Apple, Facebook and Your Privacy: What the Upcoming iOS 14 Privacy Setting Actually Is
4 years, 3 months ago

Apple, Facebook and Your Privacy: What the Upcoming iOS 14 Privacy Setting Actually Is

News 18  

Facebook is clearly rather unhappy with Apple’s upcoming iOS 14 update. In an indirect response to Facebook’s two newspaper ads trying to raise word against Apple’s move, CEO Tim Cook posted about this on Twitter earlier today. Facebook can continue to track users across apps and websites as before, App Tracking Transparency in iOS 14 will just require that they ask for your permission first.” Apple’s move, in essence, hands the power back to users to entirely refuse to have their activity tracked across the internet. Facebook can continue to track users across apps and websites as before, App Tracking Transparency in iOS 14 will just require that they ask for your permission first.

Privacy Internet Apple Ads Content Update Ios Facebook Upcoming Websites Setting Actually  ios  apple  update  facebook  content  ads  users  upcoming  websites  privacy  apples  setting  actually  internet  14

History of this topic

Facebook will enable more private settings by default for teens
2 years, 4 months ago

Facebook will enable more private settings by default for teens

Deccan Chronicle  

Washington: Social media giant Facebook has announced that for anyone under the age of 16 who signs up for the platform, they will be enabling more private settings by default. According to The Verge, for teens who already have a Facebook account, the platform will display a prompt encouraging them to use these settings, as well as a toggle that …

Meta announces new privacy policy for Facebook, Instagram, Messenger
2 years, 10 months ago

Meta announces new privacy policy for Facebook, Instagram, Messenger

The Hindu  

Meta, a California-based tech firm that owns social media platforms Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, said it has ‘rewritten and redesigned’ its privacy policy to make it ‘easier to understand’ and also to ‘make it clearer’ to users how it used or shared their information. The updated Meta Privacy Policy that would kick in from July 26 would cover Facebook, Instagram, …

Facebook And YouTube Have Lost Billions Of Dollars Due To Apple's Privacy Features
2 years, 11 months ago

Facebook And YouTube Have Lost Billions Of Dollars Due To Apple's Privacy Features

News 18  

Apple last year launched its app tracking transparency feature that gives users the option of not letting apps track their behaviour. The App Tracking Transparency feature came with iOS 14.5 to stop developers from tracking users across websites and other apps. According to a report in Lotame, Apple?s App Tracking Transparency feature could cost big companies $16 billion. Apple?s App …

iPhone users not very interested in upgrading to iOS 15, shows installation data
3 years, 6 months ago

iPhone users not very interested in upgrading to iOS 15, shows installation data

India Today  

Apple rolled out iOS 15 earlier this week to a wide range of iPhones, but it seems people are not very interested in the new software version. According to a new report, the adoption of iOS 15 is breaking away from the past trends when Apple saw record installation numbers for its new iOS versions. However, it does give a …

Facebook’s controversial encryption plans ‘won’t give users real privacy’
3 years, 6 months ago

Facebook’s controversial encryption plans ‘won’t give users real privacy’

The Telegraph  

Facebook’s controversial encryption plans ‘won’t give users real privacy’, MPs have been told as they were warned it will ‘cripple’ child abuse blocking software. The social media giant is facing mounting criticism over encryption plans that will make it harder to detect terrorist activity and child abuse material, with the Home Secretary condemning the proposals earlier this year as ‘dangerous …

Facebook’s WhatsApp takes aim at Apple over child safety software plan
3 years, 7 months ago

Facebook’s WhatsApp takes aim at Apple over child safety software plan

Live Mint  

Facebook Inc.’s WhatsApp messaging unit blasted Apple Inc.’s plan to monitor sexually exploitative images of children on iPhones as bad for privacy, opening a new front in the battle between two of the world’s biggest tech companies. Apple’s decision may set the stage for governments to push technology companies for access to more private information—something, Mr. Cathcart said in an …

Apple focus on app tracking transparency drives advertisers to spend more on Android
3 years, 8 months ago

Apple focus on app tracking transparency drives advertisers to spend more on Android

