
Using law to bully comedians
The HinduA law teacher has joined the league of self-appointed censors after watching the controversial AIB Knockout roast video. The ‘safe harbor’ in the amended IT Act ensures that law criminalising content like obscenity cannot be used to punish a platform like YouTube if it is unaware that it is hosting illegal content. The reason that the ‘safe harbor’ clause is necessary is that social networks, online auction platforms and video hosting services handle a very large volume of content. The U.K. government learned this in a very public and embarrassing way when what is known as ‘David Cameron’s porn filter’ resulted in blocking legitimate content, including information on rape crises, sex education and breastfeeding. In Ranjit Udeshi v. State of Maharashtra, which dealt with questions of constitutional protection of allegedly obscene speech, the Supreme Court suggested that the court must “apply itself to consider each work at a time.” The necessity of judicial review was stated more baldly in Chandrakant Kalyandas Kakodar v. State of Maharasthra in which the Supreme Court said, “whether the book or article or story considered as a whole panders to the prurient and is obscene must be judged by the courts and ultimately by this Court.” Mr. Vaswani and Dr. Ghuge’s demands would involve either the government or private parties making these critical decisions about speech.
History of this topic

DC Edit | No Country for Comedy
Deccan Chronicle
SC allows Ranveer Allahbadia to resume show, asks govt to curb ‘vulgar content’
Live Mint
YouTuber Ashish Chanchlani interrogated by Assam cops in obscene jokes case
India Today
From Ranveer Allahbadia to regulation: Will your fave OTT shows face more policing?
India Today
Ranveer Allahbadia news: What to know about YouTuber’s incest joke sparking outrage in India
The Independent
Amid India’s Got Latent controversy, Centre urges social media, OTT platforms to follow IT Rules
Live Mint
Outrage over Indian YouTuber Ranveer Allahbadia raises social media regulation concerns
Associated Press
Parl panel seeks I.T. ministry reply on how law tackles obscene content
Hindustan Times
To Speak Or Not To Speak: Understanding TheThin Line Between Free Speech And Obscenity
Live Law
Punjab Child Rights Panel urges action against YouTubers Ranveer Allahabadia, Samay Raina over vulgar content
New Indian Express
Supreme Court asks Central Govt to regulate obscene content on YouTube and other social media platforms
Op India
Supreme Court seeks Centre’s response on obscene content on YouTube
India TV News
Need to do something: Top court notice to Centre over obscene content on YouTube
India Today
Ranveer Allahbadia controversy: How strict are India’s ‘obscenity’ laws? What is the punishment?
Live Mint
Ranveer Allahbadia's 'Sex With Parents' Remark: What Does The Law Say On Vulgarity?
ABP News
‘India’s Got Latent’ row: Could Ranveer Allahbadia, Samay Raina be punished for obscenity?
Firstpost
Ranveer Allahbadia controversy puts ’profane & explicit’ content under fire — time for stricter online rules?
Live Mint
10-year-old spiritual influencer seeks court action against online harassment
Deccan Chronicle
Need stricter laws to curb ‘vulgar content’ on OTT, says Ashwini Vaishnaw
Hindustan Times
Need to make existing laws more stringent to curb vulgar content on social media: I&B Minister Vaishnaw
New Indian Express
Doesn't match our culture: Minister for laws to curb social media vulgar content
India Today
Cyber-Bullying: How Should India Legally Equip Itself?
Live Law
Delhi High Court Refuses Pre-Censorship Of Content Against Rohingya Community On Facebook, Says Treatment Can't Be Worse Than Disease
Live Law
World Press Freedom Day | How free speech in India is compromised by government control over platforms: Book excerpt from ‘Caged Tiger: How Too Much Government is Holding Indians Back’ by Subhashish B
The Hindu
Tread carefully: The Hindu Editorial on the power to remove online content
The Hindu
Why has Twitter gone to court against the Indian government? | In Focus podcast
The Hindu
Op-Ed: What Twitter’s lawsuit against the Indian government could mean for global free expression
LA Times
Explained | Can online bullying of women be punished?
The Hindu
India internet law adds to fears over online speech, privacy
Associated Press
India’s internet law adds to fears over online speech, privacy
Al Jazeera
The Hindu Explains | Why has the government announced new guidelines to regulate digital content?
The Hindu
Is India criminalising comedy and entertainment?
The Hindu
Bihar Govt to Treat Offensive, Anti-Govt Online Posts As a Crime
The Quint
India to regulate online news and social media sites
Al Jazeera
Take The Internet Back From The Mob
The Quint
Here are 7 bizarre judgments by the Indian Judiciary that highlight the need for urgent reforms
Op India
India’s Plan to Curb Hate Speech Could Mean More Censorship
Wired
Private censorship
Deccan Chronicle![Process Of Blocking Online Content Is Opaque; Increasing Internet Shutdowns Alarming & Disproportionate: CCG-NLU-D Study Finds [Read The Report]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Process Of Blocking Online Content Is Opaque; Increasing Internet Shutdowns Alarming & Disproportionate: CCG-NLU-D Study Finds [Read The Report]
Live Law![Process Of Blocking Online Content Is Opaque; Increasing Internet Shutdowns Alarming & Disproportionate: CCG-NLU-D Study Finds [Read The Report]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Process Of Blocking Online Content Is Opaque; Increasing Internet Shutdowns Alarming & Disproportionate: CCG-NLU-D Study Finds [Read The Report]
Live Law![Delhi Court Tells Google India To Remove Offensive Videos Against Sikhism Featuring Sakshi Bhardwaj In 7 Days [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Delhi Court Tells Google India To Remove Offensive Videos Against Sikhism Featuring Sakshi Bhardwaj In 7 Days [Read Order]
Live Law![Delhi Court Tells Google India To Remove Offensive Videos Against Sikhism Featuring Sakshi Bhardwaj In 7 Days [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Delhi Court Tells Google India To Remove Offensive Videos Against Sikhism Featuring Sakshi Bhardwaj In 7 Days [Read Order]
Live Law
Supreme Court seeks advice on porn ban
Deccan Chronicle
Supreme Court asks Google about internal mechanism to identify and take down obscene content
Firstpost
Supreme Court to Google: Can uploading of obscene videos be prevented?
Live Mint
Prevent Uploading Of Rape Videos, Child Porn: Amicus To Centre
Live Law
Cyberbullying in India is a form of censorship: Mishi Choudhary, Executive Director of SFLC
Firstpost
The cyber law series: Can India curb the trolls who ride on the coattails of politicians?
Firstpost
SC agrees to hear PIL seeking ban on websites spreading ‘Sardar Jokes’
Live Law
SC agrees to hear PIL seeking ban on websites spreading ‘Sardar Jokes’
Live LawDiscover Related











































