
The strange case of Uniform Civil Code: How lack of political will has reduced it to a mere soundbite
FirstpostThe idea of a Uniform Civil Code has foundered not so much because of Muslim obstinacy, though that has been a factor, but because of a lack of political will at the Centre under successive regimes of different hues On the face of it, the renewed debate on the need for a Uniform Civil Code to replace the existing myriad family laws has all the feel of an unrelenting Groundhog Day when the same events appear to recur in exactly the same way day after day. In its report, the 21st Law Commission said: “In the absence of any consensus on a uniform civil code, the commission felt that the best way forward may be to preserve the diversity of personal laws but, at the same time, ensure that personal laws do not contradict fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution of India.” Nothing has changed since that report came in 2018 to warrant another review by the present Law Commission raising questions whether it’s really an attempt to push the issue in the long grass. Article 44 of the Constitution pointedly entrusts the Central government with the task of securing a uniform civil code “throughout the territory of India”, not local laws. “A state-level uniform civil code seems to be prima facie incompatible with Article 44 of the Constitution which proclaims that the ‘State shall endeavour to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India.’ The all-India extent of the proposed code inherent in this phraseology is too conspicuous to be overlooked,” says Dr Tahir Mahmood, former Chair, National Minorities Commission and Member, Law Commission of India. Together, they were meant to form the basis of a Uniform Civil Code with the then law minister CC Biswas hailing it as a “first step towards a uniform civil code”.
History of this topic

State-wise common civil codes contradict the idea of UCC
Hindustan Times
False complaints under Uttarakhand Uniform Civil Code to incur Rs 10,000 fine
India Today
Pleas Challenging Uttarakhand's Uniform Civil Code: High Court Issues Notices To State Govt, UOI
Live Law
Shatrughan Sinha wants ban on non-veg food, praises civil code in Uttarakhand
India Today
Gujarat announces 5-member panel headed by ex-SC judge to prepare Uniform Civil Code draft
Hindustan Times
Uniform Civil Code in Gujarat soon as state forms panel to prepare draft
India Today
Uniform Civil Code cannot be implemented across India: DK Shivakumar
India Today
Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar advocates Uniform Civil Code, highlights national challenges
New Indian Express
Uttarakhand Becomes First State To Implement Uniform Civil Code
ABP News
Uttarakhand UCC nothing but kickstarting a pilot project without proper consensus: Congress
The Hindu
Uniform Civil Code to be implemented today in Uttarakhand: All we know so far
Hindustan Times
India’s BJP-ruled Uttarakhand implements ‘totally biased’ common civil code
Al Jazeera
What is Uniform Civil Code? Here's all you need to know
India Today
Uniform Civil Code to be implemented in Uttarakhand on January 27, says CM's aide
Hindustan Times
Uttarakhand to implement Uniform Civil Code on January 27
Live Mint
Uttarakhand government notifies Uniform Civil Code, becomes the first state in India to do so
Op India
UCC manual gets Uttarakhand Cabinet approval, CM Pushkar Singh Dhami promises implementation soon
India TV News
‘One Nation, One Election is practical, will not harm federal structure': Law minister Arjun Meghwal
Hindustan Times
Uttarakhand to implement Uniform Civil Code from January 2025; ‘homework’ complete, says CM Pushkar Singh Dhami
Live Mint
Uniform Civil Code To Be Implemented In Uttarakhand From January 2025, Says CM Dhami
ABP News
Uniform Civil Code to be implemented in Uttarakhand from Jan 2025: Pushkar Dhami
India Today
Constituent Assembly wanted Uniform Civil Code to be implemented: PM Modi in Lok Sabha
Hindustan Times
UCC's aim to promote harmony, secularism: Allahabad HC Judge
Deccan Chronicle
Uttarakhand CM Pushkar Singh Dhami reiterates Uniform Civil Code to be implemented by Nov 9
Hindustan Times
Uniform civil code not acceptable, says All India Muslim Personal Law Board
Hindustan Times
We should realise need for Uniform Civil Code, says MP High Court
The Hindu
Uniform Civil Code Could Be Driven By States, Not Centre, Hint BJP Sources
News 18
Union Law Minister Meghwal says Uniform Civil Code is part of the government’s agenda
The Hindu
Amit Shah makes big promise on Uniform Civil Code, One Nation, One Election
Hindustan Times
Decoding the Codes: Why Does India Have More Than One Civil Code?
The Diplomat
'Goa has UCC. Do they all wear same clothes?' PM scoffs at Opposition charge
India Today
Implementation of Uniform Civil Code is PM Modi's guarantee: Amit Shah
The Hindu
Implementation Of Uniform Civil Code In Country Is PM Modi's Guarantee, Says Amit Shah
News 18
Will Completely Overhaul Commercial & Civil Justice Systems, Bring UCC : BJP In Election Manifesto
Live Law
BJP promises Uniform Civil Code in its ‘Sankalp Patra’ for Lok Sabha Polls: ‘Country waits…,’ says PM Modi
Live Mint
India’s Uttarakhand State Legislature Passes Uniform Civil Code Bill
The Diplomat
Uttarakhand Moves Closer Towards UCC Law, Governor Sends Bill to President Murmu for Final Nod
News 18
Uttarakhand Uniform Civil Code: Testing the waters?
The Hindu
India’s first Uniform Civil Code gets nod in U’khand house
Hindustan Times
Uniform Civil Code (UCC) Bill passed by the Uttarakhand assembly
Op India
Uniform Civil Code bill passed in Uttarakhand assembly
Hindustan Times
Asaduddin Owaisi slams Uniform Civil Code, says ‘Hindus, tribals kept out’
Hindustan Times
Uttarakhand Assembly passes Uniform Civil Code Bill
India Today
Jamiat calls Uttarakhand UCC move ‘discriminatory’
The Hindu
Uttarakhand 1st state to bring uniform code bill
Hindustan Times
‘Not against Uniform Civil Code but...': Cong on UCC debut in Uttarakhand assembly
Hindustan Times
Uniform Civil Code Bill to be tabled in Uttarakhand assembly today
Live Mint
'UCC will be implemented in Rajasthan too': Cabinet Minister Kanhaiya Lal Choudhary's big statement
India TV News
Will a Uniform Civil Code be divisive?
India Today
Uniform Civil Code in India: Understanding its need and significance in present day
India TV NewsDiscover Related






















