Opinion: Fighting vaccine disinformation is crucial to ending the pandemic
3 years, 3 months ago

Opinion: Fighting vaccine disinformation is crucial to ending the pandemic

CNN  

Editor’s Note: Ann M. Ravel is the Digital Deception Project director at MapLight and previously served as chair of the Federal Election Commission. According to its policy, YouTube prohibits “content that spreads medical misinformation that contradicts local health authorities’ or the World Health Organization’s medical information about COVID-19.” While these short suspensions are grabbing headlines, they’re also obscuring the larger problem that major social media companies are utterly failing to prevent disinformation from spreading rampantly and wreaking havoc on public health. Here’s what these companies should do: Enhance monitoring of high-reach accounts Anyone with more than 50,000 followers — that is, a person that we’ve determined has “high reach” on social media — and a history of sharing disinformation about Covid-19 should have their posts subjected to a pre-clearance policy in which the content can be fact-checked before it’s posted online and damage has already been done. Every month, social media companies are asked to report to the European Commission how they’re working to address Covid-19 disinformation. There isn’t a silver bullet to eliminate the Covid-19 disinformation that has become so prominent online, so we need social media companies and our government to do everything they can to chip away at the problem.

Social Media Online Companies Disinformation Twitter Facebook Vaccine Social Media Companies  facebook  disinformation  public  companies  online  twitter  crucial  pandemic  social  media  covid19  fighting  opinion  ending  health  vaccine

History of this topic

Want to combat online misinformation? Regulate the architecture of social media platforms, not their content
1 month, 1 week ago

Want to combat online misinformation? Regulate the architecture of social media platforms, not their content

ABC  

Over the past couple of decades, social media platforms have evolved from simple networking sites into powerful forces that shape public opinion, influence elections, impact public health, and affect social cohesion. The growing role of social media platforms in disseminating information and the need to ensure the integrity of this information make discussions about regulation more urgent than ever. Focus …

One-third of Americans don’t trust the COVID vaccines, survey finds
1 month, 2 weeks ago

One-third of Americans don’t trust the COVID vaccines, survey finds

Salon  

Across the U.S., 35% of adults reported that they did not trust COVID-19 vaccines, without much variation across years 2021-2023, according to a survey published in the journal Vaccine: X this week. Vaccine hesitancy is one piece of a growing distrust in public health exacerbated by the government’s pandemic response that many experts fear will only deepen with the new …

White House pressured Facebook over some COVID-19 content during the pandemic, Zuckerberg says
3 months, 4 weeks ago

White House pressured Facebook over some COVID-19 content during the pandemic, Zuckerberg says

LA Times  

Meta Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg testifies before a joint hearing of the Commerce and Judiciary committees on Capitol Hill in Washington in 2018. Meta Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg says senior Biden administration officials pressured Facebook to “censor” some COVID-19 content during the pandemic and vowed that the social media giant would push back if it faced such demands again. In …

Supreme Court Rules That US Government Can Continue Talking to Social Media Companies
54 years, 11 months ago

Supreme Court Rules That US Government Can Continue Talking to Social Media Companies

Wired  

Today, the Supreme Court ruled in a 6–3 decision that the plaintiffs who'd sued the US government for allegedly violating the First Amendment—by communicating with social media companies about misleading and harmful content on their platforms—did not present enough evidence to prove that they had standing to sue. Specifically, the case alleged that government agencies like the Centers for Disease …

Fake news on social media is the problem we’re all ignoring – trust me, I worked for Twitter
6 months, 2 weeks ago

Fake news on social media is the problem we’re all ignoring – trust me, I worked for Twitter

The Independent  

The best of Voices delivered to your inbox every week - from controversial columns to expert analysis Sign up for our free weekly Voices newsletter for expert opinion and columns Sign up to our free weekly Voices newsletter SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Back when I worked at Twitter, …

EU launches disinformation probe against social media giant Meta
7 months, 3 weeks ago

EU launches disinformation probe against social media giant Meta

Al Jazeera  

Meta defends risk mitigation process after EU says the companies efforts at moderating content was ‘insufficient’. The European Commission has launched a disinformation probe against social media giant Meta. The commission said Meta’s efforts at moderating content are “insufficient” and fail to tackle deceptive advertising and disinformation. The Digital Services Act, which became effective last year, requires “Big Tech” to …