India Today  

Apple started rolling out its new App Tracking Transparency rules with iOS 14.5 for enhanced user privacy. Wall Street Journal quoted figures from ad analytics firm Tenjin noting that spending on iOS ad platforms dropped by approximately one-third between June and July and the advertising Android platforms increased by approximately 10 per cent at that time. Tinuiti research director Andy …

How Apple screwed Facebook
3 years, 10 months ago

How Apple screwed Facebook

Wired  

It is not unusual for the bosses of Apple and Facebook to be at loggerheads with each other over privacy. Back in 2018 Facebook chief executive Mark Zuckerberg accused his Apple counterpart Tim Cook of being “extremely glib” for making scathing remarks about Facebook’s involvement in the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Weeks later Apple introduced privacy controls that hampered Facebook’s ability …

Facebook Wants Your 'Help' to Keep it Free, But Can You Trust it With Your Data?
3 years, 10 months ago

Facebook Wants Your 'Help' to Keep it Free, But Can You Trust it With Your Data?

News 18  

Remember the good old days, when Facebook was all about creating the fanciest virtual farmland or being the baddest e-mafia you could be? Here’s where things get even better – explaining how they use the data that is received from users, Facebook states that letting them track you would help show you personalised As Zuckerberg deflected questions and scored a …

Apple vs Facebook: 96 Percent Users Disabling App Tracking So Far, Claims Report
3 years, 10 months ago

Apple vs Facebook: 96 Percent Users Disabling App Tracking So Far, Claims Report

News 18  

When Apple first announced the App Tracking Transparency feature, the move was largely appreciated by the privacy community – and not quite so by Facebook. Now, a brief while after the release of iOS 14.5, bringing ATT to iOS devices, a report by Flurry Analytics states that up to 96 percent of all users are already disabling app tracking on …

Signal Fires Straight At Facebook: They Aren’t Building Technology For You, It’s For Your Data
3 years, 10 months ago

Signal Fires Straight At Facebook: They Aren’t Building Technology For You, It’s For Your Data

News 18  

Signal is having a brilliant 2021. Signal believes that Facebook’s own tools can often reveal the truth about the “dimly concealed within complex, opaquely-rendered systems and fine print designed to be scrolled past.” Signal says they bought some Instagram ads and created multi-variant targeted ad designed to show users the personal data that Facebook collects about and sells access to. …

Don’t Buy Into Facebook’s Ad-Tracking Pressure on iOS 14.5
55 years, 2 months ago

Don’t Buy Into Facebook’s Ad-Tracking Pressure on iOS 14.5

Wired  

Last week, Apple released iOS 14.5, and with it a new feature that sent online advertisers scrambling: For the first time, users can tell apps not to track their activity across different sites and services. But the iOS 14.5 notice also frames the issue in a way that implies Facebook can't make money if it foregoes this kind of tracking, …

Why Facebook pop-up notification asking iOS 14.5 users to allow tracking to keep it free of charge is scary
3 years, 10 months ago

Why Facebook pop-up notification asking iOS 14.5 users to allow tracking to keep it free of charge is scary

India Today  

Apple introduced its newest privacy feature called App Tracking Transparency to iPhones and iPads with the iOS 14.5 update late last week. Facebook and Instagram have started showing prompts to iOS users who recently updated to iOS 14.5 with a notice on screen with a plea highlighting that surveilling users helps keep these services free. In a similar worded prompt, …

Facebook shows notices in iOS apps to sell you on app tracking as it helps keep it free of charge
3 years, 10 months ago

Facebook shows notices in iOS apps to sell you on app tracking as it helps keep it free of charge

India Today  

Apple’s controversial App Tracking Transparency has finally rolled out to several iPhone users with the iOS 14.5 update. Facebook is adding a popup within its iOS app to urge users to allow tracking because that “helps keep Facebook free of charge.” The new popup windows emerge randomly inside the Facebook and Instagram apps on the iPhone. “We use information about …

iOS 14.5 Is Here For Your Apple iPhone, The Update That Facebook Was Very Worried About
3 years, 11 months ago

iOS 14.5 Is Here For Your Apple iPhone, The Update That Facebook Was Very Worried About

