Visiting French submarine boss confronted over Australian industry content in $90 billion defence project
4 years, 1 month ago

Visiting French submarine boss confronted over Australian industry content in $90 billion defence project

ABC  

The global head of French defence giant Naval Group says he is having "productive" talks with the Morrison government after being confronted about the company's commitments to Australian industry in the $90 billion future submarine program. Key points: The government requires Naval Group to spend at least 60 per cent of the $90 billion contract value on local suppliers The French company has pledged to do so but has not committed to it CEO Pierre Eric Pommellet declined to say whether a deal was close to being finalised Pierre Eric Pommellet has flown across the world, spending two weeks in mandatory quarantine in Adelaide, to conduct face-to-face negotiations with ministers and officials in Canberra. Government frustration with Naval Group is growing over the company's refusal to formalise a pledge last year to spend 60 per cent of the massive contract value on local suppliers. Minister Price also warned that the Morrison government would hold Naval Group to account on the commitment, "as the Australian public would expect".

Defence Naval French Minister Group Australian Naval Group Pommellet Mr Pommellet  confronted  project  group  french  contract  submarine  visiting  boss  pommellet  content  industry  defence  billion  minister  australian  mr  naval

History of this topic

Australia: Thousands protest against proposed submarine base
1 year, 10 months ago

Australia: Thousands protest against proposed submarine base

Firstpost  

Thousands of protesters demonstrated on Saturday against the construction of a nuclear-powered submarine station at Port Kembla in eastern Australia as part of the AUKUS defence agreement with the US, UK, and Australia, which is worth A$368 billion. According to public broadcaster ABC, the Defence Department prefers to build a new east-coast submarine facility near New South Wales’ second-largest coal …

Eyeing China, Biden and allies unveil nuclear-powered submarine plan for Australia
2 years ago

Eyeing China, Biden and allies unveil nuclear-powered submarine plan for Australia

Live Mint  

The United States, Australia and Britain on Monday unveiled details of a plan to provide Australia with nuclear-powered attack submarines from the early 2030s to counter China's ambitions in the Indo-Pacific. Addressing a ceremony at the U.S. naval base in San Diego, accompanied by Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, U.S. President Joe Biden called …

Australian, French ministers to meet to mend fences over submarines row in Paris
2 years, 1 month ago

Australian, French ministers to meet to mend fences over submarines row in Paris

Firstpost  

A bitter row erupted in September 2021 when Australia’s previous prime minister Scott Morrison abruptly tore up a contract for France to build a dozen diesel-powered submarines and announced a deal to buy US or British nuclear-powered subs Paris: Australian and French ministers are to meet Monday in a fresh drive to mend fences 16 months after Canberra pulled the …

UK minister says Australian submarines will assure neighbors
2 years, 4 months ago

UK minister says Australian submarines will assure neighbors

The Independent  

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy Australia’s shift to nuclear-powered submarines …

Australia sticks to US nuclear subs despite French criticism
2 years, 4 months ago

Australia sticks to US nuclear subs despite French criticism

Associated Press  

CANBERRA, Australia — Australia’s prime minister said Friday he remained committed to building a fleet of submarines powered by U.S. nuclear technology despite the French president describing the plan as a “confrontation with China.” The previous Australian government infuriated President Emmanuel Macron last year by canceling a contract for a French-built fleet of conventionally-powered submarines worth 90 billion Australian dollars …

French navy warns AUKUS nuclear submarine plan will be 'much more difficult' for Australia
2 years, 7 months ago

French navy warns AUKUS nuclear submarine plan will be 'much more difficult' for Australia

ABC  

One of France's most senior defence figures is warning Australia that acquiring nuclear submarines will be "much more difficult" than the now scrapped plan to build a new fleet of conventionally powered boats. Key points: French military chief Nicolas Vaujour was in Sydney for talks with Australian and US military leaders at the high-powered defence conference Vice Admiral Vaujour says …

