
Lender Banks Required To Provide Audit Reports To Borrowers & Allow Representation Before Classifying Accounts As Fraud: Gujarat High Court
Live LawThe Gujarat High Court while partly allowing a special civil application has emphasized the importance of lender banks affording borrowers the opportunity to review audit reports and present their case before categorizing an account as fraudulent. During meetings held on 18.08.2020 and 29.09.2020, discussions were held regarding forensic audit reports dated 11.08.2020 and 18.09.2020, along with various related issues, including the South Indian Bank's declaration of fraud concerning the company's account. It was also held and observed that therefore, principles of natural justice demand that the borrowers must be served a notice, given an opportunity to explain the findings in the forensic audit report, and to represent before the account is classified as fraud under the Master Directions on Frauds. The Apex Court has also directed that consistent with the principles of natural justice, the lender banks should provide an opportunity to a borrower by furnishing a copy of the audit reports and allow the borrower a reasonable opportunity to submit a representation before classifying the account as fraud coupled with passing of a reasoned order on the objections addressed by the borrower.” “Undisputedly, in the present case, no such steps have been taken by the respondent lender banks and therefore, on this limited ground of violation of principles of natural justice, the decision of the respondent banks declaring the account of the company as fraud is hereby quashed and set aside,” the Court further observed.
History of this topic

Bombay High Court slams banks casual take on declaring accounts fraud, asks Anil Ambani to approach RBI
The Hindu
Bombay HC Directs Anil Ambani to Approach RBI in Loan Fraud Classification Case
Deccan Chronicle
Bombay High Court Flags 'Cut Copy Paste' Orders Being Passed By Banks To Declare Fraud Accounts; Asks Anil Ambani To Approach RBI
Live Law
Relief to Anil Ambani in Canara Bank account case; High Court issues notice to RBI
India Today
Relief For Anil Ambani As Bombay High Court Stays Canara Bank's Order Classifying Reliance Comm Loan Account As 'Fraud'
Live Law
FIR Not Invalidated By Quashing Fraud Classification Of Bank Account If It Prima Facie Discloses Cognizable Offences: Delhi HC
Live Law
Legal audits hold the key to address loan write-offs by Indian banks
Live Mint
Bank fraud allegations must never be levelled lightly
Live Mint
RBI asks lenders to hear out loan defaulters before tagging accounts as ‘fraud’; check revised norms
Live Mint
Banks must hear out loan defaulters before declaring accounts 'fraud': RBI
Hindustan Times
RBI alarmed at lakhs of bank accounts being used for fraud: Report
Live Mint![[IBC] Party Must Be Provided With All Requisite Documents That Form Basis Of Show Cause Notice: Delhi High Court](/static/images/error.jpg)
[IBC] Party Must Be Provided With All Requisite Documents That Form Basis Of Show Cause Notice: Delhi High Court
Live Law
Two private firms, its directors booked for duping bank of ₹16.85 crore
Hindustan Times
Bombay HC stays RBI circular allowing banks to declare fraud accounts without hearing
India Today
Never Said Borrowers Should Be Personally Heard Before Their Accounts Are Classified As Fraud : Supreme Court
Live Law
Banks Must Give Opportunity Of Hearing To Borrowers Before Classifying Their Accounts As Fraud : Supreme Court
Live Law
CBI searches five locations in bank fraud case against Delhi company
India TV News
Auditors must report to RBI on deviations in regulated entities: Shaktikanta Das
The Hindu
After Union Bank, IOB, Delhi HC Directs SBI, RBI To Maintain Status Quo On Classification Of Anil Ambani's RComm, Reliance Telecom Accounts
Live Law
Half-Hearted Approach By CBI Towards Investigating Bank Officials: Special CBI Court Ghaziabad Orders Further Investigation
Live Law
ED attaches assets of frauds accused in Rs 2,066 crore money laundering scam
India Today
PNB classifies its loan exposure to Reliance Home Finance as fraud
Live Mint
RBI affidavit details how it was ’cheated’ by scam-hit PMC Bank
Live Mint
Delhi court summons 11 top PNB officials for violation of banking regulations, criminal conspiracy
India TV News
ICICI Bank to hire forensic auditor to probe allegations of irregularities into 31 loan accounts
Firstpost
How do bank frauds happen? Central Vigilance Commission has the answers
Live Mint
Opinion | The anatomy of banking frauds
Live Mint
Central Vigilance Commission reviews top 100 bank frauds till 2017; Check details
ABP News
PNB fraud: Hong Kong banking regulator cracks down on Indian lenders operating in the SAR over suspected irregularities
Firstpost
Bank frauds and wilful default: Gunning for ‘innocent’ managers is inevitable, but witch-hunting must be avoided
Firstpost
Fraud-hit Punjab National Bank to hire detectives to hunt down untraceable borrowers; invites applications from agencies
Firstpost
PNB fraud case: RBI says examining enforcement action
Live Mint
Loan fraud case: CBI books, raids Totem Infrastructure Limited
Deccan Chronicle
PNB fraud fallout: RBI starts special audit of public sector banks
India TV News
PNB fraud: RBI starts special audit of public sector banks, asks details of LoUs
Firstpost
PNB fraud: RBI initiates special audit of PSBs with focus on trade finance
ABP News
PNB scam fallout: Probe NPAs above Rs 50 cr, report fraud to CBI, finance ministry directs PSBs
Firstpost
Bank frauds: Gujarat model's underbelly
Deccan Chronicle
Bank scams: Three fresh cases of financial fraud reported
India TV News
PNB Rs 11,400 cr fraud case: Finance Minister Arun Jaitley slams regulators' failure to detect scam
Firstpost
Auditor group ICAI, PwC to probe into Rs11,400 crore PNB fraud
Live Mint
How banking frauds can be nipped in the bud
Live Mint
PNB fraud might impact Narendra Modi govt's ease of doing business initiative: PHD Chamber
Firstpost
PNB-Nirav Modi bank scam: Both internal, external auditors failed to detect fraud, CA professionals must introspect, says Arun Jaitley
India TV News
PNB fraud: Finance Ministry writes to RBI, seeks view on lapses
India TV News
Punjab National Bank scam: RBI data revealed through RTI shows India's fraud problems extend far beyond PNB
Firstpost
Punjab National Bank alerts other lenders about perpetrators’ modus operandi
The Hindu
Government admits to cases of fraudulent withdrawal of money through Adhaar
The Quint
CVC seeks data on fraud from banks
ABP NewsDiscover Related














































