
Bombay High Court Quashes Criminal Case Against Nestle India For Allegedly Making Maggi With 'Substandard Materials'
Live LawThe Nagpur bench of the Bombay High Court recently quashed a criminal case lodged against Nestle India for using "substandard" materials for producing "Maggi" and breaching the provisions of the Food Safety Standards Act. Single-judge Justice Urmila Joshi-Phalke noted that the Food Inspector at Nagpur sent the samples of Maggi seized on April 30, 2015, to a Referral Food Laboratory in Ghaziabad in Uttar Pradesh despite the same not being accredited by the National Accreditation Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories. The judge noted that in the instant case, an initial analysis report was submitted by the State Public Health Laboratory in Pune, concluding that the product conformed with the safety standards as mandated under the FSS Act and the Rules and Regulations, therein. The food inspector has not assigned any reason as to his dissatisfaction about the said analysis and forwarded the said samples to the Referral Food Laboratory, Ghaziabad in Uttar Pradesh and relied upon the report which is not accredited and recognized laboratory as provided under the Act and, therefore, no reliance can be placed on the said results," the court opined.
History of this topic

High Court quashes criminal case against Nestlé officials over Maggi noodles
India Today
FSS Act | Date of Offence Would Be When Food Analyst Report Is Received, Not When Sample Was Collected: Allahabad HC
Live Law
FDA seizes over ₹3.06 crore worth expired and substandard food in Navi Mumbai
Hindustan Times
MP High Court Refuses To Quash Summons Against CocaCola For Expired ‘Maaza’ In Restaurant, Says Manufacturer Should Recall Such Products
Live Law
Bombay High Court Seeks FDA's Stand After Two Of Three Laboratories Find Johnson & Johnson Baby Powder Complies With Statutory Requirement
Live Law
Only A Food Inspector Can Investigate A Commission Of Offence Related To Food Items As Per The FSS Act: Gauhati High Court
Live Law
Nestle 'unhealthy' food controversy: Looking back at the Maggi Noodles crisis in India
India Today![Test Reports Showed Lead Content Is Within Permissible Limit: Kerala HC Closes PIL Seeking Ban Of Maggi Noodles [Read Judgment]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Test Reports Showed Lead Content Is Within Permissible Limit: Kerala HC Closes PIL Seeking Ban Of Maggi Noodles [Read Judgment]
Live Law
Nestle welcomes SC order on govt’s Maggi case at NCDRC
Live Mint
Nestle again lands in a soup over Maggi noodles
Live Mint
Maggi Controversy: Is MSG in Your Food Safe to Consume?
The Quint
Nestle asked to pay fine, co says Maggi does not have 'ash content', noodles have always been safe
Firstpost
Maggi trouble in UP again, Rs 62 lakh fine after it fails laboratory test
Deccan Chronicle
Maggi fails lab test again, UP imposes Rs 45 lakh fine on Nestle India
India TV News
Maggi fails test again in UP, slapped Rs 45 lakh fine; Nestle alleges 'application of incorrect standards'
Firstpost
Maggi fails lab test in UP, Nestle India imposed fine of Rs45 lakh
Live Mint![SC Allows Nestle To Destroy 550 Tonnes Of Expired Maggi Stock [Read Order]](/static/images/error.jpg)
SC Allows Nestle To Destroy 550 Tonnes Of Expired Maggi Stock [Read Order]
Live Law
Supreme Court to hear plea to destroy 550 tonnes of Maggi on Sep 30
India TV News
Maggi effect: FSSAI plans on new regulations for quality standards of instant noodles
India TV News
SC says quality of Maggi needs more attention as youngsters consume it; Orders more Tests
Live Law
Maggi ban: SC seeks clarification from Mysore lab
The Hindu
Supreme Court for testing of Maggi at Mysore lab
The Hindu
Nestle India moves Supreme Court against NCDRC order on Maggi samples
India TV News
Maggi controversy: Supreme Court to hear FSSAI plea
India TV News
Food Regulator Challenges SC Order to Lift Ban On Maggi Noodles
The Quint
FSSAI moves SC against lifting of ban on Maggi noodles
The Hindu
Maharashtra may challenge lifting of ban on Maggi
India TV News
Maharashtra FDA finds 'misbranding' of noodles, pasta even as Nestlé says Maggi is safe
Firstpost
Maggi clears all tests
The Hindu
Nestle to start sale of Maggi this month
The Hindu
#MaggiComesBack: Nestle resumes output at 3 units, may restart sales next month
Firstpost
Maharashtra to move SC against HC order lifting ban on Maggi
India TV News
Karnataka, Gujarat lift ban on Maggi noodles after clean chit given by 3 govt-approved labs
Firstpost
Karnataka, Gujarat Lift Maggi Ban
The Quint
Maggi ban: Nestle questions consumer disputes commission's jurisdiction to try suit
Firstpost
Apex consumer court hearing on fresh Maggi tests next week
The Hindu
Maggi dispute: National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission admits Government’s 640 crore class action suit, directs Centre to test samples afresh by accredited labs
Live Law
NCDRC issues notice to Nestle over a Rs 640 cr suit, directs govt to test fresh samples
Firstpost
FSSAI chief defends Maggi ban, questions why Nestle destroyed stocks of noodles
Firstpost
Maggi mess led Nestle to rope in crisis managers
Business Standard![Bombay High Court quashes Maggi Ban order by FSSAI; orders Re-test [Read Jt]](/static/images/error.jpg)
Bombay High Court quashes Maggi Ban order by FSSAI; orders Re-test [Read Jt]
Live Law
Nestle shares climb nearly 3% as Bombay HC quashes Maggi ban
Firstpost
Will comply with court order to undertake fresh tests: Nestle
India TV News
Partial Relief for Nestle, Fresh Tests To Be Conducted on Maggi
The Quint
Bombay HC lifts ban on Maggi
The Hindu
Not 'taste bhi, health bhi': Govt files Rs 640 cr suit against Nestle over Maggi 'unfair trade practices'
Firstpost
Govt damage claim from Nestle India can go beyond Rs 640 cr
Firstpost
Government of India files class action suit against Nestle
Live Law
Government of India files class action suit against Nestle
Live LawDiscover Related









