Australia and France make ‘new start’ after submarine row
2 years, 8 months ago

Australia and France make ‘new start’ after submarine row

Associated Press  

PARIS — Australia and France opened a “new chapter” in their relations Friday as the new Australian prime minister seeks to heal wounds from a secret submarine contract that infuriated France. President Emmanuel Macron warmly shook hands with Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese outside the French presidential palace, showing a thumbs-up before putting his arm around the Australian leader’s back …

French, Australian leaders meet in effort to rebuild ties
2 years, 8 months ago

French, Australian leaders meet in effort to rebuild ties

Al Jazeera  

Macron hosts Australia’s Albanese as the two try to rebuild ties badly strained by a ditching of a submarine contract. French President Emmanuel Macron has told new Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese he wanted to focus on the future as they try to rebuild relations badly strained by his predecessor’s decision to ditch a submarine contract with Paris. Macron reacted …

After $2.4 billion spent on scrapped submarines, 10 Australians remain in France to wind down the project
3 years, 1 month ago

After $2.4 billion spent on scrapped submarines, 10 Australians remain in France to wind down the project

ABC  

Five months after the $90 billion French submarine program was dumped, 10 Australian defence employees remain in the shipbuilding city of Cherbourg completing "final closure activities". Key points: A third of the Defence Department's team remains in Cherbourg Negotiations on the cost settlement to terminate the submarine program are ongoing Defence says all remaining staff are scheduled to return to …

Nuclear submarines and closer interaction with British military to dominate Australian talks with UK
3 years, 2 months ago

Nuclear submarines and closer interaction with British military to dominate Australian talks with UK

ABC  

Closer military cooperation and possible basing of British defence assets in Australia will be discussed when ministers from both nations hold long-awaited face-to-face talks in Sydney this week. Key points: British and Australian ministers will discuss the nuclear submarine deal and emerging security threats This will be the countries' first in-person AUKMIN meeting since before the pandemic Scott Morrison will …

Morrison Cites Leaked Messages to Prove Macron's Concerns About Submarine Deal
3 years, 4 months ago

Morrison Cites Leaked Messages to Prove Macron's Concerns About Submarine Deal

The Quint  

Media sources in Australia leaked messages related to the cancelled submarine deal between Emmanuel Macron, the president of France and Scott Morrison, the prime minister of Australia on Tuesday, 1 November, Reuters reported. According to the leaks, when the Australian PM tried to initiate a call with Macron about the contract on 14 September, only two days before AUKUS was …

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has been accused of lying to the French over the submarine deal. Here's what got us to this point
3 years, 4 months ago

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has been accused of lying to the French over the submarine deal. Here's what got us to this point

ABC  

The fallout from Prime Minister Scott Morrison's decision to scrap a French submarine deal in favour of a nuclear option from the US or UK has continued into this week's meeting of world leaders in Glasgow. And US President Joe Biden is doing his best to distance himself from what he called Mr Morrison's "clumsy" move, as the federal opposition …

Scott Morrison on the defensive over French submarine deal, after brief run in with Emmanuel Macron
3 years, 4 months ago

Scott Morrison on the defensive over French submarine deal, after brief run in with Emmanuel Macron

ABC  

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has crossed paths with French President Emmanuel Macron for the first time since Australia tore up its $90 billion submarine contract with French shipbuilder Naval Group. Key points: Scott Morrison and French President Emmanuel Macron met briefly on the sidelines of the G20 summit in Rome It followed their first tense phone call since Australia tore …

Biden tells Macron US ‘clumsy’ in Australia submarine deal
3 years, 4 months ago

Biden tells Macron US ‘clumsy’ in Australia submarine deal

Associated Press  

ROME — Working to patch things up with an old ally, President Joe Biden told French President Emmanuel Macron on Friday the U.S. had been “clumsy” in its handling of a secret U.S.-British submarine deal with Australia, an arrangement that left France in the lurch and rattled Europe’s faith in American loyalty. “What really matters now is what we will …

France to return ambassador to Australia after submarines fracas
3 years, 5 months ago

