wave and has successfully tapped into anxieties around immigration and the Joe Biden administration's poor record at tackling illegal immigration. The election has also been influenced by the war in Ukraine and West …

Unprecedented Election: Trump or Harris Set to Decide the Future of the Nation
Top News
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Unprecedented Election: Trump or Harris Set to Decide the Future of the Nation

Associated Press  

The 2024 presidential election has defied expectations, with Donald Trump and Kamala Harris emerging as the top contenders. Trump's comeback bid, fueled by anger over inflation and immigration, has captivated the nation. Harris, on the other hand, has risen from the shadows of political obscurity to become a formidable contender. The outcome of this election will have profound implications for …

Harris and Trump race to the finish line with one last burst of rallies
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Harris and Trump race to the finish line with one last burst of rallies

NPR  

Harris and Trump race to the finish line with one last burst of rallies Hide caption Vice President Harris speaks during a campaign rally at the "Rocky Steps" in Philadelphia. Previous Next Angela Weiss/AFP via Getty Images Hide caption Former President Donald Trump speaks during a campaign rally at Van Andel Arena in Grand Rapids, Michigan early on Tuesday. Previous …

Here’s Harris’ path to winning
1 month, 2 weeks ago

Here’s Harris’ path to winning

Politico  

The vice president’s paid-media campaign, along with her allies’, has been laser-focused on two themes: positioning Harris as a middle-class champion, and protecting abortion rights. But the survey is a sign that she is stronger than it appears in the Blue Wall states of Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin — where Democrats’ gubernatorial candidates all won decisively two years ago — …

In the election home stretch, what are the candidates' closing arguments?
1 month, 3 weeks ago

In the election home stretch, what are the candidates' closing arguments?

NPR  

In the election home stretch, what are the candidates' closing arguments? SCOTT DETROW, HOST: We are going to close the show with the news story hanging over everything - the presidential election that's just two days away. Vice President Harris and former President Donald Trump are campaigning in swing states, fighting for every vote in a neck-and-neck race. GARRETT: Whether …

Trump and Harris crisscross campaign trail days out from Election Day
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Trump and Harris crisscross campaign trail days out from Election Day

NPR  

Trump and Harris crisscross campaign trail days out from Election Day toggle caption Elijah Nouvelage/AFP Americans have two days left to pick their new leader in a neck-and-neck presidential election likely decided by tens of thousands of votes in a handful of swing states. Former President Donald Trump hit Pennsylvania, North Carolina and Georgia on Sunday, while Vice President Harris …

Trump and Harris Clash in Wisconsin as Election Battle Rages on
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Trump and Harris Clash in Wisconsin as Election Battle Rages on

New Indian Express  

US Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump clashed over rhetoric in Wisconsin as they converged on Milwaukee for competing rallies in the final days of a volatile presidential race. Both held full days of campaign events, with Harris attending rallies and visiting a union hall, while Trump addressed a crowd in Warren, Michigan, where he expressed his …

Harris campaign says undecided voters are breaking their way — but warns Trump will falsely claim victory
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris campaign says undecided voters are breaking their way — but warns Trump will falsely claim victory

The Independent  

Sign up for the daily Inside Washington email for exclusive US coverage and analysis sent to your inbox Get our free Inside Washington email Please enter a valid email address Please enter a valid email address SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. According to senior Harris campaign officials, undecided voters …

US Election: 4 Days Left - What Polls Say, What Harris and Trump Are Up To
1 month, 3 weeks ago

US Election: 4 Days Left - What Polls Say, What Harris and Trump Are Up To

Al Jazeera  

The article focuses on the upcoming US presidential election and provides a detailed overview of the current political landscape. It highlights the key battleground states, the state of Michigan, and the contrasting approaches of Donald Trump and Kamala Harris. The article also provides insights into the economic concerns and the impact of immigration on the election outcome.

