Accusing Judge As Corrupt In Open Court, Does It Not Lower Image Of Judiciary?
Recently, I went through a judgment delivered by the Bombay High Court in the matter of S.B. Patil, 7th Joint Civil Judge, Senior Division and Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thane, had made a reference to the High Court under the provisions of Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, stating that one Manubhai Patel i.e. Upon this, the judge issued a notice to him calling upon him to show cause as to “why reference under the provisions of Contempt of Courts Act should not be made to the High Court.” Thereafter, the said Manubhai Patel filed another application making scandalous and wild allegations against the Judge about demand of illegal gratification. The High Court came to the conclusion that the said Manubhai Patel “has made personal allegations against the judicial officer due to the time consumed in the litigation and we find that though the Judicial Officer might be justified in adjourning the matter, however it seems that the litigant got disturbed due to the delay and the time consumed in the litigation, and hence he made personal allegations against the referral Judge of seeking illegal gratification for hearing the matter”.. 2 The High Court further observed that “considering that these are the personal remarks made against the concerned Judge, and it do not amount to 'causing interference', in the administration of justice or lowering the authority of the Court and it does not attract Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act. The High Court further observed that 'though the Judicial Officer might be justified in adjourning the matter it seems that the litigant got disturbed due to the delay and the time consumed in the litigation, and hence he made personal allegations against the referral Judge of seeking illegal gratification for hearing the matter'.










Despite SC intervention, huge pendency still bogs down India's lower judiciary












Discover Related

Manish Tewari | The golden mean of judicial oversight

'Unacceptable': Allahabad High Court Bar Association (HCBA) Condemns 'Clandestine' Swearing-In Of Justice Yashwant Varma

Justice Yashwant Varma Takes Oath As Judge Of Allahabad High Court Amidst In-House Inquiry Over Cash Row
![Madras High Court Monthly Digest - March 2025 [Citations 81-122]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Madras High Court Monthly Digest - March 2025 [Citations 81-122]

Supreme Court orders mandatory disclosure of criminal history in bail petitions

High Court judge to probe allegation of sexual misconduct of district judge

Court pulls up CBI for ‘fabricating evidence’ in justice Yadav case

Supreme Court calls for ‘zero tolerance’ on abuse of power by police forces

‘Trying times’: Delhi HC judge transferred to Allahabad court

Court adjourns hearing on NCP MLA Chhagan Bhujbal's release in corruption case

Lawyers bodies to abstain from swearing-in of Justice Sharma at Calcutta HC, may not attend his court

Judging not mechanical task, demands empathy, wisdom: Delhi HC Justice C D Singh

Supreme Court dismisses challenge to Allahabad high court’s Sambhal mosque order

Shikha Mukerjee | Norms for judges: Revise or shred, choice is open

Calcutta HC lawyers may stop work to protest Delhi HC judge’s transfer

Chandigarh: Former HC judge Nirmal Yadav acquitted in cash-at-judge’s door case

Justice Varma and the Burnt Cash Scandal Puts Judicial Integrity in Question

SC sets up fact-finding panel to probe Patiala MC poll ‘violations’

Allahabad Bar Association to boycott Justice Yashwant Varma's swearing-in

Telangana High Court slams magistrate, officer for wrong remand

The judiciary’s ‘between a rock and hard place’ moment