France to return ambassador to Australia after submarines fracas

Live Mint  

France said it would send its ambassador back to Australia, as the allies sought to mend a major rift caused when Canberra scuttled a lucrative French submarine deal to join a new security pact with the U.S. and U.K. France recalled its ambassadors to Washington and Canberra last month after the announcement of the new AUKUS partnership, under which Australia …

Australia welcoming back French ambassador after sub spat
3 years, 5 months ago

Australia welcoming back French ambassador after sub spat

Associated Press  

CANBERRA, Australia — Prime Minister Scott Morrison welcomed France’s decision to return its ambassador to Australia and said Thursday the bilateral relationship was bigger than the canceled submarine contract. Morrison dismissed suggestions that Australia needed to rebuild its relationship with France after canceling a 90 billion Australian dollar contract last month, an act French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian described …

France sends its ambassador back to Australia after furious row over $90billion submarine deal
3 years, 5 months ago

France sends its ambassador back to Australia after furious row over $90billion submarine deal

Daily Mail  

France will send its ambassador back to Canberra after he was pulled out of Australia in protest when a $90billion deal to buy French submarines was scrapped. Jean-Pierre Thebault was recalled to France in September after Australia signed a new submarine deal with the United States and United Kingdom as part of the AUKUS alliance. Mr Morrison flew to France …

Aukus: French naval group seeks compensation after Australia buys nuclear-powered vessels from US and UK
3 years, 6 months ago

Aukus: French naval group seeks compensation after Australia buys nuclear-powered vessels from US and UK

The Independent  

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy France's Naval Group said it …

How can Australia repair its relationship with France after the AUKUS submarine row?
3 years, 6 months ago

How can Australia repair its relationship with France after the AUKUS submarine row?

ABC  

The continuing diplomatic rift between France and Australia is "not about the submarines", says Romain Fathi, a French-Australian historian from Flinders University. But he said it was "naive" of France to think it could replace the US and UK as Australia's most important ally. "France has huge interests at both ends of the Indo-Pacific", and could also look to frustrate …

Submarine deal row: How France was sacrificed at the altar of Australia's changing need
3 years, 6 months ago

Submarine deal row: How France was sacrificed at the altar of Australia's changing need

Firstpost  

Australian concerns about the deal were a matter of public record, with worries focused on cost over-runs and delays and whether the submarines would be fit for purpose once they entered service Paris, France: In June this year, French leader Emmanuel Macron welcomed Australia’s Prime Minister Scott Morrison to Paris, with concern about the two allies’ troubled submarine contract high …

‘Get a grip’: British PM urges France to move on from AUKUS row
3 years, 6 months ago

‘Get a grip’: British PM urges France to move on from AUKUS row

Al Jazeera  

Boris Johnson tells Paris to ‘give me a break’ amid French fury over new security pact between UK, US and Australia. British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has urged France to “get a grip” after Paris spent days reacting furiously to being sidelined by a new security pact brokered between the United Kingdom, United States and Australia. Johnson on Wednesday praised …

Defense official defends French submarine-making capability
3 years, 6 months ago

Defense official defends French submarine-making capability

Associated Press  

PARIS — France’s Defense Ministry used Twitter to offer a robust defense of the country’s submarine-making capabilities and to criticize Australia’s decision to choose the United States as a partner in a major defense deal. “France has built more than 250 submarines” over 120 years, Grandjean said, and “the feedback in terms of engineering and know-how is considerable.” Australia plans …

French foreign minister says “crisis of trust” with the US as row over submarine deal deepens
3 years, 6 months ago

French foreign minister says “crisis of trust” with the US as row over submarine deal deepens

Firstpost  

European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen has come out in support of France saying “one of our member states has been treated in a way that is not acceptable” United Nations: France’s top diplomat declared Monday that there is a “crisis of trust” in the United States after a Pacific defense deal stung France and left Europe wondering about …

‘Crisis of trust': France bristles at US submarine deal
3 years, 6 months ago

‘Crisis of trust': France bristles at US submarine deal

Associated Press  

UNITED NATIONS — France’s top diplomat declared Monday that there is a “crisis of trust” in the United States after a Pacific defense deal stung France and left Europe wondering about its longtime ally across the Atlantic. Speaking to reporters in New York, French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian said European countries won’t let Washington leave them behind when shaping …