Harris's Fiery Rebuttal: A Battleground Tour for Democracy
Trending News
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris's Fiery Rebuttal: A Battleground Tour for Democracy

Live Mint  

Vice President Kamala Harris addressed a variety of rallies throughout the United States, emphasizing her campaign's focus on unity and democratic engagement. Despite facing opposition from protesters, Harris maintained her composure and addressed key policy concerns, such as abortion rights, healthcare, and economic issues. She also addressed the divisive rhetoric of former President Donald Trump and emphasized her commitment to …

Harris vs. Trump on voter turnout : Consider This from NPR : NPR
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris vs. Trump on voter turnout : Consider This from NPR : NPR

NPR  

How many ways can you tell someone to vote? There's the direct approach, from former president Donald Trump at a rally in Georgia., borrowing a page from Nike, telling supporters: "Just Vote. That's why you hear former first lady Michelle Obama reminding potential supporters of Vice President Kamala Harris that they don't have to tell anyone how they voted. First, …

Two Closing Arguments Show The Stark Choice Between Trump And Harris
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Two Closing Arguments Show The Stark Choice Between Trump And Harris

Huff Post  

This combination of photos shows Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump, left, speaking at a campaign event Sept. 25, 2024, in Mint Hill, N.C., and Democratic presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris, right, speaking a campaign event Oct. 19, 2024, in Atlanta. Less than 48 hours earlier inside Madison Square Garden, Trump called his Democratic opponent “a trainwreck who …

Harris Takes Aim at Trump's Chaos and Division at White House Rally
Top News
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris Takes Aim at Trump's Chaos and Division at White House Rally

Hindustan Times  

Democratic vice president Kamala Harris delivered a powerful closing argument to voters on Tuesday night, urging Americans to reject Donald Trump's chaos and division. She reminded the crowd that Trump stood at the same spot nearly four years ago and sent an armed mob to the Capitol, and that the election was a choice between a country rooted in freedom …

Harris vs. Trump: A Battle of Visions for America's Future
Top News
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris vs. Trump: A Battle of Visions for America's Future

Associated Press  

The 2024 presidential election is nearing its final stretch, with the two major candidates, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris, delivering their closing arguments in stark contrast to their earlier campaigns. Trump's rally, marked by crude and racist rhetoric, highlighted the divisive elements of his base, while Harris' formal speech at the White House underscored her commitment to unity and addressing …

Two closing arguments show the stark choice between Trump and Harris
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Two closing arguments show the stark choice between Trump and Harris

The Independent  

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Please enter a valid email address Please enter a valid email address SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Less than 48 hours earlier …

Closing arguments galore
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Closing arguments galore

Politico  

Closing arguments galore Presented by Former President Donald Trump arrives for a news conference at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Florida, on Tuesday, Oct. 29, 2024. Republican Party of Florida Chair Evan Power told Playbook that he was confident the GOP would be able to win more than half of the legislative races on Democrats’ list if not “a …

Harris's Closing Speech: A Call for Unity and Leadership
Trending News
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris's Closing Speech: A Call for Unity and Leadership

India Today  

Vice President Kamala Harris delivers a passionate closing address at a campaign rally, urging unity and leadership among Americans. She frames the upcoming election as a pivotal moment, reminding voters to move past division and embrace a forward-looking vision for the country. Harris highlights her commitment to putting the country over partisan divides, contrasting her platform with the dark period …

Trump's Lovefest Speech: A Battleground of Rhetoric and Reality
Trending News
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Trump's Lovefest Speech: A Battleground of Rhetoric and Reality

New Indian Express  

The 2024 US presidential election is nearing its conclusion, with two closing arguments highlighting the stark choice between Donald Trump and Joe Biden. Trump focuses on energizing his partisan base and reaching out to infrequent voters, while Biden emphasizes unity and a commitment to working-class priorities. Trump frames his comments in a positive light, highlighting the love and support he …