News 18  

The Apple iOS 14.5 update is now rolling out for the Apple iPhone and the iPadOS 14.5 is also now available for the Apple iPad. More than any new features available for your Apple iPhone, including allowing unlocking your iPhone with the Apple Watch when wearing a mask, it is the new privacy feature called the App Tracking Transparency feature …

Apple's top executive Craig Federighi explains iOS 14.5 new privacy feature that is a headache for Facebook
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple's top executive Craig Federighi explains iOS 14.5 new privacy feature that is a headache for Facebook

India Today  

With iOS 14.5 now out, Apple has brought back the talks about user privacy right to the centre. Apple has introduced App Tracking Transparency with the new iPhone update and it targets not just your privacy but also the ad revenue of some of the biggest companies. Joanna Stern of The Wall Street Journal sat down with Federighi, who sits …

Apple’s iPhone privacy clampdown arrives after 7-month delay
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple’s iPhone privacy clampdown arrives after 7-month delay

Associated Press  

SAN RAMON, Calif. — Apple is following through on its pledge to crack down on Facebook and other snoopy apps that secretly shadow people on their iPhones in order to target more advertising at users. “What are the consequences of seeing thousands of users join extremist groups and then perpetuating an algorithm that recommends more?” It’s part of Apple’s attempt …

iOS 14.5: Why Apple’s new iPhone update is proving so controversial and has put it in a fight with Facebook
3 years, 11 months ago

iOS 14.5: Why Apple’s new iPhone update is proving so controversial and has put it in a fight with Facebook

The Independent  

Sign up to our free weekly IndyTech newsletter delivered straight to your inbox Sign up to our free IndyTech newsletter Sign up to our free IndyTech newsletter SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy Apple might be about to launch one of the most controversial features ever …

Apple and Facebook face off over iPhone privacy update
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple and Facebook face off over iPhone privacy update

LA Times  

A new privacy feature, dubbed “App Tracking Transparency,” will allow iPhone users to decide if they want apps such as Facebook to be able to track their usage in other apps. “What are the consequences of seeing thousands of users join extremist groups and then perpetuating an algorithm that recommends more?” It’s part of Apple’s attempt to use the privacy …

What do Apple’s new privacy settings mean for you?
3 years, 11 months ago

What do Apple’s new privacy settings mean for you?

Al Jazeera  

The change will mean a new pop-up notification in some apps seeking permission to collect data that Apple believes could be used to track people’s browsing habits across third-party apps. For Apple’s more than one billion iPhone users, the change will mean a new pop-up notification in some apps seeking their permission to collect data that Apple believes could be …

Apple Rolls Out Major New Privacy Protections For iPhones And iPads
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple Rolls Out Major New Privacy Protections For iPhones And iPads

NPR  

Apple Rolls Out Major New Privacy Protections For iPhones And iPads Enlarge this image toggle caption Apple Apple Editor's note: Apple and Facebook are among NPR's financial supporters. He and economist Julian Runge say Apple's new framework, called AppTrackingTransparency, "may be the most economically impactful and brazen change to privacy policy in years." "It's possible that we may even be …

Facebook Tweaks Ad Tools to Comply with Apple's Upcoming Privacy Changes
3 years, 11 months ago

Facebook Tweaks Ad Tools to Comply with Apple's Upcoming Privacy Changes

News 18  

Facebook said on Wednesday it is making changes to its advertising tools to comply with an upcoming privacy update by Apple, limiting the effectiveness of data collection features used by advertisers. The world’s biggest social media company has been at loggerheads with Apple’s ‘App Tracking Transparency’ feature, expected to kick in with the latest iPhone software update next week, which …

Facebook tweaks ad tools ahead of Apple's privacy changes
3 years, 11 months ago

Facebook tweaks ad tools ahead of Apple's privacy changes

The Hindu  

Facebook Inc on Wednesday said it has made changes to its advertising tools, a week ahead of Apple’s iOS 14.5 software update. The world’s largest social network and the second-largest seller of online ads is feuding with Apple over the iPhone maker's App-Tracking Transparency feature, which will prohibit collection of certain data from apps unless users opt in. Apple says …

Apple is quietly updating its iPhone software next week. iOS 14.5 is tipped to cost Facebook big bucks
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple is quietly updating its iPhone software next week. iOS 14.5 is tipped to cost Facebook big bucks

