CAA-NRC combo is not discriminatory against Indian Muslims
Op IndiaThe most recent criticism in regard to the Citizenship Amendment Act enacted by both Houses of Parliament is that it isn’t the CAA that is the problem. Members of six religions, that is Christians, Buddhists, Parsis, Jains, Sikhs and Hindus fleeing three countries, Pakistan, Afghanistan and Bangladesh can apply for Indian citizenship if they can demonstrate a physical presence in India of five years as opposed to the regular eleven years mentioned in the Citizenship Act, 1955. Illustration deployed by critics The illustration deployed by critics, quite simply, is this: If the NRC is implemented inefficiently and results in a situation where two Indian citizens – a Hindu and a Muslim – are determined as ‘non-Indians’ due to lack of documentation, the Hindu could still save himself from harassment by entering the CAA Pool. In fact, Amit Shah himself suggested that the Assam NRC has demonstrated shortcomings which will guide the Modi government in formulating the nationwide NRC procedure.