In final pitch to voters, Harris makes the case for her presidency : Consider This from NPR : NPR
1 month, 3 weeks ago

In final pitch to voters, Harris makes the case for her presidency : Consider This from NPR : NPR

NPR  

Harris makes her final pitch for her presidency Enlarge this image toggle caption Stephanie Scarbrough/AP Stephanie Scarbrough/AP On Tuesday night, one week before election day, Vice President Kamala Harris made her closing argument to the American people. Over about half an hour, Harris made her final pitch to voters, reviewing the agenda she would pursue as President, and arguing Donald …

Harris's Closing Argument: A Call for Unity and Hope
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris's Closing Argument: A Call for Unity and Hope

Al Jazeera  

Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris delivered a closing argument speech at the Ellipse in Washington, DC, on Tuesday. The speech focused on the importance of unity and the stakes of the election, reminding the crowd that she is the only candidate who can truly represent all Americans. Despite the tight race, Harris's speech aimed to motivate her supporters and inspire …

Trump's Closing Argument Venue Holds Deep Political Significance
Top News
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Trump's Closing Argument Venue Holds Deep Political Significance

Firstpost  

The article discusses the significance of Kamala Harris' venue for her closing argument, which is held in the same spot where Donald Trump incited a mob to attack the US Capitol on January 6, 2021. This move allows Harris to highlight the contrast between her and Trump and to present herself as the candidate for change.

Harris makes her closing argument
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Harris makes her closing argument

Politico  

The campaign believes the symbolic nature of the venue will bolster Harris’ closing message. Just as her team did with a stop in Houston last week to elevate abortion rights, they’re using Tuesday night’s location to telegraph a larger, national message: By returning to a site where Trump infamously delivered his speech on Jan. 6, 2021, in which he urged …

‘More chaos’: Harris contrasts Trump’s presidency against her future one
1 month, 3 weeks ago

‘More chaos’: Harris contrasts Trump’s presidency against her future one

Politico  

The vice president vowed in her speech to put the country first, above party and herself, and to serve as a president for both Republicans and Democrats. It’s a message targeted directly at the remaining undecided Americans, as her campaign looks to sway young and low-information voters in the final week, as well as suburban women, soft Republicans, moderates and …

Kamala Harris to Deliver Closing Argument at Site of Trump's January 6 Speech
1 month, 3 weeks ago

Kamala Harris to Deliver Closing Argument at Site of Trump's January 6 Speech

New Indian Express  

Kamala Harris will deliver her campaign's closing argument from the same spot in Washington where Republican Donald Trump helped incite a mob that attacked the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021. She will draw a contrast between her vision for the country and Trump's continued lies about the 2020 election, highlighting the risks she says his return to the White …

At the site of Trump’s Jan. 6 rally, Harris makes her closing pitch for the campaign
1 month, 3 weeks ago

At the site of Trump’s Jan. 6 rally, Harris makes her closing pitch for the campaign

NPR  

At the site of Trump’s Jan. 6 rally, Harris makes her closing pitch for the campaign toggle caption Kent Nishimura/Getty Images A week before Election Day, Vice President Harris used the spot where her opponent held his Jan. 6, 2021 rally to give a sweeping speech laying out her priorities and excoriating her opponent for his character and past actions. …

MSNBC political analyst raises red flag over major Harris campaign misstep
1 month, 4 weeks ago

MSNBC political analyst raises red flag over major Harris campaign misstep

Raw Story  

During her appearance on Friday's episode of "Morning Joe," a frantic Elise Jordan explained that Donald Trump's presidential campaign has hit upon an effective message that has played out for weeks with little to no push-back from Vice President Kamala Harris' team. As the political analyst detailed, an ad pinning blame on a Trump administration policy has been highly effective …

What are Harris’ and Trump’s swing-state strategies for the final stretch?
1 month, 4 weeks ago

What are Harris’ and Trump’s swing-state strategies for the final stretch?