ABC  

Apple held a virtual event overnight to spruik the company's new products, quietly slipping in a notice about a software update due to roll out next week. The iOS 14.5 update includes a range of software tweaks, but the biggest change is a new privacy feature that could cost companies like Facebook. Apps forced to ask for data The App …

Apple unveils new products, schedules privacy crackdown
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple unveils new products, schedules privacy crackdown

Associated Press  

SAN RAMON, Calif. — Apple spruced up its product line at an event Tuesday while slipping in quiet notice of a software update, now due next week, designed to enhance the privacy of iPhone users at the expense of digital advertisers such as Facebook. Apple also unveiled a new subscription option for podcasts and a gadget called AirTags — coin-sized …

Apple Says What Facebook Needed To Hear Again: “We Are Not Against Digital Advertising”
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple Says What Facebook Needed To Hear Again: “We Are Not Against Digital Advertising”

News 18  

The Apple iOS 14.5 update for your iPhone is expected to roll out anytime now, and the one standout feature among all that is new would be the much-awaited App Tracking Transparency feature. Your bank records, your health records, your conversations with friends and family, business colleagues — all of this information is on your phone,” before adding, “And so …

Apple iOS 14.5 Lands On Your iPhone Soon And You Can Choose To End A Free Run Of Apps Tracking You
3 years, 11 months ago

Apple iOS 14.5 Lands On Your iPhone Soon And You Can Choose To End A Free Run Of Apps Tracking You

News 18  

Apple iOS 14.5 could be landing anytime now. More than any new goodies that the latest iOS update may bring to your Apple iPhone, it is the new privacy feature called the App Tracking Transparency feature which you should be looking out for. This is designed to put an end to apps on your iPhone tracking your data and usage …

iOS 15 release soon: Features, release date, compatible iPhones and everything we know so far
4 years ago

iOS 15 release soon: Features, release date, compatible iPhones and everything we know so far

India Today  

iOS 14 was released back in September 2020 ahead of the iPhone 12 series launch. That being said, let’s find out about the expected features, rumours, release date and everything else that we know so far about the iOS 15. iOS 15 expected features --The beta update of iOS 14.5 allows Apple Watch owners to unlock their iPhone by using …

Facebook is on the offensive against Apple's upcoming data privacy update
4 years, 1 month ago

Facebook is on the offensive against Apple's upcoming data privacy update

India Today  

Two of Silicon Valley’s largest tech giants, Apple and Facebook, are in a bitter fight that revolves around the iPhone data of millions of people and whether tech companies should be able to track that data as easily as they do now without people’s consent. Various types of data collected from users are used by companies like Facebook to personalise …

Apple Beefs Up Its Fraudulent Website Warning With iOS 14.5 With an Added Layer of Privacy
4 years, 1 month ago

Apple Beefs Up Its Fraudulent Website Warning With iOS 14.5 With an Added Layer of Privacy

News 18  

Apple has a feature that alerts users when they?re about to visit a website that is known to host malware, or is believed to be a phishing site. The report cites Apple as saying that before visiting a website, Safari may send hashed prefixes of the URL to Google Safe Browsing to check if there’s a match. ?Up until iOS …

Facebook Wants Users To Love Personalized Adverts As The Privacy Battle Against Apple Rages On
4 years, 1 month ago

Facebook Wants Users To Love Personalized Adverts As The Privacy Battle Against Apple Rages On

News 18  

Facebook has made its reservations about the new incoming data privacy measures for Apple iPhones, known quite vocally. With iOS 14.5 for the iPhones, Apple will be implementing a new privacy tool that will generate a pop-up which will ask users whether they want the Facebook app on their iPhones to track their usage activities across other apps and websites. …

Facebook app will soon show prompt to iPhone, iPad users encouraging opt-in for ad tracking
4 years, 1 month ago

Facebook app will soon show prompt to iPhone, iPad users encouraging opt-in for ad tracking

Firstpost  

Facebook is testing a new full-screen prompt feature for iPhone users, which will remind users about the social network’s data collection. In the upcoming the iOS 14 update, app developers like Facebook will be required to show users pop-up asking permission to track the user data across websites and apps. In case users opt to reject the request, it would …