Scott Morrison not planning to discuss submarine deal with French President Emmanuel Macron while at United Nations General Assembly
3 years, 6 months ago

Scott Morrison not planning to discuss submarine deal with French President Emmanuel Macron while at United Nations General Assembly

ABC  

Prime Minister Scott Morrison has defended Australia's decision to scrap a $90 billion submarine contract with France, and says he has no plans to meet with French President Emmanuel Macron at the United Nations General Assembly. Key points: Scott Morrison will spend a day in New York during the meeting of the UNGA He said he made it "very clear" …

Australians posted to France fear local backlash following shock $90b submarine contract cancellation
3 years, 6 months ago

Australians posted to France fear local backlash following shock $90b submarine contract cancellation

ABC  

Defence says it is supporting Australians posted to the now-scrapped submarine building project in France, as local anger grows over the shock decision to cancel the massive contract. Key points: Anger is growing in the French city of Cherbourg, where design work on Australia's submarine program had begun Defence says 33 Australian employees remain in Cherbourg and "their wellbeing is …

France’s Macron to talk to Biden amid crisis over submarines
3 years, 6 months ago

France’s Macron to talk to Biden amid crisis over submarines

Associated Press  

PARIS — French President Emmanuel Macron will speak in the coming days with President Joe Biden in their first contact since a major diplomatic crisis erupted between France and the United States over a submarine deal with Australia, an official said Sunday. The phone call is at the request of Biden, government spokesman Gabriel Attal said, adding that there was …

France’s Macron to talk to Biden amid crisis over submarines
3 years, 6 months ago

France’s Macron to talk to Biden amid crisis over submarines

The Independent  

Sign up for the daily Inside Washington email for exclusive US coverage and analysis sent to your inbox Get our free Inside Washington email Get our free Inside Washington email SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy Emmanuel Macron, the French president, will speak in the coming …

Australia says France knew of ‘grave’ submarine concerns
3 years, 6 months ago

Australia says France knew of ‘grave’ submarine concerns

Associated Press  

CANBERRA, Australia — France would have known Australia had “deep and grave concerns” that a submarine fleet the French were building would not meet Australian needs, Prime Minister Scott Morrison said Sunday after the contract’s cancellation set off a diplomatic crisis. France accused Australia of concealing its intentions to back out of the 90 billion Australian dollar contract for French …

Australia dismisses France's accusations, says concerns over submarine deal 'raised some months ago'
3 years, 6 months ago

Australia dismisses France's accusations, says concerns over submarine deal 'raised some months ago'

Firstpost  

Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison said the capability being delivered by France’s Attack Class submarine was not going to meet their strategic interests Sydney : Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison on Sunday rejected France’s accusations that Canberra lied about plans to cancel a contract to buy French submarines, saying he had raised concerns over the deal “some months ago”. Morrison’s …

Australia says France knew of 'grave' submarine concerns
3 years, 6 months ago

Australia says France knew of 'grave' submarine concerns

The Independent  

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy France would have known Australia …

Submarine deal row: France accuses Australia, US of lying and duplicity
3 years, 6 months ago

Submarine deal row: France accuses Australia, US of lying and duplicity

Firstpost  

The move comes after Australia’s decision to break a 2016 deal for French submarines in favour of American nuclear-powered vessels Paris : France on Saturday accused Australia and the United States of lying over a ruptured Australian contract to buy French submarines, saying a grave crisis was under way between the allies. A White House official on Friday expressed “regret” …

Australia braces for EU trade backlash as France fumes over scrapped submarine contract
3 years, 6 months ago

Australia braces for EU trade backlash as France fumes over scrapped submarine contract

ABC  

The federal government is bracing itself for the possibility that EU trade talks could be disrupted, as France fumes at Australia and the United States over the decision to scrap a $90 billion submarine contract. Key points: France is a highly influential part of the 27-nation EU bloc European Affairs minister Clement Beaune says France can no longer trust Australia …