Column: Disinformation is a public health crisis. Here’s how scientists and doctors are fighting it
10 months ago

Column: Disinformation is a public health crisis. Here’s how scientists and doctors are fighting it

LA Times  

Robert F. Kennedy Jr.: Is there a way to inoculate the public against his anti-vaccine lies? “Scientists really recognize this as a problem, from what they see in the community and read in the news,” says Tara Kirk Sell of Johns Hopkins University’s Center for Health Security. It’s part of an emerging genre of advice for scientists, public health officials …

How bad is social-media misinformation going to get?
10 months, 1 week ago

How bad is social-media misinformation going to get?

Live Mint  

Get Offline Mass propaganda has infected the world for generations. —Evan Carlisle, Ohio University, mathematics Government Should Provide a Framework Misinformation poses an escalating problem that government officials and tech companies must face. —HeavenLee Vasquez, Baylor University, finance and management Do Your Research We take much of what we see on social media at face value, especially if it’s something …

Opinion: When is it wrong to urge social media platforms to take down false information?
1 year, 3 months ago

Opinion: When is it wrong to urge social media platforms to take down false information?

LA Times  

A decision on Friday by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit puts in jeopardy one of the few tools that exist to deal with false speech on the internet. The court ruled that the White House, the FBI, the surgeon general’s office and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention cannot communicate with …

Social media posts misconstrue the efficacy of vaccines for flu, measles, mumps and rubella
54 years, 11 months ago

Social media posts misconstrue the efficacy of vaccines for flu, measles, mumps and rubella

Associated Press  

CLAIM: Vaccines for the flu, measles, mumps and rubella were developed decades ago, yet the diseases haven’t been eradicated, proving that the immunizations don’t work. Mumps hasn’t been as thoroughly eliminated in the country as those two diseases because the vaccine’s protection wanes over time and isn’t lifetime, as it is with measles and rubella, says William Schaffner, a spokesperson …

Judge limits Biden administration in working with social media companies
1 year, 5 months ago

Judge limits Biden administration in working with social media companies

Associated Press  

A judge on Tuesday prohibited several federal agencies and officials of the Biden administration from working with social media companies about “protected speech,” a decision called “a blow to censorship” by one of the Republican officials whose lawsuit prompted the ruling. During the COVID-19 pandemic, a period perhaps best characterized by widespread doubt and uncertainty, the United States Government seems …

E.U. calls out Twitter for incomplete disinformation report
1 year, 10 months ago

E.U. calls out Twitter for incomplete disinformation report

The Hindu  

Twitter failed to provide a full report to the European Union on its efforts to combat online disinformation, drawing a rebuke Thursday from top officials of the 27-nation bloc. The company signed up to the EU's voluntary 2022 Code of Practice on Disinformation last year — before billionaire Tesla CEO Elon Musk bought the social media platform. Google, TikTok, Microsoft …

EU calls out Twitter for incomplete disinformation report
1 year, 10 months ago

EU calls out Twitter for incomplete disinformation report

Associated Press  

LONDON — Twitter failed to provide a full report to the European Union on its efforts to combat online disinformation, drawing a rebuke Thursday from top officials of the 27-nation bloc. The company signed up to the EU’s voluntary 2022 Code of Practice on Disinformation last year — before billionaire Tesla CEO Elon Musk bought the social media platform. Google, …

Elon Musk Turns Over Twitter Records To Key Source Of COVID Misinformation
1 year, 11 months ago

Elon Musk Turns Over Twitter Records To Key Source Of COVID Misinformation

Huff Post  

LOADING ERROR LOADING Twitter owner Elon Musk turned over access to internal company documents to a top source of vaccine misinformation who’s been giving out bunk public health advice for years, the latest in a far-right shift on one of the most influential social media sites in the world. Alex Berenson, a former New York Times reporter — whom The …

Public health agencies try to restore trust as they fight misinformation
1 year, 11 months ago

