
The politics of mercy petitions
Deccan ChronicleThe Supreme Court on Tuesday rejected Yakub Abdul Razak Memon’s curative review petition, setting off the countdown to July 30, the date of his hanging. On June 26, 2012, the office of President Patil, in a widely reported press release, claimed, “The President is not supposed to act on her own judgment but is mandated to act in accordance with the aid and advice of the government in terms of Article 74 of the Constitution.” A constitution bench of the Supreme Court of India, while explaining the scope of Article 72 in the matter of Kehar Singh vs Union of India held: “The President in exercise of power under Article 72 is entitled to go into the merits of the case notwithstanding it has been judicially concluded. As on May 21, 2010, four mercy petitions were pending with the MHA and 25 with the President of India, after the President had commuted the death sentence of R. Govindaswamy on November 23, 2009. One June 23, 2010, the President’s secretariat in response to a Right to Information request confirmed that they were in fact 25 mercy petitions pending and in three cases the death penalty had been commuted to life benefiting nine death row convicts. The principal is no less important for disposal of mercy petitions.” Chief Justice Bhagwati, in his famous dissent in the Bachan Singh case on capital punishment, observed there is no objective manner of awarding the death penalty and therefore it falls foul of Article 14.
History of this topic

'Either You Decide Or We'll Hear' : Supreme Court Gives Last Chance To Union On Balwant Singh's Mercy Plea, Posts On March 18
Live Law
Court's 'last opportunity' to Centre to decide on Beant Singh killer's mercy plea
India Today
State Must Not Defeat Purpose Of Death Sentence By Showing Laxity In Implementation: Supreme Court
Live Law
'Sensitive Matter': SC Grants 4 More Weeks To Centre In Balwant Singh's Mercy Petition
ABP News
SC Gives Centre 4 Weeks to Decide on Rajoana's Mercy Petition
Deccan Chronicle
'Sensitive Matter' : Union Seeks More Time On Balwant Singh's Mercy Petition; Supreme Court Adjourns Hearing By 4 Weeks
Live Law
Beant Singh assassination convict Rajoana's mercy plea sensitive matter: Centre to SC
New Indian Express
Beant Singh Assassination: SC Urges President Murmu To Decide On Killer's Mercy Plea In 2 weeks
ABP News
Supreme Court Requests President To Decide Death Row Convict Balwant Singh's Mercy Petition In 2 Weeks
Live Law
SC urges President to decide Balwant Singh's mercy plea in two weeks or it will consider interim relief
New Indian Express
Expedite Beant Singh's killer's mercy plea: Supreme Court to President's Office
India Today
President Murmu rejects mercy plea of Pak terrorist convicted in Red Fort attack case
Deccan Chronicle
Fake List of Politicians and Actors Linked to Yakub Memon's Mercy Petition
The Quint
President Murmu rejects mercy plea of convict for raping & killing 4-year-old girl in Maharashtra
India TV News
'What Is The Use Of Death Sentence, If It Is To Be Executed After 20-25 Years?' : Supreme Court Asks On Plea Challenging Commutation
Live Law
Supreme Court Sets April 30 Deadline For Centre To Decide Death Row Convict Balwant Singh Rajoana's Mercy Petition
Live Law
Motilal Nehru Too Had Petitioned For Release Of His Son: Historian, Vikram Sampath To Kailashnath Adhikari, MD, Governance Now
ABP News
Balwant Singh Rajoana's Mercy Plea : Supreme Court Grants 2 Weeks Time For Centre To Decide As Last Chance
Live Law
Decide Death Row Convict Balwant Singh Rajoana's Mercy Plea By Jan 25, Supreme Court Asks Centre
Live Law
SC seeks Centre’s reply on death row convict’s mercy plea pending for 8 years
Hindustan Times![Four Convicts Hanged To Death At Tihar Jail In Nirbhaya Case After Late Night Legal Battles [Read Timeline]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Four Convicts Hanged To Death At Tihar Jail In Nirbhaya Case After Late Night Legal Battles [Read Timeline]
Live Law![Nirbhaya Case : SC Dismisses Final Plea Of Convicts To Stay Execution After Past Midnight Hearing [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Nirbhaya Case : SC Dismisses Final Plea Of Convicts To Stay Execution After Past Midnight Hearing [Read Order]