LA Times  

In the final stretch of an exceedingly tight presidential race, Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Trump are targeting people’s fears as they barnstorm across the country to eke out wins in seven battleground states where polls show razor-thin margins. “We have been inundated in ways that I couldn’t even imagine.” Dan Kanninen, the Harris campaign’s battleground states director, …

Harris Warns of Election Night Uncertainty as Trump's Victory Claim Looms
1 month, 4 weeks ago

Harris Warns of Election Night Uncertainty as Trump's Victory Claim Looms

Live Mint  

Vice President Kamala Harris expresses readiness against Donald Trump's potential victory claim and prepares for election night uncertainty. In an interview, she emphasizes her campaign's preparedness for any scenario, particularly given Trump's history of challenging election results. The memo from the Harris campaign and the DNC highlights the team's extensive preparations, including veteran lawyers working on multiple scenarios and coordinating …

Harris calls Trump 'unhinged', will deliver 'closing argument' at Capitol siege site
2 months ago

Harris calls Trump 'unhinged', will deliver 'closing argument' at Capitol siege site

Raw Story  

Vice President Kamala Harris outlined plans to make her "closing arguments" against former president Donald Trump next Tuesday by returning to the site near the White House where Trump addressed supporters before they stormed the Capitol in January 2021. Kamala Harris on Wednesday said Donald Trump was "increasingly unhinged" and called her US election rival's reported praise for Adolf Hitler …

Harris' campaign is including dire warnings about a Trump presidency
2 months ago

Harris' campaign is including dire warnings about a Trump presidency

NPR  

Harris' campaign is including dire warnings about a Trump presidency Vice President Harris has shifted to an anti-Trump focus. VICE PRESIDENT KAMALA HARRIS: Donald Trump is increasingly unhinged and unstable. Marc Lotter, who served in the Trump administration and now works at a pro-Trump think tank, argues Harris' warnings will ring hollow with a lot of voters who already lived …

Harris To Deliver Closing Message At The Site Of Trump's Jan. 6 Speech
2 months ago

Harris To Deliver Closing Message At The Site Of Trump's Jan. 6 Speech

Huff Post  

LOADING ERROR LOADING Vice President Kamala Harris will deliver the closing message of her presidential campaign on Oct. 29 at the site where Donald Trump instigated the Jan. 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol after losing the 2020 election to Joe Biden. A senior Harris campaign official said the choice of the Ellipse, the circular park just south of …

Harris and Trump Battle It Out in Final 15-Day Sprint to Election Day
Trending News
54 years, 11 months ago

Harris and Trump Battle It Out in Final 15-Day Sprint to Election Day

CNN  

Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump continue their intense campaigning in battleground states, focusing on key groups of voters to secure their support in the upcoming election. Harris will hold a series of events in suburban Blue Wall counties, while Trump holds three events in North Carolina, the state that provided him with his narrowest margin of …

Trump and Harris' closing messages to Republicans are as different as they come
2 months ago

Trump and Harris' closing messages to Republicans are as different as they come

NPR  

Trump and Harris' closing messages to Republicans are as different as they come toggle caption Kamil Krzaczynski/AFP via Getty Images GREENVILLE, N.C. — With just over two weeks to go until voting closes on Election Day, Vice President Harris and former President Donald Trump spent Monday campaigning in swing states focused on a voting bloc key to victory: Republicans. Sponsor …

Trump Dines at McDonald's, Harris Speaks at Church in Swing State Push
2 months ago

Trump Dines at McDonald's, Harris Speaks at Church in Swing State Push

Al Jazeera  

US presidential candidates Donald Trump and Kamala Harris have been campaigning in battleground states of Pennsylvania and Georgia in the lead-up to Election Day. Trump visited a McDonald's in suburban Philadelphia, where he demonstrated his expertise in dunking fries in oil and wearing an apron over his shirt and tie. Harris participated in two worship services in Georgia, emphasizing the …

Discover Related