Public health agencies try to restore trust as they fight misinformation

Salon  

OKLAHOMA CITY — By the summer of 2021, Phil Maytubby, deputy CEO of the health department here, was concerned to see the numbers of people getting vaccinated against covid-19 slipping after an initially robust response. The tool found that many people in Oklahoma City didn't like the word "vaccinate" — a term featured prominently in the health department's marketing campaign. …

Twitter bans enforcement of Covid misinformation policy, experts raise concerns
2 years ago

Twitter bans enforcement of Covid misinformation policy, experts raise concerns

India Today  

Twitter has stopped its Covid misinformation policy enforcement, raising concerns among health and media experts over the move’s effect on efforts to combat the still-spreading virus, like vaccination. Alert users spotted the change Monday night, figuring out that a one-sentence update had been made to Twitter’s online rules, “Effective November 23, 2022, Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading …

Majority of social media users not bothered about absolute facts: Report
2 years, 7 months ago

Majority of social media users not bothered about absolute facts: Report

Hindustan Times  

NEW DELHI: The majority of social media users are not bothered about absolute facts and only confirm or verify online information where the ‘alleged individual events were less important than the overall narrative’, according to a report by the Future of India Foundation titled ‘Politics of Disinformation’. “The key takeaway from the focus group discussions is that not only have …

Facebook is having a tougher time managing vaccine misinformation than it is letting on, leaks suggest
3 years, 1 month ago

Facebook is having a tougher time managing vaccine misinformation than it is letting on, leaks suggest

CNN  

New York CNN Business — In public, Facebook has touted the resources it has dedicated to tackling Covid-19 and vaccine misinformation, even scolding US President Joe Biden for his harsh criticism of the company’s handling of the issue. “We have no idea about the scale of the problem when it comes to comments,” an internal research report posted to Facebook’s …

Facebook yanks Bolsonaro video claiming vaccines cause AIDS
3 years, 1 month ago

Facebook yanks Bolsonaro video claiming vaccines cause AIDS

The Independent  

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Please enter a valid email address Please enter a valid email address SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Please try again later {{ …

The great social media misinformation quiz
3 years, 2 months ago

The great social media misinformation quiz

ABC  

As social media platforms have become more intertwined with our lives, so too has the misinformation that comes with them. Minimal information, maximum effect: "A lot of people are just reading headlines and they're not even looking into what the source is … But they can be a fake international news website." Frivolous but dangerous: "A lot of misinformation can …

YouTube expands COVID move to block all anti-vaccine content
3 years, 2 months ago

YouTube expands COVID move to block all anti-vaccine content

Al Jazeera  

Aside from anti-COVID-19 misinformation, video-sharing giant will also bar erroneous claims about flu and measles jabs. YouTube will block all anti-vaccine content, moving beyond its ban on false information about COVID-19 vaccines to include material that contains misinformation about other approved vaccines, the social media giant has announced. YouTube said on Wednesday the expanded policy will apply to “currently administered …

Fighting wave of misinfo, YouTube bans false vaccine claims
3 years, 2 months ago

Fighting wave of misinfo, YouTube bans false vaccine claims

Associated Press  

YouTube announced a sweeping crackdown of vaccine misinformation Wednesday that booted popular anti-vaccine influencers from its site and deleted false claims that have been made about a range of immunizations. Despite tech companies announcing a string of new rules around COVID-19 and vaccine misinformation during the pandemic, falsehoods have still found big audiences on the platforms. Facebook, which also owns …

Fighting wave of misinformation, YouTube bans false vaccine claims
3 years, 2 months ago

Fighting wave of misinformation, YouTube bans false vaccine claims

LA Times  

YouTube, which is owned by Google, will delete videos that falsely claim vaccines are dangerous or cause health issues. The ban on vaccine misinformation, announced in a blog post Wednesday, comes as countries around the world continue to offer free immunizations for COVID-19 to a somewhat hesitant public. Public health officials have struggled to push back against a steady current …

YouTube is cracking down on anti-vaccine misinformation
3 years, 2 months ago

YouTube is cracking down on anti-vaccine misinformation

CNN  

New York CNN Business — YouTube will remove videos spreading misinformation about any approved vaccine, not only those aimed at preventing Covid-19, the company announced in a blog post Wednesday. In a statement provided to CNN Business, YouTube also confirmed it would remove the channels of “several well-known vaccine misinformation spreaders” under the new policy, including one belonging to the …

