
‘Failure of love is not a crime’: Odisha HC quashes rape charges against cop, quotes Simone de Beauvoir
Live MintThe Odisha High Court has quashed a rape complaint filed by a woman against her partner of nine years. The Odisha HC observed that the relationship not culminating into marriage could be a source of personal grievance, but ‘failure of love is not a crime’. “The law does not extend its protection to every broken promise nor does it impose criminality upon every failed relationship. That the relationship did not culminate in marriage may be a source of personal grievance, but the failure of love is not a crime, nor does the law transform disappointment into deception,” Hindustan Times quoted Justice Sanjeeb Panigrahi said in his February 14 verdict. The man and the woman entered into a relationship in 2012, when both were competent, consenting adults, capable of making their own choices, of exercising their own will, and of shaping their own futures,” the Odisha High Court said.
History of this topic

Woman can't claim rape if she was in long-term live-in: Supreme Court
Hindustan Times
Rape cases involving false marriage promises need clear evidence: Delhi HC
Hindustan Times
If A Man's Intention While Making Promise To Marry Is To Deceive A Girl Into Sexual Relations, Her Consent Gets Vitiated: Bombay High Court
Live Law
'Presumption That Woman Engages In Intimacy Only To Marry Is Patriarchal': Orissa HC Questions Criminalising Sex On False Promise Of Marriage
Live Law
'Failure Of Love Not A Crime': Orissa HC Quashes Rape Charges Against Man Accused Of Sex On False Promise Of Marriage
Live Law
DMK MP slams Chhattisgarh High Court ruling, demands India criminalise marital rape
India Today
Mere Refusal To Marry Does Not Constitute Offence Of Cheating Unless Ingredients U/S 90 Of IPC Are Met: Gauhati High Court
Live Law
'Consensual Relationship Turned Sour': Madras High Court Acquits Man Convicted For Committing Rape On False Promise Of Marriage
Live Law
Rape On False Marriage Promise A Reprehensible Offence, Act Can't Be 'Executed' By A Subsequent Marriage Offer : Allahabad HC
Live Law
Nowadays There Can Be No Presumption That Victim Would Always Tell Entire Story Truthfully In Rape Cases: Allahabad High Court
Live Law
Know The Law | When Can Sex On Promise To Marry Amount To Offence Of Rape?
Live Law
Know The Law | When Can Sex On Promise To Marry Amount To Offence Of Rape?
Live Law
Rape On False Promise To Marry Requires Proof That Physical Relationships Was Only Based On Marriage Promise : Supreme Court
Live Law
Karnataka High Court Quashes Rape Charges Against Live-In Partner After 22-Year-Long Relationship
Live Law
Man Cannot Be Held Guilty Of False Promise To Marry When Victim Willingly Consented To Physical Relationship: Calcutta High Court
Live Law
'Consensual Relationship without Misconception of Fact': Kerala HC Quashes Rape Case Filed after 13 Years
News 18
Merely Because Love Wanes Away With Time, Consensual Acts Between Two Adults Cannot Be Called Rape: Karnataka High Court
Live Law
India marital rape: Woman accuses husband of ‘unnatural sex’ but judge says it is not a crime in marriage
CNN
If Consent Of Woman Was Based On False Promise Of Marriage From Inception, Offence Of Rape Is Made Out : Supreme Court
Live Law
CJI says petitions to criminalise marital rape to be listed in mid-October
The Hindu
How are ‘false promise to marry’ cases treated in the new criminal law Bill? | Explained
The Hindu
Karnataka HC rebukes woman for alleging rape against man she dated for 6 years; man cleared of all charges
Firstpost
“Rape Law Misused As A Weapon By Females Upon Differences With Male Counterpart”: Uttarakhand High Court
Live Law
'Not A Case Of False Promise Of Marriage': Gujarat High Court Quashes Second Rape Case Against Man
Live Law
Consensual sex not rape if promise of marriage broken: Orissa High Court
Firstpost
Consensual sex not rape if promise of marriage is broken: Orissa High Court
India TV News![[False Promise To Marry] One Person Can't Be Prosecuted For Rape Merely Because Mutual Relationship Turned Sour: Bombay High Court](/static/images/error.jpg)
[False Promise To Marry] One Person Can't Be Prosecuted For Rape Merely Because Mutual Relationship Turned Sour: Bombay High Court
Live Law
Mere Breach Of Promise Not Equivalent To Giving False Promise To Marry: Madhya Pradesh High Court Quashes Rape Case
Live Law
Length Of Relationship Considerable Factor In Rape Case Over False Promise To Marry: Karnataka High Court
Live Law
'Consensual Relationship, Promise To Marry Was Not False': Kerala High Court Quashes Rape Case
Live Law
Odisha court hands out 20 year jail to man against whom wife had levelled rape charge
The Hindu
Failed Relationship Not Ground To Lodge FIR For Repeated Rape U/S 376(2)(n) IPC: Andhra Pradesh High Court
Live Law
Promise Of Marriage Made In Good Faith But Subsequently Not Fulfilled : Supreme Court Quashes Rape Case
Live Law
Not Rape If Sexual Relationship Between Willing Partners Doesn’t End In Marriage: Kerala HC
News 18
Subsequent Refusal To Marry After Sex Not Sufficient To Constitute Offence Of Rape: Kerala High Court
Live Law
Relationship Turning Sour Later Will Not Attract Offence Of Rape: Kerala High Court Reserves Verdict In Central Govt Counsel's Bail Plea
Live Law
The Delhi High Court’s split verdict on marital rape needs resolution
The Hindu
Marital Rape And Right To Equality: What Karnataka HC Had Said Before Delhi HC Split Verdict
ABP News
Marital rape a crime? Delhi HC verdict split
Hindustan Times
A far-reaching verdict that ends a regressive exception
The Hindu
A win for justice
Live Mint
Marital rape | Process on to amend criminal laws: Government
The Hindu
Marital rape debate: Arguments for and against criminalisation explained
Op India
Mere Refusal To Marry After Sexual Relations Not Offence of Cheating : Bombay High Court
Live Law
'Complainant Was Conscious Of The Fact That Marriage May Not Take Place': Madras High Court Dismisses Rape Charges On False Promise To Marry
Live Law
Maharashtra: 4 held for threatening man over failed love affair
India Today
Can't Use 'Astrological Incompatibility' To Avoid Rape Charges On False Promise Of Marriage – Bombay High Court
Live Law
That's how love kills in India, literally
India Today
Why hasn’t marital rape been criminalised in India yet?
The HinduDiscover Related






