Facebook now asking Apple users to accept device tracking: Here's why
4 years, 1 month ago

Facebook now asking Apple users to accept device tracking: Here's why

India TV News  

The Facebook-Apple war over privacy changes in iOS 14 has been going on for quite some time now. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg has argued that iOS 14 privacy changes will impact the growth of millions of businesses around the world. The upcoming privacy changes in Apple iOS 14 updates will inform users about tracking by third-party advertisers and ask them …

Facebook to prompt users about personalised ads ahead of Apple privacy changes
4 years, 1 month ago

Facebook to prompt users about personalised ads ahead of Apple privacy changes

The Hindu  

Facebook Inc said in a blog post Monday it will begin rolling out a notification for iPhone users globally about how data is used for personalised ads, in an attempt to get ahead of upcoming Apple Inc privacy changes that Facebook says will hurt its advertising business. The full-screen prompt will ask Facebook and Instagram users to allow their app …

Facebook and Apple Are Beefing Over the Future of the Internet
55 years, 2 months ago

Facebook and Apple Are Beefing Over the Future of the Internet

Wired  

Last July, Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, along with the heads of Google, Amazon, and Apple, spent a long day fielding heated questions from members of the House Antitrust Subcommittee. On Thursday morning, Apple CEO Tim Cook gave a speech explaining his company’s upcoming privacy changes, which will ban apps from sharing iPhone user behavior with third parties unless users give …

Apple CEO escalates battle with Facebook over online privacy
4 years, 2 months ago

Apple CEO escalates battle with Facebook over online privacy

Associated Press  

SAN RAMON, Calif. — Apple CEO Tim Cook fired off a series of thinly veiled shots at Facebook and other social media companies Thursday, escalating an online privacy battle pitting the iPhone maker against digital services that depend on tracking people to help sell ads. What are the consequences of seeing thousands of users join extremist groups and then perpetuating …

Amid WhatsApp Privacy Row and iOS 14 Security Prompt, Facebook Revamps 'Access Your Info' Tool
4 years, 2 months ago

Amid WhatsApp Privacy Row and iOS 14 Security Prompt, Facebook Revamps 'Access Your Info' Tool

News 18  

The Facebook group is hardly a stranger to persistent issues of privacy. After launching in 2018 in the aftermath of the Cambridge Analytics data scandal involving almost 87 million users, Facebook initially set up its user information access tool with two categories – Your Information, and Information About You. While the new Access Your Information interface is indeed easier to …

Apple's Privacy-Focused Prompt Starts Appearing for Some iOS 14 Users, Expected to Launch Early 2021
4 years, 3 months ago

Apple's Privacy-Focused Prompt Starts Appearing for Some iOS 14 Users, Expected to Launch Early 2021

News 18  

Apple?s major upcoming privacy feature that aims to provide users with more control over their data has started appearing with the latest version iOS 14.4 beta. The stable version of iOS 14.4 is slated to release by February next, and regular iPhone and iPad users may start seeing the privacy prompt around the same time, as well. Meanwhile, it has …

Apple's iOS 14 privacy prompts now rolling out in India, here is what it means for you
4 years, 3 months ago

Apple's iOS 14 privacy prompts now rolling out in India, here is what it means for you

India Today  

Apple is supposed to introduce privacy labels that need user permission on iOS 14.4 sometime in January or February but it looks like things are moving ahead of the schedule. I found an out-of-the-blue privacy prompt when I opened the Ajio online shopping app on my iPhone that is currently on iOS 14.3. This is a laughable attempt from Facebook …

Facebook's fight against iOS 14 privacy rules is laughable, distracting, says digital rights group
4 years, 3 months ago

Facebook's fight against iOS 14 privacy rules is laughable, distracting, says digital rights group

India Today  

Facebook is putting out all the stops to make sure Apple is compelled to abandon the new iOS 14 privacy rules. Now, a digital rights group has said that Facebook’s campaign against Apple is laughable and a ploy to distract users. The Electronic Frontier Foundation, better known as EFF, has said that Facebook’s criticisms against Apple are laughable while siding …

Facebook’s campaign against Apple is a ‘laughable’ distraction tactic, says privacy group
4 years, 3 months ago

