
Trump's call to impeach judges is a threat to the constitutional order.
SlateSign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily. Together, the threats of presidential defiance and congressional impeachment constitute a dangerous attack on the independent judiciary’s power to constrain executive branch action within the limits of statutory and constitutional law. The constitutional standard for removal of judges is the same as for executive branch officers—whether they committed “treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.” Related From Slate Lawyers Can Slow a Trump Dictatorship. The primary example is Judge John Pickering, who was impeached, convicted, and removed in 1804—nominally for improper rulings, drunkenness, and blasphemy, but actually because he was severely mentally ill. With the exception of Judge Pickering and Judge Mark H. Delahay, who was impeached in 1873 for being habitually drunk on the bench and resigned before he could be tried in the Senate, all 11 successful removals by impeachment of judges have involved charges of treason, corruption, perjury, or other ordinary crimes. First, the House of Representatives is now controlled by a Republican majority which seems perfectly prepared to investigate and indeed impeach officials it does not like regardless of whether they have engaged in conduct remotely approximating “treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.” In February 2024, House Republicans impeached Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas, although the Senate refused to consider the matter.
History of this topic

Republicans move to impeach judges who block Trump
China Daily
Trump wants to rein in federal judges. One California Republican is already working on it
LA Times
'Crime and Chaos': Trump goes on Truth Social rant after judge's 'angry order'
Raw Story
Trump Ramps Up Attacks On Judges, Calls Out Justice John Roberts
Huff Post
Ex-federal judge flags 'frightening part' about Trump’s impeachment threats
Raw Story
Trump ruled to have flouted the law more than a dozen times since taking office: report
Raw Story
'The cowardice!' Republican slammed for anonymous attack on Trump
Raw Story
'Certain to fail': Mike Johnson has a new 'headache' thanks to Trump
Raw Story
Trump has "declared war on the rule of law," says retired conservative judge J. Michael Luttig
Salon
A look at the judge who blocked Trump’s deportations and is now facing calls for impeachment
Associated Press
'Not appropriate': Chief Justice Roberts smacks down Trump's call to impeach judge
Raw Story
John Roberts Rebukes Trump: Impeachment Not 'Appropriate' For Disagreeing With Judge's Ruling
Huff Post
Roberts rejects Trump’s call for impeaching judge who ruled against his deportation plans
Associated Press
I'm just doing what the voters wanted: Trump slams judge over immigration ruling
India Today
"Impeachment is not appropriate": Chief Justice Roberts slaps down MAGA attacks on federal judge
Salon
Impeachment not appropriate: Chief Justice rejects Trump's call to remove judges
India Today
US Chief Justice John Roberts slams Trump’s call to impeach a federal judge
Al Jazeera
Conservative ex-judge fears 'the end of the rule of law' amid Trump and Musk attacks
Raw Story
Federal judges push back on calls for impeaching jurists who rule against Trump
CNN
Musk, GOP Push To Impeach Judges Is Dangerous 'Theater'
Huff Post
'Coming for the judges': Ex-prosecutor puts GOP senator on notice for 'ludicrous' comments
Raw Story
After Trump goes 0-3 in court, Musk again demands judges be impeached
The Independent
As judges move to block Trump's executive orders, who has the ultimate power?
NPR
Trump's shock and awe campaign rock the courts
Salon
White House says judges blocking President Donald Trump's triggering a ‘constitutional crisis’
Hindustan Times
Trump says he ‘always’ abides by court orders as allies lay groundwork to defy them
The Independent
Here’s what federal judges could do if they’re ignored by the Trump administration
CNN
Trump tests US laws with fast-paced executive orders, can judiciary bind his hands?
Firstpost
Vance and Musk question the authority of the courts as Trump’s agenda faces legal pushback
Associated Press
Is Trump pushing his presidential powers beyond what the Constitution allows?
LA Times
Ex-federal judge warns Trump that his ‘inexcusable’ attacks on judges could ‘imperil’ his cases
The Independent
Senate votes that Trump impeachment trial is constitutional
The Telegraph
The 3 impeachment defenses of Donald Trump (opinion)
CNN
Can Senate convict Trump of incitement based on a speech?
LA Times
Donald Trump becomes first U.S. President to be impeached twice
The Hindu
8 Presidential Candidates Outline Their Visions For The Courts
Huff Post
Five key takeaways from Donald Trump's impeachment trial; president likely to be acquitted after Wednesday's vote
Firstpost
Trump impeachment: US Senate approves trial rules
Al Jazeera
Donald Trump’s Senate trial defense: Abuse of power is not impeachable
CNN
‘Impartial Justice’? What to watch in Trump’s Senate trial
Associated Press
The Crossing: What to watch as impeachment heads to Senate
Associated Press
The courts could decide if Trump was impeached (opinion)
CNN
US House starts historic session to impeach President Donald Trump
India TV News
Takeaways from the House Judiciary Committee’s first impeachment hearing
CNN
Trump impeachment is happening, says George Bush's former ethics chief
The Independent
Analysis: Trump court pick aimed at cementing legacy
Associated Press
White House turns to above-the-law political defense
CNN
McConnell scolds Trump for lashing out at federal judge
Daily Mail
Ironic justice: Donald Trump could completely overhaul the judiciary, thanks to Republican obstructionism
SalonDiscover Related







