Facebook misinformation posts get six times more engagement than genuine news, finds study
3 years, 3 months ago

Facebook misinformation posts get six times more engagement than genuine news, finds study

India Today  

Facebook users liked, shared, and interacted six times more with misinformation posts on the platform as compared to genuine news sources, a new study has found. "The study helps add to the growing body of evidence that, despite a variety of mitigation efforts, misinformation has found a comfortable home - and an engaged audience - on Facebook," the report quoted …

There's a psychological reason anti-vaccine misinformation is so hard to fight
3 years, 4 months ago

There's a psychological reason anti-vaccine misinformation is so hard to fight

Salon  

A January 2021 poll from the Pew Charitable Trust found that 53% of Americans reported that social media was their primary source for news. In a world where we easily consume that which is put before us, this makes for a particularly potent chance that misinformation about the vaccine, shared widely in social media spaces, may encourage vaccine resistance — …

Facebook bans firm behind smearing COVID-19 vaccines from Pfizer, AstraZeneca
3 years, 4 months ago

Facebook bans firm behind smearing COVID-19 vaccines from Pfizer, AstraZeneca

Daily Mail  

Facebook has removed hundreds of accounts linked to a mysterious advertising agency emanating from Russia that tried to pay social media influencers to smear COVID-19 vaccines made by Pfizer and AstraZeneca, the social network said on Tuesday. Facebook has removed hundreds of accounts linked to a disinformation network operating out of Russia that sought to smear COVID-19 vaccines made by …

Can social media influencers change vaccine skeptics’ minds?
3 years, 4 months ago

Can social media influencers change vaccine skeptics’ minds?

LA Times  

Fashion blogger Abena Antwiwaa, who lives in Aurora, Colo., is one of dozens of influencers who are getting paid to help change the minds of people who are hesitant to get the COVID-19 vaccine. “It started last year when I saw misinformation that directly affected our department, rumors like police were arresting people without a mask,” said Cornejo, a 10-year …

Ex presenter and Jeremy Corbyn's brother are campaigning to stop youngsters getting Covid jab
3 years, 4 months ago

Ex presenter and Jeremy Corbyn's brother are campaigning to stop youngsters getting Covid jab

Daily Mail  

There is a worrying Zeitgeist among twentysomethings in the Essex seaside town of Clacton. Kate Shemirani compared NHS staff to doctors in Nazi Germany as she spoke to a rally in Trafalgar Square protesting against the vaccination programme 'They say there's a 90 odd per cent survival rate so if you're going to catch it you're probably going to be …

Let’s Keep the Vaccine Misinformation Problem in Perspective
3 years, 4 months ago

Let’s Keep the Vaccine Misinformation Problem in Perspective

Wired  

With Covid cases surging in parts of the United States and vaccinations proceeding at a crawl, all eyes are on social media platforms. Then, late last week, Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota introduced a bill that would strip away Section 230 immunity for vaccine content promoted by social media algorithms. As my former colleague Daniel Engber recently pointed out in …

Democrats Want To Hold Social Media Companies Responsible For Health Misinformation
3 years, 5 months ago

Democrats Want To Hold Social Media Companies Responsible For Health Misinformation

NPR  

Democrats Want To Hold Social Media Companies Responsible For Health Misinformation Enlarge this image toggle caption Elijah Nouvelage/Getty Images Elijah Nouvelage/Getty Images Democratic senators introduced a bill on Thursday that would hold Facebook, YouTube and other social media companies responsible for the proliferation of falsehoods about vaccines, fake cures and other harmful health-related claims on their sites. On Friday, President …

White House communications director Kate Bedingfield says they're reviewing section 230
3 years, 5 months ago

White House communications director Kate Bedingfield says they're reviewing section 230

Daily Mail  

White House comms director Kate Bedingfield said social media companies should be held accountable for publishing misleading info on vaccine White House communications director Kate Bedingfield said on Tuesday that social media companies should be held accountable for publishing misleading information on the COVID vaccine. She also said the administration is reviewing Section 230, a section of the law that …

Biden: ‘Killing people’ remark was call for big tech to act
3 years, 5 months ago