How a submarine deal sparked a major diplomatic crisis
3 years, 6 months ago

How a submarine deal sparked a major diplomatic crisis

Al Jazeera  

Australia’s move to ditch a $66bn submarine deal has spiralled into an unprecedented diplomatic row between Western allies. French Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian, said, “There has been contempt so it’s not going well between us, not at all.” President Emmanuel Macron will have a call with his US counterpart, Joe Biden, in the next few days, the French government …

Why A Submarine Deal Has France At Odds With The U.S., U.K. And Australia
3 years, 6 months ago

Why A Submarine Deal Has France At Odds With The U.S., U.K. And Australia

NPR  

Why A Submarine Deal Has France At Odds With The U.S., U.K. And Australia Enlarge this image toggle caption Chief Mass Communication Specialist Amanda R. Gray/U.S. Over the next 18 months, Australia's Department of Defense will establish a task force to guide the coalition's goal to become a "reliable steward" of nuclear technology. More importantly, the institute said, Australia's new …

AUKUS | France's recall of ambassador over submarine deal regretful, says Australia
3 years, 6 months ago

AUKUS | France's recall of ambassador over submarine deal regretful, says Australia

The Hindu  

Australia said on Saturday that it was noting with regret France's recall of its ambassador over the surprise cancellation of a submarine contract in favour of a U.S. deal. Foreign Minister Marise Payne's office said in a statement: “We note with regret France's decision to recall its Ambassador to Australia for consultations following the decision on the Attack Class project.” …

Australia: France's recall of ambassador over subs regretful
3 years, 6 months ago

Australia: France's recall of ambassador over subs regretful

The Independent  

For free real time breaking news alerts sent straight to your inbox sign up to our breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails Sign up to our free breaking news emails SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy Australia said Saturday it was …

France recalls its ambassadors to US and Australia over AUKUS alliance
3 years, 6 months ago

France recalls its ambassadors to US and Australia over AUKUS alliance

Firstpost  

The move comes after Canberra ditched a deal to buy French submarines in favour of US vessels Paris: France on Friday recalled its ambassadors to the United States and Australia for consultations in a ferocious row over the scrapping of a submarine contract, an unprecedented step that revealed the extent of French anger against its allies. Le Drian said in …

France withdraws ambassadors to Australia and US over submarines deal
3 years, 6 months ago

France withdraws ambassadors to Australia and US over submarines deal

ABC  

Australia's Foreign Ministry says it "regrets" France's decision to immediately recall its ambassadors to Australia and the US in response to a new submarine deal. Key points: A recall of ambassadors is highly unusual between allied countries France said it was unable to trust Australia in talks on a trade deal with the EU The EU is Australia's third-biggest trading …

France accuses Australia, US of ‘lying’ over submarine deal
3 years, 6 months ago

France accuses Australia, US of ‘lying’ over submarine deal

Al Jazeera  

Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian says a ‘serious crisis’ is now in progress between allies after Canberra scraps submarines contract with Paris. France has accused longtime allies Australia and the United States of lying over a security pact that saw the Australian government scrap a contract to buy French submarines in favour of US vessels. “There has been lying, duplicity, …

AUKUS | France recalls Ambassadors to U.S., Australia over submarine deal
3 years, 6 months ago

AUKUS | France recalls Ambassadors to U.S., Australia over submarine deal

The Hindu  

France said late on September 17 it was immediately recalling its Ambassadors to the U.S. and Australia after Australia scrapped a big French conventional submarine purchase in favour of nuclear subs built with U.S. technology. He said Wednesday’s announcement of Australia’s submarine deal with the U.S. is “unacceptable behaviour between allies and partners”. Mr. Macron has not commented on the …

Why France is angry about the US and UK giving Australia nuclear-powered submarines
3 years, 6 months ago

Why France is angry about the US and UK giving Australia nuclear-powered submarines

CNN  

CNN — The French government says it was betrayed when Australia pulled out of their existing multi-billion dollar defense deal, agreeing instead to attain nuclear-powered submarines through a new deal with the United States and the United Kingdom. The effort to provide Australia with nuclear-powered submarines – a major step toward countering China as President Joe Biden works to build …

