
The BJP argument against Muslim reservation is false
FirstpostOriginally, the Scheduled Caste reservations were restricted to only Hindus. The Para 3 of the Constitution Order 1950 clearly stated that nobody other than Hindus would be eligible for reservations. It said: “We recommend that para 3 of the Constitution Order 1950 which originally restricted the Scheduled Caste net to the Hindus and later opened it to Sikhs and Buddhists thus still excluding from its purview Muslims, Christians, Jains and Parsis etc. should be wholly deleted by appropriate action so as to totally delink Scheduled Caste status from religion and make the Scheduled Castes net fully religion-neutral like that of the Scheduled Tribes…We further recommend that all those groups and classes among the Muslims and Christians, etc. whose counterparts among the Hindus, Sikhs or Buddhists, are included in the Central or State Scheduled Castes lists should also be covered by the Scheduled Caste net.” About Muslims specifically, it said, “Since the minorities – especially the Muslims – are very much under-represented, and sometimes wholly unrepresented, in government employment, we recommend that they should be regarded as backward in this respect within the meaning of that term as used in Article 16 of the Constitution … and that 15 percent of posts in all cadres and grades under the Central and State Governments should be earmarked for them as follow…” But seven years later, its report is still gathering dust.
History of this topic

BJP to challenge Karnataka’s 4% Muslim reservation in court, calls it ‘unconstitutional misadventure’
Hindustan Times
BJP vows legal fight against Karnataka's 4% Muslim quota in government contracts
India Today
'Who said reservation is only for Muslims? DK Shivakumar defends 4% quota amid BJP's 'appeasement' charge
Hindustan Times
Karnataka Cabinet Approve 4 Percent Reservation for Muslims in govt contract
Deccan Chronicle
BJP slams Karnataka’s quota for Muslim contractors; DK Shivakumar responds
Hindustan Times
Karnataka approves 4% Muslim reservation in contracts, BJP calls it unconstitutional
Op India
Karnataka's nod to 4% quota for Muslim contractors in tenders, BJP slams move
India Today
Minority quota not based on religion: Karnataka CM
New Indian Express
Reservation can't be on basis of religion: Supreme Court on West Bengal OBC case
India Today
'Reservation Can't Be On Basis Of Religion', Says Supreme Court While Hearing West Bengal's Plea Against HC Quashing OBC Classifications
Live Law
AMU Students Protest, Demand Quota for Dalits and Tribals
Deccan Chronicle
Karnataka’s proposed 4% Muslim quota sparks debate; BJP asks: ‘Whose share will be cut — SC, ST or OBCs?’
Live Mint
Karnataka CMO: No Proposal on Muslim Reservation
Deccan Chronicle
Amit Shah says BJP won't allow Muslim reservation in Haryana
Hindustan Times
SP demands Muslim reservation in Maharashtra
Deccan Chronicle
BJP MLC CT Ravi criticizes TDP's Muslim reservation policy, says quota is against Constitution
New Indian Express
BJP against Muslim reservation to protect SC, ST, OBC quota: CM Yogi
Deccan Chronicle
OPINION | Should there be reservation for Muslims on religious grounds?
India TV News
INDIA bloc will give quota to Muslims by changing Constitution: BJP over Lalu Prasad's remarks
The Hindu
Lalu says Muslims should get reservation ‘in full’, Modi says ‘snatching quota’
Hindustan Times
Modi and Lalu Prasad spar over the issue of reservations for Muslims
The Hindu
No reservation based on religion to Muslims as long as I am alive: PM Narendra Modi
Hindustan Times
Fact Check: Analysing Modi’s Claim That Congress Gave Religion-Based Reservation to Muslims in Karnataka
ABP News
Reservations to Muslims is not new thing as the community has been enjoying it as its Constitutional right for last 30 years: Siddaramaiah
The Hindu
Muslim quota part of agenda to push country towards Islamisation: Adityanath
Hindustan Times
Panel slams Karnataka OBC quota for Muslims: 'Against social justice principle'
India Today
Fact Check: No, BJP Leader Didn't Say Party Will End Muslim Quota In Andhra Pradesh
ABP News
SC says THIS on withdrawal of Muslim quota bill in Karnataka today
Live Mint
Amit Shah defends scrapping 4% reservation for Muslims in Karnataka
The Hindu
Suspect moves: The Hindu Editorial on changes to reservation policy in Karnataka
The Hindu
Karnataka says 4% quota for Muslims was shifted'
Deccan Chronicle
DC Edit | Scrap religion-based quotas; it's time to rethink all others
Deccan Chronicle
Bijapur MLA opposes reservation for Muslims
Deccan Chronicle
Reservations to Dalit Christians and Muslims was a ‘Communal Award’ given by Sonia Gandhi for defeating Vajpayee: Why BJP has to resist it
Op India
Caste based reservations should continue till caste based discrimination is there: RSS chief
Op India
After Maharashtra Assembly passes quota bill, AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi demands reservation for Muslims
Firstpost
Muslims giving birth to more children to takeover India from Hindus: Rajasthan BJP MLA
India TV News
Muslims will not get justice without reservation, says AIMIM chief Asaduddin Owaisi
India TV News
Reservation alone can't help Muslim community: Heptulla
India TV News
Maharashtra govt clarifies decision to provide reservations for Marathas, Muslims
India TV News
Withdraw notifications providing reservation to Muslims, demands BJP
India TV News
BJP Not Against Muslims, But Reservation, Says Swaraj
India TV News
BJP To Oppose Religion-Based Reservation Through Mass Movement
India TV News
BJP to oppose religion-based reservation
The Hindu
Rahul Hard Sells Reservation For Minorities In UP
India TV News
Mayawati Favours Reservation For Muslims
India TV News
BJP opposes caste-based reservation for minorities
The Hindu
A reservation row
The HinduDiscover Related









