Biden: ‘Killing people’ remark was call for big tech to act

Associated Press  

WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden tempered his assessment that social media giants are “killing people” by hosting misinformation about the COVID-19 vaccines on their platforms, saying Monday that he hoped they would not take it “personally” and instead would act to save lives. It comes as the U.S. sees a rise in virus cases and deaths among those who haven’t …

Facebook slams Joe Biden after he claimed they were 'killing people' with COVID-19 misinformation
3 years, 5 months ago

Facebook slams Joe Biden after he claimed they were 'killing people' with COVID-19 misinformation

Daily Mail  

Facebook has defended itself against U.S. President Joe Biden's assertion that the social media platform is 'killing people' by allowing misinformation about coronavirus vaccines to proliferate. Zuckerberg V Biden: Facebook has hit back at President Biden after he accused the company of 'killing people' by allowing misinformation about the COVID-19 vaccine to circulate on its platform Facebook has defended itself …

Biden: Social media platforms ‘killing people’ with misinformation
3 years, 5 months ago

Biden: Social media platforms ‘killing people’ with misinformation

India TV News  

President Joe Biden said Friday that social media companies are “killing people” by failing to police misinformation on their platforms about COVID-19 vaccines. Biden, when asked if he had a message for platforms like Facebook where false or misleading information about the coronavirus vaccines has spread, told reporters, “They’re killing people.” “The only pandemic we have is among the unvaccinated,” …

Joe Biden says Facebook is 'killing people' by carrying COVID-19 misinformation
3 years, 5 months ago

Joe Biden says Facebook is 'killing people' by carrying COVID-19 misinformation

ABC  

US President Joe Biden said social media platforms like Facebook "are killing people" by allowing misinformation about coronavirus vaccines to be posted on their platforms, as the administration continued criticising the company. Key points: The Biden administration is arguing Facebook and other platforms need to do more to combat misinformation about coronavirus Facebook claims it is helping to save lives …

Biden: Social media platforms ‘killing people’ with misinfo
3 years, 5 months ago

Biden: Social media platforms ‘killing people’ with misinfo

Associated Press  

WASHINGTON — President Joe Biden said Friday that social media companies are “killing people” by failing to police misinformation on their platforms about COVID-19 vaccines. Biden, asked if he had a message for platforms like Facebook where false or misleading information about the coronavirus vaccines has spread, told reporters, “They’re killing people.” “The only pandemic we have is among the …

"Flagging" misinformation isn't enough: COVID is resurging because the right gobbles up lies
3 years, 5 months ago

"Flagging" misinformation isn't enough: COVID is resurging because the right gobbles up lies

Salon  

On Thursday, Surgeon General Vivek Murthy did something no surgeon general has done before: He issued a warning — not about what people are consuming with their bodies — but with their minds. "I am urging all Americans to help slow the spread of health misinformation during the COVID-19 pandemic and beyond," Murthy asked in the health advisory titled "Confronting …

Biden: Social media ‘killing people’ with COVID misinformation
3 years, 5 months ago

Biden: Social media ‘killing people’ with COVID misinformation

Al Jazeera  

Misinformation about the virus and vaccines has spread on platforms including Facebook and Twitter. President Joe Biden has said that social media companies are “killing people” by failing to police misinformation on their platforms about COVID-19 vaccines. “Misinformation poses an imminent and insidious threat to our nation’s health,” Murthy said during remarks on Thursday at the White House. Lives are …

‘They’re killing people’: Biden blames social media for COVID-19 vaccine misinformation
3 years, 5 months ago

‘They’re killing people’: Biden blames social media for COVID-19 vaccine misinformation

LA Times  

President Biden targeted social media platforms like Facebook on Friday for allowing the spread of misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines, as many Americans’ resistance to getting the shots has left wide swaths of the country vulnerable to the more contagious Delta variant. President Biden said Friday that misinformation on social media about COVID-19 vaccines was “killing people.” Unlike the increase in …

US steps up fight against COVID-19 misinformation
3 years, 5 months ago

US steps up fight against COVID-19 misinformation

Al Jazeera  

The effort comes as the pace of COVID-19 vaccinations has slowed throughout the US, due in part to false claims. US Surgeon General Vivek Murthy on Thursday called for a national effort to fight misinformation about COVID-19 and vaccines, urging tech companies, health care workers, journalists and everyday Americans to do more to address a problem “that cost us lives”. …