Facebook’s campaign against Apple is a ‘laughable’ distraction tactic, says privacy group

The Independent  

Sign up to our free weekly IndyTech newsletter delivered straight to your inbox Sign up to our free IndyTech newsletter Sign up to our free IndyTech newsletter SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy The Electronic Frontier Foundation has called Facebook’s campaign against Apple “laughable”, as the …

Apple hits out against Facebook as fight between companies over privacy escalates
4 years, 3 months ago

Apple hits out against Facebook as fight between companies over privacy escalates

The Independent  

Sign up to our free weekly IndyTech newsletter delivered straight to your inbox Sign up to our free IndyTech newsletter Sign up to our free IndyTech newsletter SIGN UP I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our privacy policy Apple has hit out against Facebook after the social media company said it …

Apple's anti-app tracking policy is all about profit, not privacy, Facebook says
4 years, 3 months ago

Apple's anti-app tracking policy is all about profit, not privacy, Facebook says

The Hindu  

Facebook slammed Apple's new App Tracking Transparency policy for being more about the iPhone maker's own profit, and not privacy. "They’re creating a policy — enforced via iOS 14’s AppTrackingTransparency — that’s about profit, not privacy," said Dan Levy, VP Ads and Business Products, Facebook in a statement. Facebook says that Apple's new policy will force content creators to explore …

Facebook Accuses Apple of Anticompetitive Privacy Policy, Takes Out Full-Page Newspaper Ad
4 years, 3 months ago

Facebook Accuses Apple of Anticompetitive Privacy Policy, Takes Out Full-Page Newspaper Ad

News 18  

Facebook accused rival Apple of engaging in anticompetitive practices on Wednesday, firing another shot in a monthslong standoff between the two tech giants over Apple’s planned privacy changes for iOS14. In response, Apple said its new rules will not require Facebook to change its “approach to tracking users and creating targeted advertising” but instead requires Facebook to give users on …

Facebook criticises Apple privacy policy, says 'it limits business' ability to run personalised ads'
4 years, 3 months ago

Facebook criticises Apple privacy policy, says 'it limits business' ability to run personalised ads'

Firstpost  

Apple brushed aside Facebook’s attacks, saying that that it isn’t preventing people from being tracked if they so desire. Facebook is again pushing back on new Apple privacy rules for its mobile devices, this time saying in full-page newspaper ads that the social media giant is standing up for small businesses. In ads that ran in The New York Times, …

Facebook criticizes Apple privacy policy in newspaper ads
4 years, 3 months ago

Facebook criticizes Apple privacy policy in newspaper ads

Associated Press  

Facebook is again pushing back on new Apple privacy rules for its mobile devices, this time saying in full page newspaper ads that the social media giant is standing up for small businesses. In ads that ran in The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal and other national newspapers Wednesday, Facebook said Apple’s new rules “limit businesses’ ability to …

Head of Instagram says user privacy is important but business comes first
4 years, 3 months ago

Head of Instagram says user privacy is important but business comes first

India Today  

Apple’s plan to tighten privacy on its iPhone ecosystem next year is not going well with Facebook. Apple is bringing crucial privacy changes with iOS 14 and iPadOS 14 that will inform users and seek their approval for targeted advertising and data gathering, both of which lie at the core of Facebook’s advertising business. The entire debate over user privacy …

Facebook slams Apple for bringing transparency to ad tracking, says old way is good for business
4 years, 3 months ago

Facebook slams Apple for bringing transparency to ad tracking, says old way is good for business

India Today  

One of the biggest industries of our times, which is online advertising, is built on obfuscation. Facebook claims that the new iOS update would “limit businesses’ ability to run personalized ads and reach their customers effectively.” Apple has responded back by saying that it is not asking companies like Facebook to change its ad targeting practices. App Tracking Transparency in …

Apple’s app stores open new privacy window for customers
4 years, 3 months ago

Apple’s app stores open new privacy window for customers

Associated Press  

CUPERTINO, Calif. — Apple has begun spelling out what kinds of personal information is being collected by the digital services displayed in its app stores for iPhones and other products made by the trendsetting company. Starting Monday, the additional disclosures will begin to appear in apps made for iPads, Mac computers and Apple’s TV streaming device, as well as its …

Discover Related