
IND vs ENG: Shivam Dube-Harshit Rana swap raises debate over concussion sub rule
The HinduConcussion substitute or Impact Player. That has been the debate ever since Harshit Rana was allowed to be a concussion substitute for Shivam Dube during India’s fourth T20I against England at the Maharashtra Cricket Association stadium in Pune on Friday. There is no doubt the concussion sub after Dube took a blow on his helmet before being run out in the last over wasn’t the sole factor for England surrendering in a tense chase. But the fact that Rana – a pace bowler who is no mug with the bat – was allowed to replace Dube – a batting allrounder whose medium pace has seldom been utilised by the Men in Blue over the last 12 months – has raised a lot of questions over the match referee Javagal Srinath’s decision. No doubt there is a case for Srinath to have possibly suggested Ramandeep Singh as a like-for-like replacement instead of approving Rana as a concussion sub for India’s bowling essay.
History of this topic

Harshit Rana shuts down concussion-sub controversy once and for all, issues definitive 'I'm not bothered' response
Hindustan Times
‘If the concussion sub had been done correctly…’: Pietersen's no-nonsense take on India's T20I series win over England
Hindustan Times
'Shivam Dube shut him up': England legend handed a brutal takedown over concussion sub controversy
Hindustan Times
Gavaskar slams Team India management over concussion substitution controversy: 'There's nothing like-for-like'
Firstpost
Kevin Pietersen breaks into laughter hearing Gautam Gambhir's hilarious response to concussion sub controversy
Firstpost
Sunil Gavaskar slams Suryakumar Yadav, Gautam Gambhir over concussion substitute controversy; ‘Such acts…’
Live Mint
Shivam Dube must have been happy with risk he took: Jos Buttler takes another dig
India Today
Sunil Gavaskar lashes out at India for Shivam Dube controversy: He was not concussed
India Today
Ravichandran Ashwin stunned by Harshit Rana’s concussion substitute ruling, calls it ‘pure cricketing miscalculation’
Live Mint
Concussion substitute Harshit Rana dropped for 5th T20I despite three wickets in fourth match, Shami returns
India TV News
England left with little recourse over controversial concussion substitute
The Independent
ICC needs to ensure concussion-sub rule is not misused
The Hindu
IND vs ENG: Shivam Dube-Harshit Rana swap raises debate over concussion sub rule
The Hindu
England will admit, maybe not publicly, that Harshit Rana for Shivam Dube was not the problem
Hindustan Times
Explained: Did Harshit Rana qualify as a like-for-like replacement for Shivam Dube during 4th India-England T20?
Firstpost
IND vs ENG: 'An out-and-out bowler replacing...', Experts miffed after Harshit replaces Dube as concussion substitute in 4th T20
Firstpost
'England would've done same': Vaughan's puzzling U-turn despite social media fury over India's Rana-Dube concussion sub
Hindustan Times
We don't agree: Jos Buttler on team India's concussion sub
Deccan Chronicle
IND vs ENG: 'We don't agree with that,' Buttler fumes at Harshit coming on as concussion substitute for Dube
Firstpost
Harshit Rana-Shivam Dube concussion substitute controversy: India coach plays safe, says ‘it is out of our hands’
Live Mint
Jos Buttler fumes over India’s concussion sub in 4th T20I, says Harshit Rana ‘not a like-for-like replacement’ for Dube
Live Mint
'Either Dube put on 25 mph or Rana…': Jos Buttler's sarcastic dig at Team India on concussion substitute controversy
Hindustan Times
Jos Buttler fumes, Kevin Pietersen shocked as Harshit Rana for Shivam Dube concussion sub raises huge controversy
Hindustan Times
ICC Concussion Sub laws: India did no wrong by bringing Harshit Rana in place of Shivam Dube; full explainer
Hindustan Times
Concussion controversy: Who said what as India captain keeps mum after 4th T20I
India Today
Kevin Pietersen extends support to Harshit Rana after concussion-sub controversy
India Today
How India fielded Harshit as concussion substitute for Dube? Morne Morkel reveals
India Today
Controversial concussion sub Harshit Rana leads India to series-winning T20 victory over England
The Independent
Jos Buttler incensed as controversial concussion sub Harshit Rana inspires India
The Independent
Harshit not a like-for-like replacement, says Buttler
The Hindu
IND vs ENG, 4th T20I: Jos Buttler says Harshit Rana was not like-for-like replacement for Shivam Dube
The Hindu
IND Vs ENG, 4th T20I: KKR Pacer Marks T20I Debut As Concussion Substitute With Match-Winning Figures
ABP News
Concussion sub Harshit Rana takes 3-33 as India seals T20 series win against England
Associated Press
Concussion substitute rules explained: What the ICC playing conditions say?
The Hindu
Harshit Rana first Indian cricketer to make T20I debut as concussion sub, wins match vs England by replacing Shivam Dube
Hindustan Times
India beat England to seal T20 cricket series as sub Rana vexes Buttler
Al Jazeera
Harshit Rana shrugs off concussion controversy: Still a dream debut for me
India Today
Harshit Rana not like-for-like replacement for Shivam Dube: Jos Buttler
India Today
Concussion sub controversy explained: Harshit Rana replaces Dube, puzzles pundits
India Today
Harshit Rana makes T20I debut as concussion substitute against England in Pune
India Today
ENG vs NZ 2nd Test: Do you know about concussion substitute rule? Here are all details
India TV News
Mark Taylor warns against abuse of concussion substitute rule, says should be used fairly and responsibly
India TV News
Mark Taylor warns against abuse of concussion substitute rule
The Hindu
There is one important breach of protocol that happened: Sanjay Manjrekar on India's concussion substitute row
India TV News
India vs West Indies: Virat Kohli backs concussion substitute rule
The Hindu
India vs West Indies: Virat Kohli endorses ICC rule on concussion substitutes after Darren Bravo retires hurt
FirstpostDiscover Related






