Anti-Vaccine Activists Use A Federal Database To Spread Fear About COVID Vaccines
3 years, 6 months ago

Anti-Vaccine Activists Use A Federal Database To Spread Fear About COVID Vaccines

NPR  

Anti-Vaccine Activists Use A Federal Database To Spread Fear About COVID Vaccines Enlarge this image toggle caption Matt Slocum/AP Matt Slocum/AP The largest U.S. database for detecting events that might be vaccine side effects is being used by activists to spread disinformation about COVID-19 vaccines. Sponsor Message "It's a very valuable system for detecting adverse events, but it has to …

Just 12 People Are Behind Most Vaccine Hoaxes On Social Media, Research Shows
3 years, 7 months ago

Just 12 People Are Behind Most Vaccine Hoaxes On Social Media, Research Shows

NPR  

Just 12 People Are Behind Most Vaccine Hoaxes On Social Media, Research Shows Enlarge this image toggle caption Chandan Khanna/AFP via Getty Images Chandan Khanna/AFP via Getty Images Researchers have found just 12 people are responsible for the bulk of the misleading claims and outright lies about COVID-19 vaccines that proliferate on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. "The 'Disinformation Dozen' produce …

Sharing Information Widely An Important Tool To Combat COVID : Supreme Court On SOS Calls In Social Media
3 years, 7 months ago

Sharing Information Widely An Important Tool To Combat COVID : Supreme Court On SOS Calls In Social Media

Live Law  

The Supreme Court has sent a strong message that persons who are putting out public appeals for help in social media during the COVID-19 crisis cannot be targeted through arrests or coercive actions by saying that such messages are false or are tarnishing the national image. However, it is with deep distress that we note that individuals seeking help on …

No clampdown on information if citizens communicate grievances on social media: Supreme Court
3 years, 7 months ago

No clampdown on information if citizens communicate grievances on social media: Supreme Court

India TV News  

The Supreme Court has ordered no clampdown on information if citizens communicate their grievances pertaining to Covid-19 treatment on social media. "We want to make it very clear that if citizens communicate their grievance on social media, then it cannot be said it's wrong information. We will treat it as a contempt of court if such grievances are considered for …

No action against anyone who seeks Covid help on social media or criticises govt, Supreme Court tells Centre
3 years, 7 months ago

No action against anyone who seeks Covid help on social media or criticises govt, Supreme Court tells Centre

India Today  

The Supreme Court on Friday came done heavily on some state governments that were taking action against people seeking help for medical assistance or oxygen supplies for their families or friends, charging them for spreading misinformation. The Supreme Court raised the issue of the threat of civil or criminal action against people putting SOS messages on social media asking for …

Misleading tweets on Covid situation removed to stop panic mongering: Govt
3 years, 7 months ago

Misleading tweets on Covid situation removed to stop panic mongering: Govt

India TV News  

In view of the misuse of social media platforms by certain users to spread fake or misleading information and create panic about the COVID19 situation in India by using unrelated, old and out of the context images or visuals, communally sensitive posts and misinformation about COVID19 protocols, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology on the recommendation of Ministry of …

Covid-19 is a shot in the arm for anti-vaccine movement
3 years, 7 months ago

Covid-19 is a shot in the arm for anti-vaccine movement

Live Mint  

Anti-vaccine campaigners once confined to relatively obscure groups have exploited the coronavirus pandemic to reach a wider audience online, feeding on public fears to sow doubt about the drugs now available. You can find them online among France's yellow vest campaigners, among libertarian groups and New Age proselytisers, according to First Draft, a campaign group that specialises in exposing misinformation. …

Govt asks Twitter, other social media platforms to remove misleading posts around COVID
3 years, 8 months ago

Govt asks Twitter, other social media platforms to remove misleading posts around COVID

India TV News  

The government has asked social media platforms, including Twitter and Facebook, to remove content and posts that were found to be spreading misinformation and public panic around the pandemic, according to sources. Twitter said it has notified the impacted account holders of its action taken in response to a legal request from the Indian government but did not give details …

Discover Related