Live Law
Nirbhaya case convicts to be hanged on March 20
Op India
2012 Delhi gang rape case: Tihar jail authorities move court seeking fresh date for hanging; matter to be heard at 2 pm
Firstpost
President rejects 2012 Delhi gangrape convict Pawan Gupta’s mercy petition; all legal remedies available to perpetrators exhausted
Firstpost
2012 Delhi gangrape case: Convicts won't be hanged tomorrow, rules court; Pawan Gupta filed mercy petition with president
Firstpost
Nirbhaya case: Delhi govt recommends rejecting mercy plea of convict Pawan Gupta
India TV News
2012 Delhi gangrape case: Delhi court reserves order on convict Pawan Gupta's petition seeking stay on execution
Firstpost
Nirbhaya case: Execution of convicts delayed again, Patiala House Court stays and defers matter
Op India
2012 Delhi gangrape case: SC dismisses Pawan Gupta's curative plea; Delhi court dismisses plea to stay execution of death warrant, hearing at 2 pm today
Firstpost![[Breaking] Nirbhaya Case : Delhi Court Issues Fresh Death Warrants For Hanging Of 4 Convicts On March 3 At 6 AM](/static/images/error.jpg)
[Breaking] Nirbhaya Case : Delhi Court Issues Fresh Death Warrants For Hanging Of 4 Convicts On March 3 At 6 AM
Live Law
Aaj Ki Baat Feb 13: Death row convicts who commit heinous crimes must not be allowed to file mercy petitions
India TV News
Nirbhaya Case : SC Dismisses Convict Vinay Sharma's Challenge Against Mercy Rejection
Live Law
Nirbhaya Convict Cites Mental Illness To Challenge Rejection Of Mercy Petition In SC
Live Law
Nirbhaya Case : SC Allows Centre To Move Trial Court For Fresh Death Warrants
Live Law![Nirbhaya Case : SC Adjourns Hearing Of Centre's Appeal Against Stay On Executions Till Feb 11 [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Nirbhaya Case : SC Adjourns Hearing Of Centre's Appeal Against Stay On Executions Till Feb 11 [Read Order]
Live Law
Nirbhaya Case: SC Agrees To Hear Tomorrow Centre's Appeal Against Delhi HC Order Refusing To Vacate Stay On Executions
Live Law![[Breaking] Nirbhaya Case : Delhi HC Refuses To Set Aside Trial Court's Stay On Execution; Directs Convicts To Exercise Legal Remedies Within 7 Days [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
[Breaking] Nirbhaya Case : Delhi HC Refuses To Set Aside Trial Court's Stay On Execution; Directs Convicts To Exercise Legal Remedies Within 7 Days [Read Judgment]
Live Law
Nirbhaya case: A game of petitions
India Today
2012 Delhi gangrape case: President Ram Nath Kovind rejects clemency petition of death row convict Vinay Kumar Sharma
Firstpost![[Breaking] Delhi Court Stays Hanging Of Four Convicts In Nirbhaya Case Until Further Orders](/static/images/error.jpg)
[Breaking] Delhi Court Stays Hanging Of Four Convicts In Nirbhaya Case Until Further Orders
Live Law
No hanging tomorrow: Delhi court stays execution of Nirbhaya case convicts
India Today
Nirbhaya gangrape convict Vinay Sharma files mercy plea
India TV News
SC dismisses 2012 Delhi gangrape convict Mukesh Singh's appeal against rejection of mercy plea; fellow convict files curative petition challenging execution
Firstpost![[Breaking] SC Dismisses Nirbhaya Convict Mukesh's Plea Against Mercy Rejection By President [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
[Breaking] SC Dismisses Nirbhaya Convict Mukesh's Plea Against Mercy Rejection By President [Read Order]
Live Law
Nirbhaya Case : 'Mercy Rejection Cannot Be Challenged Saying That President Acted Fast', Submits SG; SC Reserves Order On Mukesh's Plea
Live Law
'Execution case will be given top priority,' SC says after 2012 Delhi gangrape convict seeks urgent hearing against rejection of mercy plea by President
Firstpost
Nirbhaya Convict Seeks SC Hearing Against Mercy Plea Rejection
The Quint
Nirbhaya rapists get no mercy, to hang on February 1
Deccan Chronicle
December 2012 gang rape case: Court issues fresh death warrant after President rejects mercy petition of Mukesh Singh
Hindustan TimesDiscover Related










































