
Admission that SC did not ask for Aadhaar-SIM linkage points at govt's refusal to accept alternative identification methods
FirstpostThe State, in the Aadhaar hearings yesterday, finally admitted that there never was any direction from the SC to mandatorily link Aadhaar to SIM cards. Lack of clarity on the issue led to the government widely citing the Supreme Court order in question to not only mandate Aadhaar SIM linking but also as proof of Court’s support to Aadhaar. The DoT order mandating the linkage In particular, and as pointed out by the Supreme Court in yesterday’s Aadhaar hearings, the Court had never specified that the verification was to be conducted via Aadhaar only. No SC order mandating Aadhaar SIM linkage Two crucial factors, which were widely misinterpreted, based on these events are: the Supreme Court never mandated the verification to be conducted via Aadhaar, and second, it was the DoT’s decision to use Aadhaar mandatorily. It was further argued that the case had ‘approved’ Aadhaar based verification : “In the case of Lokniti Foundation v. Union of India & Ors., this Court has disposed of the writ petition while approving the Aadhaar based verification of existing and new mobile number subscribers and upon being satisfied that an effective process has been evolved to ensure identity verification.” A similar paragraph, in fact, also finds place in other documents like the Draft Bill for Human DNA Profiling, in the discussion on constitutional law on privacy.
History of this topic

EPIC-Aadhaar Linking Controversy: EC Faces Privacy Concerns and Legal Hurdles
The Hindu
Aadhaar-PAn link not infringement of fundamental rights: Orissa high court
Hindustan Times
Private entities can now use Aadhaar authentication
Hindustan Times
New SIM Card Rules: Aadhaar-based biometric verification now mandatory
India TV News
'No Public Interest': Delhi HC Directs Roster Bench To Hear Lawyer's Plea For Govt Life Insurance Benefits Without Furnishing His Aadhaar
Live Law
Supreme Court asks UIDAI, Manipur govt to ensure Aadhaar cards are provided to displaced persons
India TV News
People Can’t Be Denied Benefits Of Welfare Schemes Only Because They Don’t Possess Aadhaar Card Or Mobile Number: Orissa High Court
Live Law
Expanding Aadhaar to private entities is risky
Hindustan Times
Secure Aadhaar data from misuse
Hindustan Times
Madras High Court Dismisses PIL Against Insistence On Aadhaar Authentication With Electricity Connection
Live Law
Explained: The plea in Supreme Court challenging Aadhaar-Voter ID card linking
Firstpost
Supreme Court Of India Issues Notice On Plea Challenging Aadhaar-Voter ID Card Linkage
Live Law
SC to Examine Plea Challenging Centre's Decision to Link Electoral Roll Data with Aadhaar
News 18
SC to examine plea challenging decision to link electoral roll data with Aadhaar
Deccan Chronicle
SC tags plea challenging Aadhaar-voter ID linking with other pending cases, says detailed hearing required
India Today
EC to start campaign to link voter ID with Aadhaar from August 1. Check details
Live Mint
SC asks Cong leader to approach HC against law linking Aadhaar with Voter ID
Live Mint
Supreme Court Directs UIDAI To Issue Aadhaar Cards To Sex Workers Without Insisting On Proof Of Residence
Live Law
Aadhaar and Voter ID link: Joining the strands of the debate
Hindustan Times
Aadhaar Verdict Review: SC Judgement on Pleas Against Aadhaar Scheme Validity Tomorrow
News 18
Legal notice to Kerala government for making Aadhaar mandatory for ILGMS log in
The Hindu![Examining Proposal To Link Aadhaar With Election Cards: Ministry Of Law And Justice [Read Statement]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Examining Proposal To Link Aadhaar With Election Cards: Ministry Of Law And Justice [Read Statement]
Live Law![PAN Not To Be Declared Inoperative Due To Non-Linking With Aadhaar Until Aadhaar Act Attains Finality: Gujarat HC [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
PAN Not To Be Declared Inoperative Due To Non-Linking With Aadhaar Until Aadhaar Act Attains Finality: Gujarat HC [Read Order]
Live Law
SC seeks govt’s response on use of Aadhaar as ID
Deccan Chronicle
Supreme Court seeks government reply to plea on Aadhaar data use by private firms
The Hindu![SC Issues Notice On Plea Against Amendment Allowing Use Of Aadhaar Data By Private Entities [Read Petition]](/static/images/error.jpg)
SC Issues Notice On Plea Against Amendment Allowing Use Of Aadhaar Data By Private Entities [Read Petition]
Live Law
SC refuses to entertain plea seeking linking of Aadhaar with social media accounts
The Hindu
Decide to link Aadhar card with property transactions: Punjab & Haryana High Court
India TV News![Plea In SC Seeks Linkage Of Social Media Accounts With Aadhaar [Read Petition]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Plea In SC Seeks Linkage Of Social Media Accounts With Aadhaar [Read Petition]
Live Law
Supreme Court asks government whether it plans to link social media and Aadhaar
The Hindu
Aadhaar-social media account linkage: Facebook’s concern on privacy a ‘red herring’, Tamil Nadu govt. tells Supreme Court
The Hindu
Content management: On Aadhaar-social media linkage
The Hindu
Link Aadhaar to Facebook? Apex court seeks response from government
Live Mint
Aadhaar bill passed, Ordinance on its use not valid anymore: Centre tells High Court
India TV News
Rajya Sabha clears bill on voluntary use of Aadhaar as ID proof
Live Mint
Aadhaar Bill seeking its use as ID to open bank accounts passes in Lok Sabha
India Today
Jamaica SC Follows Aadhaar Dissent to Strike Down Its ID System
The Quint
Challenge Against Aadhaar Ordinance: Delhi HC Seeks Centre's Response
Live Law
President gives nod to ordinance that allows Aadhaar as valid ID proof in certain cases
Firstpost
President's nod to ordinance for voluntary use of Aadhaar as ID proof for bank account, SIM
India TV News
The Aadhaar ordinance raises serious constitutional concerns
Hindustan Times
Cabinet clears voluntary use of Aadhaar as identity proof
The Hindu
Aadhaar-PAN Linking Mandatory; To Be Completed By March 31, Says CBDT
Live Law
To file ITRs, linking Aadhaar-PAN is mandatory by March 31: CBDT
Live Mint
A renewed attack on privacy: on Aadhaar Bill
The Hindu
SC Declines Urgent Hearing Of PIL Seeking Linking Of Aadhaar & Voter IDs
Live Law![Calcutta HC Questions Non Verification Of Declarations Made During Aadhaar Enrollment [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Calcutta HC Questions Non Verification Of Declarations Made During Aadhaar Enrollment [Read Judgment]
Live Law
Aadhaar card is no more mandatory for SIM cards and bank accounts
India Today
Lok Sabha passes Bill to amend Aadhaar Act
The Hindu
Aadhaar Amendment Bill grants broad, vague powers; privacy needs to be priority
FirstpostDiscover Related












