Inside the creation of the US-Australia submarine deal
3 years, 6 months ago

Inside the creation of the US-Australia submarine deal

CNN  

CNN — American and Australian officials have been in highly secret talks for months over a plan to share technology for nuclear-powered submarines, a process that was hatched more than a year ago and accelerated after President Biden took office in January. There was no public disclosure of the submarine deal at the time, though a White House description of …

France recalls US and Australia envoys over submarine deal
3 years, 6 months ago

France recalls US and Australia envoys over submarine deal

Al Jazeera  

France has recalled its ambassadors to US and Australia for consultations – an unprecedented move taken over a submarine deal. Calling the cancellation “unacceptable behaviour”, Foreign Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian said in a statement on Friday the decision to recall the envoys, on request from President Emmanuel Macron, “is justified by the exceptional seriousness of the announcements” made by Australia …

Defence Minister will not apologise to France for 'backstab' over dumped $90b submarine deal
3 years, 6 months ago

Defence Minister will not apologise to France for 'backstab' over dumped $90b submarine deal

ABC  

France's Foreign Minister, Jean-Yves Le Drian, has described the decision to cancel a $90 billion submarine deal as a "stab in the back", but Australia's Defence Minister, Peter Dutton, says he will not apologise for the decision. Key points: Australia, the US and UK have formed a new security partnership, which will deliver Australia nuclear-powered submarines It means Australia's $90 …

Australia to be left 'strategically naked' for 20 years under nuclear submarine deal, Rudd says
3 years, 6 months ago

Australia to be left 'strategically naked' for 20 years under nuclear submarine deal, Rudd says

ABC  

Former prime ministers on both sides of politics are calling for a rapid acceleration in the building of a fleet of nuclear-powered submarines, with claims Australia will otherwise be left "strategically naked" for the next two decades. Key points: Kevin Rudd and Tony Abbott are calling for the new fleet of nuclear-powered submarines to be built quickly Labor says it …

France Recalls Ambassadors To The U.S. And Australia Over Snubbed Sub Deal
3 years, 6 months ago

France Recalls Ambassadors To The U.S. And Australia Over Snubbed Sub Deal

NPR  

France Recalls Ambassadors To The U.S. And Australia Over Snubbed Sub Deal Enlarge this image toggle caption Jens Schlueter/AP Jens Schlueter/AP In response to a newly penned nuclear submarine deal between the United States and Australia, France announced on Friday it would recall its ambassadors to both countries, citing "unacceptable behavior" on the part of the allied nations. "This exceptional …

French Ambassador says Australia's decision to scrap submarine deal was a breach of trust
3 years, 6 months ago

French Ambassador says Australia's decision to scrap submarine deal was a breach of trust

ABC  

The French Ambassador has accused Australia of deliberately keeping his country in the dark over a decision to scrap a $90 billion submarine contract. Key points: The Ambassador said there was no sign the French contract was in trouble during recent talks The French government has criticised Australia for deciding to pursue nuclear submarines instead It is unclear how much …

Furious EU complains that it was 'not consulted' on AUKUS submarine deal
3 years, 6 months ago

Furious EU complains that it was 'not consulted' on AUKUS submarine deal

Daily Mail  

provide at least eight nuclear-powered submarines to Australia Josep Borrell said union was only made aware of new alliance through the media The EU has complained that it was 'not consulted' on the AUKUS submarine deal while France has lashed out at Australia for 'stabbing it in the back'. Josep Borrell, the EU’s high representative for foreign affairs, said the …

'Stab in the back': Why France is livid after Australia signed new submarine deal with US, UK
3 years, 6 months ago

'Stab in the back': Why France is livid after Australia signed new submarine deal with US, UK

Firstpost  

To be fair, despite the French outburst, there had been indications of problems with the project for several years now Australia on Thursday decided to dump its contract with France to build diesel-electric submarines in favour of US’ nuclear-powered submarines because of a “changed strategic environment”. But US president Joe Biden and the prime ministers of Australia and Britain announced …

Discover Related